An analysis of data densities; SD v. SSD

SanDisk recently announced a 32GB SD card (pictured) at PMA08 that will retail for US$349 in April. That's a lot of meggers (as an old client used to say) in a tiny little chip.

SanDisk Ultra II SDHC 32GB High Performance Card
SanDisk recently announced a 32GB SD card (pictured) at PMA08 that will retail for US$349 in April. That's a lot of meggers (as an old client used to say) in a tiny little chip. So what does this new monster memory card mean for data densities in other memory form factors, like Solid State Drives (SSDs) for example?

A colleague (Shaun Redmond) breaks down the price:density ratio of the new SD card:

  1. The volume of an SD card (W x D x H; mm) is 24 x 32 x 2.1 = 1,612.8 cubic mm or 1.6128 cubic centimeters (cc). (Source: SD Card Association)
  2. The volume of 1.8-inch x 5mm thick HDD in the MacBook Air (W x D x H; mm) is 54 x 78.5 x 5 = 21,195 cubic mm = 21.195 cubic centimeters (cc). (Source: PhysOrg.com)
  3. The theoretical data density of a 1.8-inch, 5mm tall HDD/SDD is 21.195 cc divided by 1.6128 cc per SD card times 32GB per SD card or (21.195/1.6128) x 32 = 420+GB!

Shaun used gross volumes in his calculations that include packaging and connectors on the SD card. There may be some efficiencies when packaging the memory in to a larger package (i.e. fewer connectors, plastic skin, etc.). This should allow for an even larger memory package than the 420GB calculated. However there may be a need for additional memory controllers to address the large array of memory modules within a larger 1.8-inch package.

So, what would this new 420GB 1.8-inch SSD cost? (21.195/1.6128) x US$349 = US$4,586.47 based on current retail cost of the new 32GB SD card.

Using the math above, the current 64GB SDD option in the MBA should only cost US$349 x 2 = US$698 based on the price point of the new SanDisk 32 GB SD drive. This is still more than the US$179 retail price of a 60GB 1.8-inch by 5mm thick mechanical drive, but less than the US$999 that Apple charges for the 64GB SSD option.

The gap is between HDD and SSD is narrowing all the time.

Newsletters

You have been successfully signed up. To sign up for more newsletters or to manage your account, visit the Newsletter Subscription Center.
See All
See All