SAN FRANCISCO -- After video excerpts of his deposition were presented at trial on Tuesday morning, Google CEO Larry Page was on the stand in the intellectual property case against Oracle by the afternoon.
However, Page offered few concrete answers -- if any -- constantly reasserting that he had little knowledge about any discussions regarding Java licenses needed for Android during a presentation in July 2005 by Google senior vice president Andy Rubin and his team.
- Larry Page leads as first witness in Oracle, Google IP trial
- Oracle's Larry Ellison takes the stand in Android IP trial
- Oracle's opening statement vs. Google: 91 slides
Oracle attorney David Boies asked Page if he knew if some of Google's developers did have access to some intellectual property related to Java. Page replied, "I don't know anything about that."
Boise then pointedly asked Page, "Is it your testimony that you are unaware that certain lines of code in Android were copied symbol-for-symbol from Sun's intellectual property?"
Page replied that he knew there were "some disputes" about files, and that he once discussed this with Oracle CEO Larry Ellison, asking for a copy of this information. Page asserted that he never received it because such evidence must not have been substantial enough.
This cat-and-mouse pattern continued as Boies questioned Page, "If you discovered that Android included some lines of code that had been literally copied from Sun's intellectual property, do you think that would be a violation of Google policy?"
Boies similarly asked, "Is there any circumstance that you could think of that is consistent with a clean-room where you could have line-for-line copying and be consistent with Google standards?"
To both questions, Page responded that it's hard to answer about hypothetical situations, but that such cases would be taken seriously, and he doesn't see any reason as to why such a circumstance wouldn't be possible.
Judge William Alsup called for a break during the middle of Page's examination by Oracle's lawyers. He will retake the stand on Wednesday morning.
- Oracle, Google CEOs lined up as witnesses in Android IP trial
- HP: Oracle execs thought Sun acquisition was a ‘bad idea’
- Oracle v. Google: What’s at stake
- Google, Oracle going to trial as settlement talks collapse
- Google attempts settlement while Oracle doesn’t budge