X
Business

Microsoft, others fight Apple's EU 'App Store' trademark

Microsoft, HTC, Nokia and Sony Ericsson have taken on Apple's "App Store" trademark claims in Europe, filing papers that seek to get it invalidated.
Written by Josh Lowensohn, Contributor

Microsoft, HTC, Nokia and Sony Ericsson have filed formal applications for a declaration of invalidity against Apple's attempts at trademarking "App Store" and "Appstore" with the Community Trade Mark office in Europe.

The four companies join Amazon, which filed a similar complaint in Europe against Apple's efforts in mid-April. All seek to keep Apple from being granted the trademark, saying the two phrases are too generic.

"Today's filings by HTC, Nokia, Sony Ericsson, and Microsoft, like Amazon's recent action, demonstrate the breadth of opposition to Apple's unsupportable claim of exclusivity," a Microsoft representative said in a statement. "'App store', like 'toy store' or 'book store', is a generic term that should continue to be available for everyone to use for stores that sell apps."

The new claims specifically call out Apple CEO Steve Jobs for referring to competing applications markets on another phone platform--specifically Google's Android--as "App Stores". The claims also highlight the fact that several other retailers make use of the term, including Shopify, Sendmail and DirectTV.

Apple did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

This move follows a similar legal effort in the U.S. by Microsoft in January. Apple's attempts to trademark the term "App Store" with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office back in 2008 resulted in Microsoft launching a legal battle, complete with both sides obtaining linguists and other language experts to argue whether the two words were synonymous with Apple's App Store, or mobile application stores in general.

Why are these companies so worried? For one thing, Apple's already gotten litigious on the matter. Back in March, Apple sued Amazon over its use of the "Appstore" in the title of its mobile application store for Android devices. At the time, an Apple representative said Amazon's word choice could "confuse and mislead customers." Amazon responded by countersuing, and followed a similar party line to Microsoft, saying Apple's claims were too generic.

Editorial standards