Will charm matter to OLPC's mission? See gallery (right).
Microsoft has managed to slim down the OS enough to boot up off a 2GB flash memory card and has written drivers for a number of the XO laptop's unique features, such as its scratch pad, game controller, and built-in camera.
But what's missing in the Windows version is the personality that oozes out of the Linux incarnation. The Linux model comes with an integrated suite of educational games, programming tools, and other software, all built around a kid-friendly OS shell known as Sugar.
I can attest for Sugar's charm since I have an XO and my daughter liked it. However, my daughter also knows XP and Mac for that matter. Perhaps that XO on XP would be more useful to her.
These are all open-ended questions and people will debate the Linux vs. XP thing forever. But for the OLPC's broader mission--putting laptops in developing markets--having two OS flavors makes sense.
But let's not get confused about the Windows vs. Linux thing. What makes the XO work is that it's in a form factor that works for kids--a fact me and my fat fingers have learned repeatedly. And double bonus points if teachers integrate the technology into lesson plans.
- XP meets XO: Will Linux get an equal shot?
- Lessons learned: Two weeks with the XO laptop
- Gallery: Unboxing OLPC’s XO laptop
- Gallery: The OLPC XO Sugar OS