Oracle's patent infringement and copyright lawsuit against Google is finally set to go to trial at the U.S. District Court in San Francisco today, but there are certainly plenty of questions looming as to where this will end up.
The fact that these two Silicon Valley giants will finally have a trial underway is fairly incredible (and slightly unbelievable) given how much back-and-forth there has been over the last two years since Oracle initially filed suit in August 2010.
Since then, there have been numerous delays with potential start dates assigned for October 2011, January 2012, and March 2012. It was only just last month that April 16 was given the green light. That date was solidified once the last-ditch effort for another round of settlement talks fell through.
One of the biggest hurdles for getting this trial underway is that these two companies just can't even seem to agree upon on what they're fighting over.
Yes, it's clear that Oracle is suing Google over patent violations involving Android and Java -- patents that used to be owned by Sun Microsystems but now belong to Oracle. Google reasserts time and again that Sun was a big supporter of Android, and that the programming language was free to use.
To clarify matters before going into trial, Judge William H. Alsup issued an order on April 6 asking each side to "take a firm yes or no position on whether computer programming languages are copyrightable."
But Oracle has also repeatedly failed to pinpoint and narrow down which patents being violated. Furthermore, it hasn't helped that settlement talks have continuously stalled proceedings. Even dragging in Oracle CEO Larry Ellison and Google CEO Larry Page didn't do any good.
The big debate going into the trial is what is at stake here for Oracle and Google. Even more to the point: How much money is Oracle going to win, and will it get a cut of Android revenue going forward?
It's all but said and done that Oracle is going to have some kind of pay day. During a court hearing last July, Judge Alsup admitted that Google is definitely going to pay up "probably in the millions, maybe in the billions" at some point.
Last September, Oracle wanted at least $1.16 billion in damages from Google, which is considerably less than the $6.1 billion it was asking for in July. Yet some followers of the case have said that Oracle would be lucky to extract even $100 million in this intellectual property suit.
Likely accepting that some sort of defeat is inevitable, Google did put one offer on the table a few weeks ago. Google offered to pay Oracle up to $2.8 million in damages over two patents in question. Furthermore, Google also offered a deal of 0.5 percent from Android revenue for one patent through December 2012 and 0.015 percent on a second patent through April 2018.
However, that bargain would only be offered as a stipulation for damages if (and only if) Oracle prevails on patent infringement. Oracle rebuffed the deal anyway.
Whatever Oracle ends up with (or not), we should know relatively soon as the trial is only expected to last eight weeks -- an incredibly short time when you put all of these other proceedings into perspective.
Related coverage of the Oracle v. Google legal battle:
- Google, Oracle settlement talks: Scrum over damages remains
- Oracle, Google far apart on Android talks; Two Larrys to talk again
- Google, Oracle still don't reach agreement after Page, Ellison meet
- A Google Android and Java history lesson
- Latest filings in Oracle patent case spell trouble for Google
- Google-Oracle settlement likely with top execs called to court
- U.S. judge scolds Oracle and Google at Android IP hearing
- Google ready to settle with Oracle over Android IP?
- Oracle looks for Page pyrotechnics in Google Android lawsuit
- Can Oracle collect on Android too?
- Oracle, Google scrap over Android IP damages
- Oracle wants billions from Google over Android: And just might get it
- Google pans Oracle damages argument: Java was fragmented well before Android
- Oracle wants big cut of Android damages as Google's IP headache gets worse
- Judge tells Oracle, Google to narrow Android patent claims, prior art references
- Oracle's Sun purchase: Grading the results so far
- Android OS bombshell: Did Google illegally lift copyrighted code?