Overly restrictive A.P. quoting guidelines risk winning battles at the war's expense

Summary:Saul Hansell reports today that the Associated Press "will, for the first time, attempt to define clear standards as to how much of its articles and broadcasts bloggers and Web sites can excerpt without infringing on The A.P.

Overly restrictive A.P. quoting guidelines risk winning battles at the war's expense

Saul Hansell reports today that the Associated Press "will, for the first time, attempt to define clear standards as to how much of its articles and broadcasts bloggers and Web sites can excerpt without infringing on The A.P.’s copyright."

The problem with "clear standards" is that as Tim Wu (quoted in the article) correctly points out, the legal standard is unclear, and subject to interpretation on a case by case basis. There are instances when reproducing the entire work (or large portions thereof — "Fisking" we used to call it, seems like eons ago) with sufficient commentary is fair use. The A.P.'s vague statement that it wants to police what appears to be reproduction for reproduction's sake as opposed to commentary, thus is a fair representation of what it's entitled to do by law; anything more specific might not hold up.

Given this, it'll be interesting to see what the A.P. cobbles together with the Media Bloggers Association, which of course does not act for and can't bind the whole blogosphere and Web. If, as the statements to Hansell suggest, it's as restrictive as purporting to make brief direct quotations against A.P. policy, the A.P. will either have to backtrack or try to get judicial buy-in on a policy that in all likelihood would be deemed overbroad.

(Image by SideLong, CC Attribution-2.0)

Related: Mike Arrington, Here’s Our New Policy On A.P. stories: They’re Banned, and all stories and posts linked from there; Techmeme re same.

Topics: Legal

About

Denise Howell is an appellate, intellectual property and technology lawyer who enjoys broad industry recognition for her expertise on the intersection of emerging technologies and law. For further details please see her professional background and speaking schedule. Denise's career is characterized by her passionate engagement in intell... Full Bio

zdnet_core.socialButton.googleLabel Contact Disclosure

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Related Stories

The best of ZDNet, delivered

You have been successfully signed up. To sign up for more newsletters or to manage your account, visit the Newsletter Subscription Center.
Subscription failed.