When Daniel Cuthbert was convicted last month of gaining unauthorised access to a Tsunami fund-raising Web site, many people — including the trial judge — suspected his career in the IT industry was over.
These fears were unfounded, though. Cuthbert is hard at work at Corsaire, a UK security company.
Martin O'Neal, director at Corsaire, confirmed on Friday that Cuthbert had actually joined the company before his trial. O'Neal, though, isn't worried that one of his employees is a high-profile breaker of the Computer Misuse Act (CMA).
"The reason being, we've known Daniel for a long time. He was well-known in the security industry, even before the case. His integrity has never been called into question," O'Neal told ZDNet UK on Friday.
Cuthbert was found guilty under the CMA of gaining unauthorised access to the Tsunami appeal Web site. He claimed in court that he had made a donation and then became concerned that he'd fallen victim to a phishing scam. To check, he added ../../../ to the URL in an attempt to access the site's higher directories — an action that triggered an alarm.
Security experts and ZDNet readers have expressed concern about the conviction. O'Neal shares this view.
"As for the conviction, it's frankly ridiculous. It highlighted how untried and untested the CMA is. The main problem is how you define unauthorised access and intent in the context of an open Web server," O'Neal said.
As a full-time employee at Corsaire, Cuthbert is currently working on internal training material. This may come as a surprise to the judge in his case, who told Cuthbert that the consequences of his actions were “more serious than anything I can do".
The wider issue of the ethics of hiring known hackers or convicted cybercriminals is one that splits the security industry. Last year, German firewall vendor Securepoint was criticised after hiring Sven Jaschan, a teenager who had been charged – and was subsequently convicted – of writing the Sasser worm.
Richard Starnes, UK president of the Information Systems Security Association, acknowledged that the circumstance of Cuthbert's conviction should not automatically debar him from the security industry.
"Life is rarely made of hard and fast rules, nor should it be. You should look at the merits of each particular case. In general, I do not hire former hackers. However, from a potential employment standpoint, a situation such as Mr. Cuthbert's would certainly warrant further investigation rather than a flat refusal to consider for employment," said Starnes.