Telstra failed to treat ADSL customers equally

Telstra failed to treat ADSL customers equally

Summary: Telstra's wholesale customers were not given access to new ADSL products at the same time as Telstra's own retail ISP BigPond, the ACCC has found.

SHARE:
3

Telstra's wholesale arm created two new ADSL products for its retail arm but failed to offer similar products to its retail competitors, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission has found.

As part of the transition to the National Broadband Network (NBN), Telstra agreed to structurally separate its wholesale fixed line network business from its retail businesses, including BigPond.

The ACCC produces a yearly report to ensure the company's structural separation undertaking is working as planned to keep the two arms of the company separated, with no information sharing, and no special preferences given to Telstra's retail arm.

In its annual compliance report (PDF) tabled in Parliament today, the ACCC found a number of instances in the 2012-2013 financial year where Telstra had breached the undertaking over information security and equivalence obligations.

The biggest breach came through Telstra continuing to struggle to ringfence 14 wholesale and data warehouse systems to prevent Telstra Retail staff from accessing those systems. The ACCC said in its report, Telstra was continuing to work to remediate these issues.

In another instance, Telstra's small business call centre staff were emailed to check whether a customer on a call was a BigPond customer. The company was then tasked to train staff to ensure they do not look up a customer's retail provider in the wholesale system.

Outside of information ringfencing, the ACCC found that new ADSL products offered to BigPond were not also offered to Telstra's retail customers.

"This meant that wholesale customers were not able to migrate an existing ADSL service to a better ADSL service supplied from a Telstra cabinet when retail services could be migrated in that way, and wholesale customers having fewer line configurations available to optimise consumers' services," the ACCC said.

In a statement, a spokesperson for Telstra said that the SSU was "working well" but highlighted "some gaps in our systems."

"We proactively identified these gaps ourselves and we are investing significantly in our systems to close them. The SSU sets a very high bar. It encompasses the potential for actions that are not equivalent as well as actual instances of Telstra not providing equivalence between wholesale and retail," the spokesperson said.

"This report outlines some gaps that create the potential for non-equivalent treatment as well as actual actions by Telstra that have impacted our wholesale customers. The report includes no evidence to suggest our retail staff have used wholesale customer information to gain an unfair commercial advantage."

The spokesperson said that overall, Telstra had more than 100 million interactions with customers on the copper network, and the company had performed "very well in delivering equivalence across all these interactions."

Topics: Telcos, Telstra, Australia

About

Armed with a degree in Computer Science and a Masters in Journalism, Josh keeps a close eye on the telecommunications industry, the National Broadband Network, and all the goings on in government IT.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

3 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • Yes...sure

    Telstra are the big white knights of the Telecom industry.. (sarcasm).

    What a joke !

    Telstra doesn't do anything unless it benefits Telstra, ..first,..last.. & always!

    It's only when the ACCC or the TIO steps in (which isn't often) that Telstra abides by the rules.
    Huntsman.ks
  • Only wholesale?

    Telstra's low cost brand, "Belong" is not available in my area. Noting it is fully supported by Telstra, I suspect that I am being discriminated against because I live in an area of low mobility and high income.
    Letterboxfrog
  • Surprise surprise

    For the last few years my customers have found this. They call their ISP, iiNet for example, ask the if ADSL2+ is available on their line. iiNet check the Telstra systems. "No sorry sir, Telstra only have ADSL1 infrastructure in your area". Customer calls Telstra, and low and behold 5 days later they are connected to ADSL2+.

    Thieving lying gnomes.
    Ramrunner-5dd3e