Aussie IT managers love DIY

Summary: Aussie IT managers are in control, or at least they think they are. They admit they need help with IT training, they'll even entertain a bit of IT consulting, but they are not at all keen on outsourcing.

Aussie IT managers are in control, or at least they think they are. They admit they need help with IT training, they'll even entertain a bit of IT consulting, but they are not at all keen on outsourcing.

Of the respondents to the ZDNet 2010 IT Priorities survey, 61 per cent said they had no plans to outsource IT activity in the next two years. Only 9.5 per cent will be outsourcing anything in the next six months, compared to 15 per cent in Europe, 21 per cent in China and Latin America and 31 per cent in India. Bigger Aussie companies are more likely to let go: 21 per cent of those with 10,000 or more employees plan to outsource within six months compared to just 5 per cent of micro-businesses (less than 10 people).

IT Priorities graph

Perhaps because they're keen on doing stuff themselves, Aussie IT managers are keen on training. 28 per cent will be applying for some training in the next six months and 70 per cent plan to in the next two years. Only 30 per cent don't have training in the pipeline. This commitment to training is common across all businesses with 50 or more employees. Although the same thing is happening overseas where IT teams are being trained and work is being outsourced.

So what about consultants? If we don't like to outsource are we prepared to pull someone in to offer expertise? The answer is, yes, a bit. 18 per cent of respondents will be using IT consulting in the next six months (27 per cent in very big businesses), but 45 per cent have no plans to use consultants in the next two years. That pretty much echoes the pattern overseas.

Perhaps the reason why we're not calling for help is because we're not doing much that's new. It has been a period of consolidation for many businesses as we come off the back of the global financial crisis. That could account for the relatively low percentage of businesses who are going to call for help with change management (just 18 per cent). Instead, IT teams are sticking to their knitting, by providing remote support for staff for example.

Or perhaps it's because our IT teams have an insular approach, focusing on training themselves up and not calling on outside expertise. This could be because the services offered by external consultants aren't up to scratch, or because the opposite is the case and the IT manager doesn't want to be shown-up. Whatever the reason, the study shows that the keep-it-in-house approach is an Aussie phenomenon. How often have you said "if a thing's worth doing, it's worth doing yourself?"

Topics: IT Priorities, Outsourcing, IT Employment

About

Phil Dobbie has a wealth of radio and business experience. He started his career in commercial radio in the UK and, since coming to Australia in 1991, has held senior marketing and management roles with Telstra, OzEmail, the British Tourist Authority and other telecommunications, media, travel and advertising businesses.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

2 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • Perhaps they are sick of being screwed by out-sources and have realised that DIY is the best value, safest and often the fastest way to do IT?
    The implication that Aussie IT are "insular" or "not doing anything new" for avoiding the crap-ware fed to companies via (usually US based) out sourcing profiteers is rather naive. Outsourcing will only do newness if the client pays. Even when it is standard stuff the consultants will screw it up, so why use them?
    Has Telstra actually benefited from 10 years of "improving" IT? Answer: No. they have wasted $Billions and have lost their best IT staff and now have barely functioning systems, all to enrich a bunch of clueless IT consultants.
    So perhaps this insulting little piece is by the poor consultants who don't appreciate that they have killed all the goose for now...they will need to wait until another spin-cycle generation has passed so they can sell the whole "core business" line again and muck up another round of IT departments. Imagine: training before outsourcing! How un-Americ---I mean Australian!
    OzAndy-65c37
  • Its fairly stock standard for anyone from outside Australian IT to make comments about being insular , overly protective of its own envirionment and under whelming in its approach. The truth is that most Australians in IT can actually think and assess and analyse what is being sold to them as mostly recycled and often failed American marketing and management theory. One of the most common sales techniques by these poorly run companies is to criticise the existing platform of a potential client then become that company's so called saviour (in theory) by offering a get out of jail card but its NEVER for free and there is ALWAYS a sting in the tail. Meanwhile we lose experienced , interested and committed staff who walk away from IT or go overseas and customers always suffer poorer service outcomes. When Managers realise that the outsourcing approach is no better than maintaining its own staff and they do need a training budget perhaps the industry will start to improve. There is also at work totally unrealistic management expectations of IT and appalling budgets that are often so low that even the existing infrastructure is never well maintained let alone having money , time or staffing resources to improve things. So in a way many , many Aussie business's just keep on repeating the same old mistakes as they churn and burn people in the quest for a perfect solution which is just not out there. Add to that the poor endeavours of companies like Microsoft who decide on a whim to no longer support Xp , provide no direct upgrade path to Windows 7 from XP , take out options that clients and business alike used , appreciated and were familiar with and then deliver a crap O/S like VISTA then try to fix it with an even lamer version of Windows 7 (remember this is America at its BEST) and you can see why no-one is ever going to win this argument . No wonder smart and sensible people walked away from IT some time ago. The only people left are those financially bound to the job through mortgages , fear or desperation - not the most inspring way to go to work and I imagine the least productive.

    Ken IT Director
    Melbourne
    ramnet@...