Unboxing Asia

Hana Stewart Smith

How panic spreads: Japan’s resilience to earthquakes

By | January 30, 2012, 3:01pm PST

Summary: News reports, suggesting that Tokyo can 70 percent expect a 7.0 magnitude earthquake in the next four years, sparked panic. That was the least of my worries.

In the last few days more and more information about the potential for another big quake in Japan has surfaced, and it’s caused quite a bit of a stir.

The story, put simply, was alarming.

Experts from Tokyo University had released new information that suggested there was a 70 percent chance of a significant 7.0 or greater magnitude earthquake in Japan’s capital within the next four years.

It started with a report in the Yomiuri Shimbun newspaper that quickly spread, with reports and stories from almost all of Japan’s major newspapers and news sites following suit, along with national television coverage.

As you know, no news travels quite as quickly as bad news, and it wasn’t particularly long before it hit international sites, getting coverage in the Guardian and the Telegraph, along with others.

Twitter followed soon after, with hundreds of tweets cropping up about the imminent threat of a major quake in Japan, stirring up people’s fears even more, and with some users even inflating the risk to 75 percent.

The statistics are alarming — no mistake. But this news wasn’t actually new.

Mainichi Shimbun’s Takao Yamada, got to the heart of the matter, and was quick to find that this brief media panic was exactly that.

In fact, the University of Tokyo’s Earthquake Research Institute had released these results last year as part of predictions for the next thirty years. The original statistics — whilst still rather scary — were not so immediate.

The prediction was instead that there would be a 98 percent chance of a 7.0 magnitude earthquake in the Tokyo area in the next thirty years. According to Prof. Naoshi Hirata, the statistics are the same but presented on two different scales.

Give people thirty years to deal with the possibility of another earthquake, and the news can slip by more or less unnoticed. Give people only four years, and they react accordingly.

Adding fuel to the flames was the newly released information that an active 200km fault line — probably caused by the Tohoku earthquake — was discovered off Honshu’s Kii peninsula. On top of that, a spattering of heavy tremors in the Tokyo region over the weekend made the threat feel real.

It got people thinking: Is this happening much more regularly than usual?

I certainly felt that way, although I didn’t feel qualified to say what was ‘usual’ at all.

There was the definite feeling that there was just more seismic activity hitting the capital, and the stubborn part of me that had told all the naysayers who had called me crazy for going to Japan started to doubt itself.

The very first earthquake I experienced in Japan was at Yoyogi Park. It was the first time I had visited the large park — equivalent to New York’s Central Park — and it was late at night.

The major spectacles at that time were lit up fountains in various colours, late-night joggers, teenagers sneaking off to make out, and not much else. I was sat on the ground — and the feeling was incredibly surreal — the ground just started to rock back and forth like a swing.

My friend, who was mid sentence when the tremor started, just dismissed it with a light, “Oh, hey, an earthquake”, and that was it. Considering that all three of the friends I was talking with had been here during the heights of the Tohoku earthquake, a tiny tremor like this was absolutely nothing.

To me, it was impressive.

More impressive was the way that seconds later every bird in the entire park just went crazy. I had heard that animals reacted strongly to earthquakes, but I’d never really expected it to be so intense. It made me feel like I’d been dropped directly into the ‘foreshadowing’ sequence in a horror film.

A few minutes later a helicopter passed overhead, (”Collecting data,” my better informed friend told me), and all three of their phones lit up with earthquake warnings.

They told me that the warnings usually come after the fact, and that they’d taken hours to arrive after the Tohoku earthquake, meaning that when they were being warned of a big, impending earthquake, all they could say whilst watching the aftermath unfold was: “Obviously.”

Every major mobile network in Japan has simultaneous broadcasting services to send out early warnings when an earthquake is detected, and it is a mandatory requirement for all 3G phones out on the market.

Although the major overseas manufacturers do not share this system, Apple announced in August last year that its iOS 5 would include an early warning system for iPhone users.

In retrospect, that first earthquake was positively tiny in scale to some that I’ve experienced since.

On Saturday morning I was woken up by a 5.5 magnitude tremor, with an epicentre very close to Tokyo, and was pleased to find that all of the anti-earthquake measures fitted into my apartment were fully operational.

All my drawers were locked into place; the windows too, and less conveniently, the elevator stopped dead. It went a long way to appeasing the part of my brain that had been devouring news reports about earthquake fears all week.

It still fascinates me how completely unaffected most people here are by the tremors. Everything just keeps going, because they’ve seen this all before and worse, and there’s still grocery shopping to be done.

I’m aware of the fact that tremors and small quakes are actually very common in Japan, because absolutely everybody told me about them before I came here. To say that people thought I was kind of mad to want to come here, in light of the situation in Fukushima also would be an understatement.

It’s more than a little reassuring to read an article like Takao Yamada, when, as an ex-pat in Japan these English language news reports are the best information I can get.

I also keep Japan’s meteorological agency webpage bookmarked and ready to go in case of an emergency, which also has an English language option for Japanese beginners like myself.

Although the panic caused by these somewhat skewed statistics has been blown out of proportion, it has provided a welcome wake-up call for people in the capital, reminding them that they must be prepared.

For me, as a stranger in a strange land, it’s reminded me that no matter how advanced the tech in my home is to help in an earthquake. It might not be enough. No matter how many ‘earthquake’ alerts I attach to my phone, they’ll probably arrive a little too late.

No matter how many English reports are available — the news is going to be in Japanese first and foremost — and I need to make sure I’m as prepared as anyone else.

Image source: ZDNet.

Related:

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

Hana is three things -- small, British, and stranded in Tokyo.

Disclosure

Hana Stewart-Smith

Hana Stewart-Smith's mother is presently employed by IBM UK. No other existing or potential conflicts to report; this information will be updated whenever deemed necessary.

Biography

Hana Stewart-Smith

Hana is three things -- small, British, and stranded in Tokyo. After recognising that a degree in both English Literature and Film is, in fact, two parts unnecessary and useless, Hana decided that a change in pace was in order. With a lifelong passion for writing and a healthy fear/ fascination with technology, the next logical step was to move to Japan and surround herself with terrifying tech and a complete absence of the English language. She'll let you know how that venture works out.

Related Discussions on TechRepublic

Did you know you can take part in these discussions with your ZDNet membership?
5
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

RE: How panic spreads: Japan's resilience to earthquakes
silicon_salami 31st Jan
@JALockhart - Ok so first things first; when you are correcting someone's grammar and/or spelling it usually helps for your grammar and/or spelling to be correct itself.

Secondly, this sentence you are "correcting" is actually correct. Strangely enough there is a grammatical term for this, it's called the 'PASSIVE'. Maybe you missed this lesson, or maybe this was a lesson you missed - see what I did there? That's called the passive. If you are still a little hazy - the passive is when the thing receiving the action is the subject of the sentence, and the opposite - the active - is when the thing doing the action is the subject of the sentence and the thing receiving the action is the object.

Thirdly, and this is really more related to the article - there was an earthquake felt in Tokyo on the Saturday and it woke me up with the shaking. I live in Ikebukuro and funnily enough...that's Tokyo!

It was at 7.44-ish in the morning and the website - http://www.jma.go.jp/en/quake/20120128074401391-280739.html - has recorded activity on this day from 7.44 am to 7.54 am.

So in the future, keep your comments related to the article and please double check your grammar.
0 Votes
+ -
Another factual problem
JALockhart 30th Jan
You write that "an active 200km fault line???probably caused by the Tohoku earthquake???was discovered off Honshu???s Kii peninsula." What grounds do you have for attributing it to the Tohoku (3/11) quake? Besides that being a totally illogical statement (quakes don't cause faults), the linked article mentions it in conjunction w/several past quakes, citing one as far back as 1707!
0 Votes
+ -
The first earthquake you experienced in Japan was not in Yoyogi Park; your first experience of an earthquake was.

In any case, Saturday morning's M5.5 under Doshimura, Yamanashi, was hardly felt in central Tokyo, so I doubt that it served as a "wake up call" for people there, especially given that the shaking of 3/11 was much more intense for them. Let us know when you've experienced Shindo 3 or more intense shaking. (There were two of these on Saturday and one on Sunday where I live.) If you're going to discuss earthquakes, at least know the difference between magnitude (M) and intensity of shaking (in Japan, reported as shindo).
@JALockhart - Ok so first things first; when you are correcting someone's grammar and/or spelling it usually helps for your grammar and/or spelling to be correct itself.

Secondly, this sentence you are "correcting" is actually correct. Strangely enough there is a grammatical term for this, it's called the 'PASSIVE'. Maybe you missed this lesson, or maybe this was a lesson you missed - see what I did there? That's called the passive. If you are still a little hazy - the passive is when the thing receiving the action is the subject of the sentence, and the opposite - the active - is when the thing doing the action is the subject of the sentence and the thing receiving the action is the object.

Thirdly, and this is really more related to the article - there was an earthquake felt in Tokyo on the Saturday and it woke me up with the shaking. I live in Ikebukuro and funnily enough...that's Tokyo!

It was at 7.44-ish in the morning and the website - http://www.jma.go.jp/en/quake/20120128074401391-280739.html - has recorded activity on this day from 7.44 am to 7.54 am.

So in the future, keep your comments related to the article and please double check your grammar.
0 Votes
+ -
More aware now
Nihon8888 31st Jan
I have lived in Japan for 9 years. When I first arrived, having never experienced an earthquake before, I was quite excited when the earth moved. Now not so much. Now every tremor is a reminder of the possibility of "the big one" just around the corner...
0 Votes
+ -
More aware now
Nihon8888 31st Jan
I have lived in Japan for 9 years. When I first arrived, having never experienced an earthquake before, I was quite excited when the earth moved. Now not so much. Now every tremor is a reminder of the possibility of "the big one" just around the corner...

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix