ie8 fix
madison

With Apple's U.S. dominance, smartphone race heads overseas

By | January 26, 2012, 6:00pm PST

Summary: Collectively, four recent earnings reports from very large companies paint a clear picture of the global smartphone market. Who’s in the lead? That depends on where you look. Who’s in second? That spot’s up for grabs, worldwide.

The big four of the United States mobile phone industry all reported their 4th-quarter earnings in the past few days. Apple and Google (with its Android hardware partners) have the smartphone category locked up. Meanwhile the combo of AT&T and Verizon own a combined 70% or so of the U.S. mobile carrier market.

I’ve been reading through those reports, which tell a clear story about the current state of the U.S. market. But an offhand comment by Apple CEO Tim Cook suggests that big changes could be ahead:

“I wouldn’t say it’s a two-horse race. There’s a horse in Redmond that always suits up and always runs, and will keep running, and there are other players we can’t count out.”

Is he serious? Yes. Remember, though, Cook’s perspective is that of a jockey turning his head to see how far back the other runners are.

In the United States smartphone market, Apple has already won. Decisively. Here’s how complete the domination is among this country’s top two carriers:

With only three models, Apple sold more than twice as many units as all Android handset makers combined in that segment in Q4.

Apple is also dominating among enterprise customers. Survey results released last week by Good Technology, a maker of enterprise mobile software, show Apple with an impressive lead:

Despite Android’s overall market share growth and steady absolute growth among Good’s customers, just 35 percent of all Good smartphone activations were on Android, compared to iPhone’s 65 percent.

That number wasn’t an anomaly caused by the launch of the iPhone 4S. The Good Technology report notes that collectively, “iOS devices accounted for over 70 percent of all activations in Q4, roughly the same as Q3 2011.”

And the win is even more staggering when measured in dollar terms. Apple has done as well as it has by capturing the hearts and minds of the most affluent. Those customers don’t just pay a premium for hardware, they also pay a premium for monthly service, which puts more money in carriers’ pockets. That’s the reason Apple reported a staggering 44.7% gross profit margin (up from 38.5% a year ago) in its recent quarterly results.

Related:

Google still has an edge in other parts of the developed world, but it’s eroding. A report last week from Kantar Worldwide Tech said “Apple sales are now growing at a faster rate than Android across the nine countries we cover.” The list includes Great Britain, where iPhone’s share is up nearly 10% in a single year, to 30.9%. (Germany is a bedrock of Android strength at 61%.)

I suspect that Apple’s success will continue in Japan and Western Europe and among the emerging well-to-do in China. Worldwide, the iPhone will continue to appeal to the top of the economic pyramid and to information workers who can bring their own devices to work. Android will be the phone of the huddled masses.

The Kantar Worldwide Tech study counted Windows Phone at less than 2% worldwide. This year, with the Nokia partnership finally taking off, Microsoft has an opportunity to compete against Android for market share outside the developed world, with a special emphasis on emerging markets. Nokia has deep supply chain and manufacturing advantages in those countries, not to mention great brand value and operator billing relationships with carriers worldwide that Google and Apple don’t.

By this time next year, Windows Phone will probably have picked up a few percentage points in the U.S. market, but it could easily swing to double-digit shares in places like Russia, Brazil, and India, where Nokia has historically had strong market share. And China, of course, where it will face a head-on fight with Apple.

The other opportunity for Windows Phone to make inroads is in the enterprise. In a bring-your-own-device environment, Windows Phone could end up ahead of Android if Microsoft beefs up the enterprise capabilities of the Windows Phone OS. And RIM’s ongoing troubles also create tremendous opportunity to reach disenchanted BlackBerry owners.

But make no mistake about it, in the high-margin markets that matter, the battle is for second place behind Apple’s iPhone.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Ed Bott is an award-winning technology writer with more than two decades' experience writing for mainstream media outlets and online publications.

Disclosure

Ed Bott

Ed Bott is a freelance technical journalist and book author. All work that Ed does is on a contractual basis.

Since 1994, Ed has written more than 25 books about Microsoft Windows and Office. Along with various co-authors, Ed is completely responsible for the content of the books he writes. As a key part of his contractual relationship with publishers, he gives them permission to print and distribute the content he writes and to pay him a royalty based on the actual sales of those books. Ed's books written prior to fall 2011 have been distributed by Que Publishing (a division of Pearson Education) and by Microsoft Press. As of November 2011, Ed is a partner in the independent publishing company Fair Trade Digital Exchange, which exclusively publishes his books.

On occasion, Ed accepts consulting assignments. In recent years, he has worked as an expert witness in cases where his experience and knowledge of Microsoft and Microsoft Windows have been useful. In each such case, his compensation is on an hourly basis, and he is hired as a witness, not an advocate.

Ed does not own stock or have any other financial interest in Microsoft or any other software company. He owns 500 shares of stock in EMC Corporation, which was purchased before the company's acquisition of VMware. In addition, he owns 350 shares of stock in Intel Corporation, purchased more than two years ago. All stocks are held in retirement accounts for long-term growth.

Ed does not accept gifts from companies he covers. All hardware products he writes about are purchased with his own funds or are review units covered under formal loan agreements and are returned after the review is complete.

Biography

Ed Bott

Ed Bott is an award-winning technology writer with more than two decades' experience writing for mainstream media outlets and online publications. He's served as editor of the U.S. edition of PC Computing and managing editor of PC World; both publications had monthly paid circulation in excess of 1 million during his tenure. He is the author of more than 25 books on Microsoft Windows and Office, including the recently released Windows 7 Inside Out.

69
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

RE: With Apple's U.S. dominance, smartphone race heads overseas
zmichel_3@... 10th Feb
Facts are facts, opinions... well atleast I live in America and we are all still allowed to express them last I checked. I am familiar with both mobile OS's and yes my current and future phones will be android based(especially with the more polished ics/4.0 release). While it is true that Androids have have been buggy, and difficult? to operate for the general masses(I get questioned almost everyday by my coworkers on how to do this and that on their Android phones) their selling points are their flexibility and customiseability. The main reason I hear from real, general public for why they chose the iPhone is not their popularity but their ease of use and the "one size fits all" in other words their standardization. Obviously most people will gravitate towards the path of least resistance so Apple should be holding on to that lead for a little while longer. But! The tech industry always changes and as Android goes through its growing pains I believe they will close that gap, Ice Cream Sandwich aka Android 4.0 is a huge step towards a standard OS across all their devices and as we are starting to see on the hardware front even the phones coming out this year are getting closer in specs across all brands with fewer derivatives. Let Apple enjoy their lead, I just hope they have one hell of a plan for their next phone (iPhone 5?) because I am quite sure Google is not content playing second Fiddle.
Yeah, and what's happening now? Check Craigslist, people are practically giving away these phones, for many that used their old phones for things like facebook, gps, hands-free driving, and the like, the iPhone has them wishing they had Android back!

I was talking to a guy tonight who's girlfriend bought my iPhone 4s and he pretty much said his friends that bought the 4s all agree, the phone is nothing special and they all want their old phones back! Now, I can relate because to me, I had all I could do not to throw the 4s! I swear, everytime I turned around there was something that it couldn't do that my Android phones could! Needless to say, I will never go back down this road again! iOS is flat out weak as an operating system and it really brings Down what is otherwise very strong hardware!
@Peter Perry
What absolute and utter garbage. I don't believe a word of what you wrote.
0 Votes
+ -
Even Craig had his doubts
Robert Hahn 26th Jan
Yeah, that was a howler, wasn't it? Sounded like one of those spams about how my sister's boyfriend's cousin just bought an iPad for twenty bucks.
@Habiloso of course not, why would you? You're in denial!

Check the Craigslist, you will find them for like $325 and $350! Honestly, some of those scared me because I thought for sure at those prices mine wasn't going to sell for $425 (I got $400 for it)! I confirmed the 360 trade and the $350 were legit but I didn't chase the others down.

But anyway, why is it hard to believe that people are used to Android and iOS is Culture Shock to them?

As for me, the first thing was not being able to change the default mapping software so things like siri wouldn't work with Mapquest and neither would tapping an address in the web browser.

Second was when I tuned all my music in iTunes with custom preset equalizer settings only to have the phone not sync nor support those... of course what does it do with a song that has a preset? Shuts the EQ off! So I try to buy an EQ so I can use it with my sound bar! Nope, can't do that either because nothing is allowed to integrate with Apple Software so you have to buy a whole music App and the phone once again will not set it as the default app so the sound bar remote is useless! Did I mention these things are much easier on Android??? I guess I should just not have tried to use My Sennheiser HD518 Headphones and then I wouldn't have noticed this right???

Oh and the Wonderful Siri! Yes, refused to read messages from the lock screen and I followed everyones advice but still it didn't work! I know, Siri is Beta and they still don't say that in commercials.

So then I want to change things like ISO in the camera, nope, can't do that either! Talk about Point and shoot!

Oh and Group Messaging is handing out people's contact information to everyone else! Yeah, this is a wonderful feature and very secure!

Spell checking? Right, I always want confirmation that I spelled something correctly when I only have one letter left to go!

Oh and the final straw!!! The mobile hotspot refused to broadcast the SSID! This would be okay if Apple listed the encryption they were using in the settings and you don't think about it until it isn't working (which was often!)...

Is that enough for you? I didn't even touch Battery Life, lack of true handsfree mode with Siri, or average black level of the 4s!

Now if you don't believe me, do a little research and you will see, all of these things are very real with iOS!
@Robert Hahn That's the funny thing about Sheep! They follow without thinking! Baaaa!
@Habiloso

Have to agree, I love it when people argue facts with stories. A sure sign of a failed point of view.

By the way I have an Android and can't wait to get back to an iPhone. Though I will miss the Android's buggyness, unpolished interface, system hesitations and slow downs:) see I have a story too.
@Peter Perry But anyway, why is it hard to believe that people are used to Android and iOS is Culture Shock to them?
That is not what is hard to believe. It's not only hard it's actually illogical to believe, based on your post history, to believe anything you post in regard to anything Apple.

So let's talk about craigslist. You mention what you claim iPhones are going for and consider it cheap but don't mention that the beloved Android phones are going to what $0.10 on the dollar? I looked at our local craigslist and there were no 4Ss, the 4s were going for $350+ and 3GSs were going for $200+. On the flip side there was on Android phone listed for $300 and the rest were in the $50-$80 range.
@Peter Perry

do i believe you or polls of thousands of users by companies like Changewave that show 4S satisfaction rates sky high: 96% satisfied with the phone

http://www.changewaveresearch.com/articles/2011/iphone4s_20111201.html

even the iPhone 4 at the peak of antennagate had a return rate of only 1.6%. The iPhone has won JD Powers customer satisfaction award (poll of users) 6 times in a row beating all the androids, wp7 etc
@Davewrite depends on the way the data was captured! The iPhone is ab anomoly because it wasn't returned but, that doesn't mean they kept them either! Think about it, if you could get $750 for the iPhone 4 why return it? You can easily sell that phone and buy one without an antenna issue... the point being, marketing is running the iPhone train!
@Davewrite

so if the polls are flawed i.e exaggerating numbers etc why didn't it also exaggerate Android, WP etc phones as well (the same JD Power poll covered many different phones) ?

fictional example:
Question:
-- what phone do you use?
-- list down from one to ten how satisfied you are with it.

asked of different phone users. Apple comes up on top by a wide margin. So how can you all say "depends on the way the data was captured!"?

and don't say 'Apple fanboys' skew the data either because iPhones sell 30 million plus a quarter, apple used to sell only about 2 million macs a year in the old 'fanboy' days so most users are new to apple. Unless of course a new user who uses an Apple device instantly becomes a 'fell in love' fanboy... in which case it proves the 'satisfaction' theory as well.
I would say that Android and iOS appeal to different people. Personally I will never buy an iPhone because I don't want to be locked in to Apple's walled garden. Clearly Apple's approach appeals to a great many people, however.
@TV John
Too many people buy what is advertised, not what they really need.
@TV John And that's different from the way Google is beginning to reshape Android how? I'm willing to bet that within a year's time, to be able to use subscription media on an Android device is going to require a locked bootloader and an official carrier (or manufacturer, in the case of Wifi-only devices) build of Android updated to the latest release within 3 months, whether it's buggy or not.
@rhonin And a very large number get the cheapest smartphone they can skewing the number one way so what is your point?
@Peter Perry I thought you had an Android phone?
0 Votes
+ -
I'm calling BS
lumpy_blumpkin 27th Jan
@Peter Perry I just sold my 2 year old 3GS (16 GB) on eBay for $183, and my wife's for $166 (hers was missing the headphones and charger). You have no clue what you are talking about.
0 Votes
+ -
@lumpy_blumpkin
I just looked and there are a lot of them for sale.....
0 Votes
+ -
RE: With Apple's U.S. dominance, smartphone race heads overseas
neil.postlethwaite@... Updated - 27th Jan
@Peter Perry
Total crap.

Don;t know anyone in the UK with a Nokia Lumia phone, and only ever came across one person in the 12 months or so it has been out with a WP7 phone (a HTC), who junked it for a Samsung Galaxy S 2.

Smartphone-wise "In the hand", people have iPhone, Android (mainly Samsung), and Blackberry's.

Windows Phone is no-where, and Nokia's 1 million sales (to retailers) Q4/2011 blows.

It's a race to bankrupcy between Nokia and RIM, and a vulture patent-fest.

My wife loves her iPhone 4S (64gb), effectively cost of GBP50 on contract after trading in her 32Gb iPhone 3GS in mint condition for GBP175
@Peter Perry
Thanks for putting into words what the rest of us, who have open eyes and can think for ourselves, acknowledge is the difference between an iPhone and and Android phone.
All I care about is the quality of the product that I can buy and what I can do with it. I can't understand how people fanatically pay more cash for an inferior product. Although maybe that is the point. No one who has real product knowledge and buys an iPhone wants to admit that their emperor is naked and not wearing fancy clothes after all.
@K6H Maybe you are the one that can't admit something. I couldn't care less what OS you prefer but apparently it affects you somehow that some people have a different preference. You seem to need your OS to win so that it can some justify your existence.
@Peter Perry
Your comments were interesting but you badly need to get laid.
0 Votes
+ -
We don't have good Internet here
Robert Hahn 26th Jan
I don't understand how Nokia's strength in selling cheap feature phones in developing countries helps Windows Phone. In one of the other articles, a commenter from Africa says that Nokia phones are very popular there, but that all these "smartphone" capabilities don't interest them much.

Nokia obviously needed something to compete in the smartphone segment, but that market is not in emerging countries.
@Robert Hahn ...Does he speak for everyone there or himself and a few people he knows? Emerging is hard to gauge. But it does point to a future where more and more people might find smartphones interesting as an option. With the OS's and hardware growing ever more capable I'm sure that many would find they don't need/want a full sized desktop and can kill many different birds with the one smartphone. Who knows but what I do think is that emerging points to change but perhaps that change had not hit this particular person... YET that is.

Pagan jim
said the doofus "worshipper" (of Apple) jim, the rabid Apple shareholder
@Robert Hahn As an African, I do not agree with that, although I do see challenges in increasing their smartphone market share in Africa. I agree that Nokia not only has a big market with its cheap feature phones but that its brand has also become popular with the consumers. The problem is ...

1. Price. This is still the single most decisive factor for any African or any other consumer in any emerging or developing country that would either make or break a deal. I honestly can't see how they can get a good market share with the average mid to high end smartphones common in developed markets. Unless they're willing to adopt low end smartphone like Android phones, this is one hurdle they cannot pass at this time.

2. No major producer seem to want to bother with most of the emerging markets. That's right, all the bling bling technological developments we hear through the media is mostly tales we recount with each other but not have access to. Of course people would want to have these fancy tech products in their hands! But we hardly see any product being manufactured with Africans' in mind. Price is one factor, as stated above. Another small example, check the available languages of most products. Only Afrikaans is the one I find commonly. Arabic is present also but that could be due to rich oil-state Arab countries and their large population. Why not Amharic, Swahili, Tigrinya, Somali, Wolof, Fulani, Afan Oromo, Zulu, or others? Because the speakers are not likely to buy such expensive products? Some services the smartphones offer are completely irrelevant to these markets, and you will hardly see innovative features that are relevant to these markets. A friend of mine who bought an iPhone (3) wasn't able to create an account, which required an American address; so he had to use an account from the person he bought it from who lives in the US. I don't see Android Market giving space for African developers (Ironically, it was a Chinese developer made a multilingual keyboard which included my Amharic language, though I appreciate his efforts).

3. Some necessary prerequisites are missing. I honestly can't say about African countries in general, but if you don't have some services like 3G, that could undermine some of the benefits of having a smartphone (like in where I am). Some amount of education is also necesasry for people in general to have an idea of how to use the advantages of a smartphone. Chances are the manufacturers will most likely have to focus on urban areas.

In short, there is a possibility of getting a market share in Africa and other emerging markets but the companies will have to focus on these markets' specific conditions and be willing to give a little dedication to adjust to their their marketing and manufacturing based on these conditions without judging based on the simplistic purchasing power of consumers there.
0 Votes
+ -
Anecdotal evidence only, but...
Ben_E Updated - 26th Jan
...I know plenty of people who are getting rid of their iPhones...

...to upgrade to the latest iPhone. A lot of the arguments I've seen put forward in this talkback are about software features and capabilities - these are the tech crowd arguments. The man in the street doesn't care for most of these things, he wants a phone that looks good, is easy to use and he can get music and video and apps on to it, and do Facebook. Yes, I KNOW you can do all this stuff on android, but not as easily or as seamlessly as on iOS despite what its fans say.

The problems facing Android:
- too many handsets with too many different capabilities. Go to Joe Public and ask him to tell you what a typical iPhone can do, and what a typical Android phone can do and he'll get most of the iPhone features straight out, but when asked which of the Android specific features belong with which handset, he'll be far less sure.
- lack of upgrades. Apple's aggressive support policy puts other handset manufacturers to shame. End of story. My two year old 3GS runs the latest iOS fine. My wife's Android phone, only one year old, had update support removed about a month after she got it and is still stuck on 2.1 (SE Xperia X10 Mini Pro).
- variable handset quality - this was actually a feature on a consumer watchdog programme over here in the UK about return rates on Android handsets from companies such as HTC, and the poor customer service they entail.
- handset size - this will be the point many of you won't like. Of the few people I know who have Android phones, most have gone for the Samsung Galaxy S II or similar. Of those people, most, including my own dad, dislike the handsets after a while because they're too big. Awesome screen, no doubt, but too big.

Just my 2p's worth. Like I said, anecdotal, but from a workplace of about 90 employees, the vast majority with smartphones have iPhone 4 or 4s handsets. Hardly any androids, and still quite a few "feature" phones in the mix.

Representative cross section over here in the UK I think.
I think OS has assumed as much following and passion as soccer or rugby. Some techies are nothing more than diehard fans, whether Android, iphone or Windows. Imagine, statistics being pulled out of thin air to support claims.
0 Votes
+ -
Android sales. Oh. Wait. They don't. So why compare them to Apple? That's right, it's so you can make it look like Apple isn't totally and utterly dominating the market by pretending an operating system is a telephone.
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
@baggins_z

The chart says Apple and Android. The text says "Google (and its Android handset partners)." So what's your beef?

Google does make money off Android for devices that license the Google software package. It also makes advertising dollars from all Android phones, which are tied to various Google services.

And you accuse me of trying to "make it look like Apple isn't totally and utterly dominating the market." Um, did you read the post? The part where I said: "In the United States smartphone market, Apple has already won. Decisively. Here's how complete the domination is..."

If you're going to troll, please at least pretend to make some sense.
0 Votes
+ -
Gotta admit...
vulpine@... 27th Jan
@Ed Bott: ... Baggins' complaint really doesn't make sense. I wonder if even he knows what he was trying to say?
In this case it ends up being kind of misleading to quote one quarter's sales and act like it's the whole picture. It's pretty clear that the iPhone numbers for that quarter were inflated by pent up demand waiting for the next phone to come out. Overall, it would make more sense to compare averages over the last few quarters, or to give the numbers for each of them. Of course, the iPhone 4s could be a regularly highly in demand phone, but we can't really tell from the numbers for its first quarter on sale. We have to wait for it to be available for another quarter or two.
@CFWhitman I agree that more than one quarter will show a far better picture but I do find it funny that you claim Apple's numbers are so high due to pent up demand for a new version. I find that funny because all we heard when the 4S was announce was how it was a complete disappointment.
You based this story off of one joe blow's site that claims apple is leading? You have GOT TO BE KIDDING? Seriously? Do a little more searching out there and you'll see that android is dominating. On a article from bizjournals it shows that android increased it's market share to 46.3% (up by 4.4%) while apple increased it's share to 28.1% up a paultry 1%. I'm willing to be this is an attempt to manipulate the market by apple and the media is more than willing to help. GET YOUR FACTS STRAIGHT. http://www.bizjournals.com/sanjose/news/2011/12/05/android-phones-iphones-grow-market.html
@sej69 it don't matter right now, as WP 7 will be the dominant platform by June 2013. nokia is looking to sell 100 million Windows Phones this year and 200 million next year. Those numbers alone will prove which phone will rule the air.
@Stephen-B
So much MS based trolling.
Patanjali we get email from our vendors, on a regular basis. Microsoft is confident that Nokia will ship that many phones globally. If those numbers are correct, WP could easily jump into the number 1 spot. I seriously hope these are accurate numbers, as it would prove my thought to be correct. I love WP7 on my 5 phones, but I love it on my Lumia 710 the most. I honestly can't wait till the Lumia 900 launches, and I'm going top try and be the first person locally to get one.
@Stephen-B
posting here is not enough. Buying 5 WP7 is too little, you should buy at least 20, and also for your mom, wife, childrens, relatives, etc; you need to beef up your effort, 200 millions still is a distant figure...
@Stephen-B

Nokia will do a great service to itself and it's shareholders and millions of satisfied users, if they restrict the Windows Phone usage to a tiny fragment of their products.
Nokia has much better choice to develop and support their own Symbian OS.

That said, I wonder if someone at Microsoft even dreams that Nokia will commit suicide to please them. They just could not pay Nokia that much.

But... **** happens, of course.
0 Votes
+ -
@sej69: The article to which you linked was for the three months ending last October, during two months in which people were waiting for the iPhone 4S, so your argument is seriously out of date.

Talking about getting your facts straight...
@sej69 Yeah right, we are to believe that Ed is doing anything to help Apple, get real.
Mobile phone stats are getting to be worse than browser stats. I know Ed was referring to US market. However, I'm curious what folks think about the IDC predictions at http://www.idc.com/getdoc.jsp?containerId=prUS22762811. These are also backed up by Gartner and at least one other firm.
@CochranMA I honesyly do not seeWP7 losing 40% markrtshare between 2013, and 2015.The memo we got was Nokia was on track to ship 100 million phone this year and by the end of next year they should be near 300 million WP7 phones. There are supposed to be new models every 6 months, that are years ahead of the competition.
@Stephen-B I guess you are getting way ahead of yourself. You are saying ship not purchase. Its two different things. Lets see the numbers first before you claim something.
@Stephen-B Yeah, we are supposed to believe some memo about shipped units, right.
0 Votes
+ -
Nothing like year-old references
vulpine@... 27th Jan
@CochranMA: ... or are you saying you're waiting for this year's numbers for comparison?
0 Votes
+ -
Geeks Missing the POINT
matenai 27th Jan
Peter you are probably right in all the techinical issues you raise. Frankly I am disappointed in my iPhone 4s. It is my first Apple phone and I find that is rates a C in old smartphone features. I had the first HTC windows phone about 5 years ago...it worked better on most phone basics and email. I went to a Blackberry. Loved how it handled human aspects of life, simplicity, documentation, email, phone features, address book, to name a few. To go from the Blackberry to the iPhone was a significant STEP down in meeting my EXISTING expectations. So you can be happy to hear that. What I have found that impresses me about the iphone is the apps...no credit to Apple but to their network of developers. Many of those are the same folks doing Android apps. The difference I think is the QA done on the apps by Apple vs. the Android community. That is the bugginess factor commented on by others. So all this being said I think the ideal product would be a Blackberry with Apple Apps! They tried and failed miserably because their hardware cannot support the environment.

But let's leave the technical for the moment. What sells the iPhone and makes it the market leader is all about image and ego. This is what Jobs understood best and it represented his own ideology. It is integrating the rebel spirit appeal into a product and leveraging that against that part of the population with the most rebellious frame of mind at their age...the young. I know because I was one caught with the infection when I was young and the MacIntosh first came out. It was a much better user environment than the PC and it also had rebel appeal. I converted my whole business unit to Macs! Loved it and still do. But I had to move back to PCs because I needed to do WORK things with my computer not play things...not withstanding Apple also fostered the entire image world set of tools directly and indirectly. But work required a fuller palette of everyday functions.

So it is with the iPhone. I often consider the option of having an iPad and a Blackberry...but alas a real good platform has bitten the dust due to image over function. Read the article again...the smartphone market is not a technical market it one driven by perceptions...having an iPhone is a cool thing and associated with wealth even if it is not the smart thing to have it appeals to the those who have wealth and the wanna-bees . The Android is the appeal of the masses in spite of it's more advanced technical capabilities and flexibility. It is a shame but it is reality. No matter how much it glows and dominates in function it will be along time before it can out stage the glitz the iPhone has garnered no matter how unworthy it may be in the eyes of true geeks.
@matenai

Its not all about image and ego, those are emotional and derogatory arguments put forward by android fans all the time. Its about simplicity and functionality.

The iPhone is a better user experience, and has better apps. Its not about QA either, since when the same app is available on both platforms, by the same author, the iPhone app is clearly superior.

The reason is not the OS, but the development platform. On Android its JAVA, which has historically suffered performance issues and continues to do so. Its the same reason apps are slower on the Blackberry. Screens lock up, scrolling pages are jerky etc. Higher end android phones compensate for this by throwing huge horsepower at the problem, much like fast PC's running bloated apps. Good most of the time but still not quite as good as a well-written app.

Apps written for the iPhone MUST be written in ObjectiveC, a close variant of C, which provides high performance apps at the cost of slightly more difficult software development.

Any fool can bang out a Java app, and the results are apparent in the Android marketplace.

That's why the iPhone will continue to dominate with almost every market segment that can afford one.
@happyfun and WP 7 handily beats the iJunk phone o all those points. The hub centric UI, the ease of use, the security, and stability. Nothing out there currently beats WP 7, and by the time they do catch up WP 8 will be out.
@happyfun: You say that nothing beats WP7, and yet WP7 is selling worse even than Blackberry at a very measly 2%. If WP7 is so good, why isn't it selling?

Well, I can tell you one reason; like it or not. Windows Mobile has a terrible reputation and there are a lot of former WM user who are afraid WP is no different--just made prettier. Me? I simply don't know if it is or not.

WP needs to overcome that reputation first and the only way to do that is to prove itself to more people in the same manner the iPhone proved itself when it first came out. WP is going to have a slow start, there's no denying that, but it does have a chance to progress and grow. Personally, as it does I believe the real victim of its growth will be Android, not iOS. But that's just me.
Facts are facts, opinions... well atleast I live in America and we are all still allowed to express them last I checked. I am familiar with both mobile OS's and yes my current and future phones will be android based(especially with the more polished ics/4.0 release). While it is true that Androids have have been buggy, and difficult? to operate for the general masses(I get questioned almost everyday by my coworkers on how to do this and that on their Android phones) their selling points are their flexibility and customiseability. The main reason I hear from real, general public for why they chose the iPhone is not their popularity but their ease of use and the "one size fits all" in other words their standardization. Obviously most people will gravitate towards the path of least resistance so Apple should be holding on to that lead for a little while longer. But! The tech industry always changes and as Android goes through its growing pains I believe they will close that gap, Ice Cream Sandwich aka Android 4.0 is a huge step towards a standard OS across all their devices and as we are starting to see on the hardware front even the phones coming out this year are getting closer in specs across all brands with fewer derivatives. Let Apple enjoy their lead, I just hope they have one hell of a plan for their next phone (iPhone 5?) because I am quite sure Google is not content playing second Fiddle.

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix
ie8 fix