Between the Lines

Larry Dignan, Andrew Nusca and Rachel King

Are netbooks quietly driving us toward cloud computing?

By | March 2, 2009, 2:09am PST

Summary: Cost is the primary factor driving the rise and spread of netbooks. Businesses are even starting to get on board. However, the proliferation of netbooks will quietly drive us into the arms of thin client infrastructure and cloud computing.

I want to be completely honest about something: I can’t stand netbooks. Netbooks have drawn a surprising amount of attention from corporate users, so TechRepublic has tested virtually every netbook on the market and in the process I’ve kicked the tires on all of them.

While I have a few favorites - the Acer Aspire (right) and the HP Mini 2140 - all of them are essentially useless for me. When I’m mobile I prefer a smartphone for instant access, and when I sit down I’d prefer to use a full laptop in order to get real work done.

Despite the fact that a netbook is not a viable choice for me and a lot of other power users like me, it’s impossible to ignore the growing influence of the netbook phenomenon - and it still hasn’t peaked. Here are a few metrics that demonstrate the growth and trajectory of netbooks:

  • Taiwan’s Market Intelligence Centre (MIC) had 2008 worldwide sales of netbooks at 8 million units, and predicted sales of 18 million units in 2009, which is 128% growth.
  • Gartner’s netbook numbers are more conservative. It predicted that worldwide netbook shipments will grow from 5.2 million in 2008 to 7.8 million in 2009. That’s 50% growth, compared to just 15% growth for the entire laptop market and a 21% decline in shipments for desktop PCs.
  • IDC reported that netbooks accounted for 30% of all laptop sales in Europe during the fourth quarter of 2008, with 3.6 million netbooks sold.
  • In 2008, netbook sales were still roughly about 10% of the global PC market, in terms of units sold. That leaves a lot of room for growth.

Last week Intel CEO Paul Otellini called Netbooks the “only bright spot of growth in the PC industry,” and said, “Not only will [a netbook] appeal to people in emerging markets as first-time machines, it will also offer an alternative to somebody that wouldn’t have bought a higher-end laptop even in mature markets.”

Meanwhile, Gartner analyst Mika Kitagawa said, “It looks like [netbooks] are definitely stronger than regular notebook growth rates and may be eating up traditional notebook shipments.”

As netbooks continue to spread and become a common option for entry-level users, road warriors, and users who primarily need just e-mail and the Web, netbooks are going to inevitably change the computing world. Why? It’s because of their limitations.

Nearly all netbooks suffer from the following drawbacks:

  • Low-power CPUs that can’t handle extensive multi-tasking
  • Minimal local storage (often SSDs with 32 GB or less)
  • Cramped keyboards
  • Small screens with quirky resolutions

All four of these issues are related to the smaller footprint and the lower power consumption of the netbooks. And these factors are ultimately what make the netbooks so cheap - under $500 and even as low as $300. And since the price tag is the primary factor driving netbook sales, these limitations are not likely to disappear any time soon.

As a result, the limited local processing and limited local storage available on netbooks are likely to become catalysts for transferring more processing and storage to the data center, where companies such as Google, Microsoft, and Amazon are currently building up large reservoirs of computing resources.

Those three companies will certainly be beneficiaries of this trend - especially in terms of their cloud storage initiatives - but so will many other companies that host Software-as-a-Service applications, hosted storage, and cloud computing services.

Enterprises will also exploit this trend to gain efficiency and manageability improvements by being able to centralize more applications, and in some cases even migrating to more of a thin client architecture. Corporate users have often resisted this scenario because it took away some of the flexibility they were used to on their PCs. However with netbooks, this type of centralization would actually help speed up and simplify storage and applications for users on their netbooks, and so it’s much more likely to be accepted.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

Jason Hiner is the Editor in Chief of TechRepublic. He writes about the products, people, and ideas that are revolutionizing business with technology.

Disclosure

Jason Hiner

Jason Hiner has nothing to disclose. He doesn't hold investments in the technology companies he covers.

Biography

Jason Hiner

Jason Hiner is the Editor in Chief of TechRepublic, an online trade publication and peer-to-peer community for IT leaders. He is an award-winning journalist who examines the latest trends and asks the big questions about the technology industry. He previously worked as an IT manager in the health care industry.

You can also find him on Twitter, , Facebook, and at JasonHiner.com.

Talkback Most Recent of 13 Talkback(s)

  • Save the Netbooks
    I've been saying for a long time that netbooks and cloud computing are intrinsically linked - indeed we developed something akin to a nettop 5 or 10 years ago at Australian Online Solutions but dropped it because web tools like SquirrelMail just didn't cut the mustard compared to Gmail and its ilk (that and we're a services company!).

    A netbook (a portmanteau of "Internet Notebook") is a single-purpose device whose hardware and software is tuned for web browsing. Adequate RAM and CPU are required (as opposed to "abundant") but minimal local storage and graphics are called for. Indeed in terms of data loss and breaches read/write local storage is a liability!

    Pixels are important though (if not physical screen size) and it's good to see that devices like MSI's new 13.4 inch X320 are finally shedding the shackles imposed by vendors like Intel and Microsoft, whereby discount chips and licenses were only offered for physically small devices so as to pigeon hole them and avoid cannibalising premium sales.

    There's nothing wrong with having an expensive Apple-style netbook (which by shedding features for supporting general-purpose use, like optical drives, magnetic media, graphics hardware, etc. are smaller, cheaper and run longer) and as you will see this year, nothing wrong with having a cheap, truly embedded single-purpose device running Linux on Arm. The third category (basically today's netbooks) fall somewhere in between.

    I expect the industry to settle on ~13.3 inch ARM devices that run customised linux distributions for a (business) day at a time, for us power users to opt for more capable generic devices and for the distinction between a "netbook" and a "notebook" to blur over the coming years (as it did with the "migration" from laptop to notebook).

    In summary, netbooks are facilitating cloud computing as much as they are being facilitated by it. It is a symbiotic relationship and neither would be the same without the other (a netbook 10 years ago for example would be of limited utility without SaaS like Google Apps and similarly, netbooks can unlock much of the value proposition of cloud computing).

    That's part of the reason why we've formed the 'Save the Netbooks' grassroots campaign (http://www.savethenetbooks.com/) to protect the term, though the primary motivator is our disdain for intellectual property abuse (the netbook trademark was more akin to a minefield in the intellectual property wasteland than a valuable asset for the taking in our opinion).

    Sam

    PS ABI Research predict 35 million units will ship this year rising to 139 million in 2013.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    samjohnston
    2nd Mar 2009
  • Save the Netbooks but not for those reasons
    I don't think most pundits are "getting" the driving force behind the popularity of netbooks. Netbook users (like myself) use them because of the complete freedom they offer for very little money. Focusing on cloud services will KILL netbooks, not help them. Tethering us to online services in order to accomplish our tasks is nearly as bad as tethering us to a big heavy laptop or tethering us to a desktop. We want self-contained, self-sufficient, extreme portability for a reasonable price.

    Also, anything with a screen bigger than 10" is no longer a netbook. It is a mini-notebook. If the machine gets bigger than a large book, it defeats the purpose of having a netbook. A netbook doesn't require a laptop case to tote. You can throw it in a pocket on your suitcase.

    On my inexpensive netbook with extended battery, I can watch two full-length feature films during a cross-country flight and still have enough battery left to type up a document or two using Open Office. I have the same applications I use on my desktop in the space of a hardcover book and I can use it for nearly six hours sitting under a tree in the park. That freedom is the appeal of netbooks.

    If all of my apps were thin-client and cloud-based, I'd be sitting on that flight or under that tree twiddling my thumbs with no Internet connection. There is no freedom in that. Netbooks + thin-client/cloud = disaster.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    BillDem
    1st Apr 2009
  • Define "real work"
    Only comment I can make is that your assumption about what "real work" is sounds a lot like a mainframer when they first saw a PC.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    richsc@...
    2nd Mar 2009
  • Both netbooks AND smartphones
    Netbooks & smartphones are likely to cause companies to re-evaluate their computing strategies.

    By moving to browser-based/cloud applications, companies can:

    1. reduce their support costs (software updates are propagated to all clients instantaneously).

    2. provide OS (Windows/Linux/OS X) & device (smartphone/netbook/notebook/desktop) flexibility.

    3. simplify data backup (performed at the server level, instead of the client level).

    4. enable workforce collaboration.

    By utilizing technologies like HTML5, Gears, Native Client, etc., browser-based applications also begin to approach desktop application functionality & performance.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    linuser
    2nd Mar 2009
  • Of course they are not...
    just google OSX + "netbook name" or windows 7 + "netbook name".

    It's clear people want to run an entire OS on a netbook, and not just some gateway to the Internet App.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    croberts
    2nd Mar 2009
  • The question is...
    ...what do they do with an entire OS besides use it as a gateway to the internet App. Cut the data cord on one of these people and I almost guarantee the computer becomes absolutely useless for them.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    storm14k
    2nd Mar 2009
  • I can name a few
    Spreadsheets
    Presentations
    Games
    Videos (aka ripped DVD stored on an SD card)
    Music
    VPN client to office network

    Notice I left out email... I think most mail systems forward mail to multiple destinations (aka Exchange and Gmail, yahoo, etc) so on-the-go it is better to get email on a portable device like an iPhone or PDA.

    ZDNet Gravatar
    croberts
    2nd Mar 2009
  • I'm not saying netbook users don't want all that
    But you'd be wrong to say that is ALL they want. With the exception of maybe presentations, because full sized laptops still and will probably continue to dominate for that due to the strength of the video chip, all of those things you mention are things people want to do on a netbook both locally and via the cloud.

    People do want spreadsheets, but they want a way to share them too. People do want games, but they know a netbook will limit the experience of local games, so internet games would be more popular. People do want videos, but they want both local and streaming equally (Hulu has a nice reservoir of free so-so movies and TV shows). People want music, but they want both local and streaming as well. And they want access to work, but they are just as likely to use a terminal server as a VPN, if not more so considering the costs involved.

    Yes, there is more than one way to skin this cat, and no one method will be the only method. Local computing will not disappear but it's not realistic to think you can get away with only local computing anymore. As things get faster on the cloud, the cost savings of cloud computing versus local computing, not to mention the increased content it allows, will force people to rethink the way they do things.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    Michael Kelly
    2nd Mar 2009
  • The next shift
    will happen when the devices become capable of
    more input methods. The technology for voice
    recognition, handwrite recognition, gestures
    etc are improving, fast. Cue Vistas voice
    recognition/dictation, Windows tablets ability
    to recognize handwritten text etc. The future
    devices will be tablets equipped with an OS
    capable of fast input. It's the keyboard which
    is quickly becoming obsolete, not the OS. The
    role of the OS will shift, but in the near
    future you'll not be able to shift
    voice/handwrite/gesture recognition to the
    cloud. It seems inevitable that applications
    will increasingly move to the cloud.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    honeymonster
    2nd Mar 2009
  • I see it the other way around
    Cloud computing is driving us towards netbooks. People aren't buying netbooks expecting cloud computing to follow, people are buying netbooks because cloud computing (and the fact that most local tasks are not processor intensive) allows them to.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    Michael Kelly
    2nd Mar 2009
  • RE: Are netbooks quietly driving us toward cloud computing?
    My Acre Aspire had 160 gig hard drive. With Open
    office it handles all my normal needs. For
    traveling it is better than anything else that I have
    tried. Loading OSX is easy and much improves
    speed and usefulness.

    I purchased it instead of a full size laptop and
    saved $3-400. When I get home I just transfer
    pictures and videos from my camera to the
    desktop and away I go.

    i was surprised how usefull it is as I started with
    an attitude much the same as the article.

    XP is slow on the machine but OSX is not.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    gertruded
    2nd Mar 2009
  • RE: Are netbooks quietly driving us toward cloud computing?
    Hi Jason, my name is Josh and I'm with the Symantec
    GoEverywhere project. I liked you article and you
    bring up a few problems with NetBooks that I'd like to
    address because I feel we at GoEverywhere have the
    solution.

    GoEverywhere is a webtop being created as an incubator
    project at Symantec (currently in FREE beta http://cli.gs/UtJZWm). Our webtop connects your SaaS
    subscriptions to one account and via a windows like
    interface givse you access to them without having to
    open multiple windows or tabs in your browser.

    "Low-power CPUs that can?t handle extensive multi-
    tasking" With GoEverywhere your online personal
    workspace does the heavy lifting and connects to your
    SaaS accounts.

    "Minimal local storage (often SSDs with 32 GB or
    less)" With SaaS you don't need to install any
    software beyond your favorite browser and your files
    are stored online & accessible from anywhere with an
    internet connection. GoEverywhere is hosted at
    Symantec so you don't need to download anything, just
    connect it all together and use the internet (via
    SaaS) as your PC and GoEverywhere as your OS.

    If you switch back to your home PC, or your netbook
    gets lost stole, damaged, etc and you get a new one
    you don't have to reconfigure anything. Just sign back
    into GoEverywhere and you're right back to where you
    were.

    Sorry we can't help with the other 2,but if we make
    something that can help, I'll be sure to let you know.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    GoEverywhere
    2nd Mar 2009
  • ZDNet Gravatar
    Vahidm
    2nd Mar 2009

Talkback - Tell Us What You Think

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources