ie8 fix

Between the Lines

Larry Dignan, Andrew Nusca and Rachel King

Firefox's next big innovation: A new OS-like interface

By | July 28, 2010, 3:30am PDT

Summary: Firefox has been losing momentum to Google Chrome in 2010, but a new innovation called Tab Candy could give Firefox a big leap forward.

During 2010, Firefox has had much of its momentum as an alternative Web browser stolen by Google Chrome. However, a new Firefox innovation called Tab Candy will make Firefox act more like a operating system, with much-improved multitasking and sharing capabilities. In fact, if the Firefox team can pull off all of the features of Tab Candy that it recently demonstrated, it would leapfrog Chrome in functionality.

The Tab Candy functionality is being spearheaded by Aza Raskin, the Head of UX at Mozilla Labs. Raskin is the son of Macintosh creator Jef Raskin and he joined Mozilla in 2008 when his software company Humanized merged with Mozilla.

Raskin said, “How many of us keep tabs open as reminders of something we want to do or read later? We’re all suffering from infoguilt. We need a way to organize browsing, to see all of our tabs at once, and focus on the task at hand.”

With that mind, here’s what Tab Candy can do:

  • Organize tabs into groups that you can name and position on a desktop-like view (Figure A)
  • Save tab groups to look at later
  • Search through your tabs
  • Have multiple profiles so that you can sign into the same site with different logins in two different tab groups
  • Share tabs or tab groups between different computers and devices (Figure D)
  • Share tabs or tab groups with other users
  • Set up a shared tab group where several users can co-browse and see what each other is looking at on the screen
  • Choose colors or image backgrounds to distinguish different tab groups (Figure C)

Screenshots

Figure A: Basic Tab Candy interface

Figure B: Tab Candy can handle lots of tab groups

Figure C: To distinguish between different tab group you can give them a color or background

Figure D: Tab Candy will also let you share tabs across different computers and devices

Video demo

Here is Raskin’s seven-minute demo of Tab Candy:

Sanity check

Raskin has perfectly articulated the workflow and tab overload problem in today’s Web browsers, and his Tab Candy vision of innovating the browser experience would be a major step forward. And, Firefox needs a big shot in the arm. Not only is Google Chrome leaching away more and more Firefox users, it has also stolen away Firefox’s reputation as the browser bringing the most innovation to the Web experience.

My only question with Tab Candy is if and when it will make it into Firefox. In the lackluster announcement of Firefox 4 in May, the Firefox team had Tab Candy listed in light gray at the bottom of its list of new features (giving no indication of its importance). Raskin said “The reason why Tab Candy was listed in grey in the product plan is that there are still some implementation challenges to be solved and a couple user experience questions to be answered for us to be able to commit to TabCandy being in Firefox 4.”

Part of the challenge may be that Tab Candy is being developed entirely in HTML, Javascript, and CSS, and what they are trying to accomplish is extremely ambitious. The other part may be that the Mozilla leadership hasn’t honed in on how big of a deal Tab Candy would be for users.

Make no mistake, this is Firefox’s best shot at competing with Chrome, especially since the rest of Firefox 4 feels a lot like a copy of Chrome. Launching Firefox 4 with Tab Candy should be Mozilla’s top priority.

Also see

This article was originally published on TechRepublic.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

Jason Hiner is the Editor in Chief of TechRepublic. He writes about the products, people, and ideas that are revolutionizing business with technology.

Disclosure

Jason Hiner

Jason Hiner has nothing to disclose. He doesn't hold investments in the technology companies he covers.

Biography

Jason Hiner

Jason Hiner is the Editor in Chief of TechRepublic, an online trade publication and peer-to-peer community for IT leaders. He is an award-winning journalist who examines the latest trends and asks the big questions about the technology industry. He previously worked as an IT manager in the health care industry.

You can also find him on Twitter, , Facebook, and at JasonHiner.com.

75
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

RE: Firefox's next big innovation: A new OS-like interface
tomlin21-24319035676893835085146735905770 11th Oct
Hey what a exceptional submit I've manifest across and therefore are convinced me I've been searching for out for this equal form of publish for previously each week and barely stumbled on this. Many thanks an incredible football jersey offer and might make an attempt to try to look for additional postings from you.
What a great idea. this will be such a big help to me, since I work in several places on several machines.

It should not be rushed out, since it could change the way I use the browser, so if its rushed through it could get very messy.
@willt1984@...
I can hardly wait for this! I love researching, and I always preshop for things keeping many tabs open at once (I love how FF currently will save my tabs so I can shut off my computer to come back to my browsing session...something IE8 doesn't seem to do). Keep up the good work FF!
@willt1984@... OMG... this will be perfect. I want it now, but I'll wait till it's perfected. I'm not coder but I could definitely add the input that could help move this along! grin
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
Aza emailed me only a few days ago to a link to his new creation. I said in reply: "It's got a very 'desktop' feel to it... it's like a desktop within a desktop". Seeing as the desktop OS is now more often than not just a 'looking glass' for the web and your online content, this takes on almost the values of what Chrome OS could achieve.
0 Votes
+ -
Staff
@zwhittaker Totally agree. This is what a Web-based OS should look like.
0 Votes
+ -
Very nice feature! This is something every browser needs!
@joarobles Not tab candy, but in IE8 there is a feature called related tabs and if you open tabs as done in the video, the tabs are grouped together and given a similar color. You can even click on of those related tabs , right click and can select close related tabs. Well, because this is from MS, people can ignore it. Had it been from any other company, it would be the greatest thing next to life on earth.
@jagansai Ome feature doesn't make up for that fact that IE8 is slow in comparison to all the other browsers (think "JavaScript thick" clients), missing things like the canvas tag, a robust and free extension community, etc., etc.


In short, IE8 sucks, one UI feature isn't going to change that.

-M
0 Votes
+ -
@jagansai

The website I must use for work requires that I use IE. Win 7 has IE8 installed, and I've used the function your talking about. But it is nowhere NEAR the scope of what this project is aiming to be.

First, IE makes them a "group" simply by placing the tabs next to each other. You can do this in any modern browser (rearrange tabs so they are next to each other). Next, it colors them the same color. Big, freaking deal. I have a small FF extension that also colors tabs spawned from other tabs the same colors, but also colors tabs that completely unrelated, OTHER colors!

IE is a pretty lackluster browser.
0 Votes
+ -
Or, you know...
wolf_z 28th Jul 2010
...just don't open so many tabs at once?

You have 50 tabs open at once? Really? Why?

Seriously? Why do you need so many tabs open at once? It's not like you need them all at once. This Tab Candy sounds like crack for ADHD types...
0 Votes
+ -
@wolf_z

One can make the claim that all porn addicts have ADHD, and they seem to me to be the ones who would be most likely to have that many tabs open. Personally I never have more than 8 or so open, and that's when I'm too lazy to close them.
0 Votes
+ -
Eh?
wolf_z 28th Jul 2010
@Michael Kelly

Why would porn addicts have that many open tabs? I mean how many movies can you watch at once, how many pictures can you look at at the same time?

Seems like if you're looking at naked women you'd want to give each one your undivided attention! (laughing)
@Michael Kelly

At first I thought your comment was a tangent, even though the correlation you mention is strong. Then I realized the connection. It is the name "Tab Candy". Seriously, that name has luscivious overtones in our culture. Hey, Firefox, if you're reading, then rethink the product name. Maybe that is why it was in grey! wink
@Michael Kelly: Why is it that a new option for people who browse a certain way led to a porn discussion? I've been using more than 10 tabs at a time since I was a teenager, at the time when it took 5 minutes or more for them to load. Different doesn't mean bad, and multiple tabs does not indicate a population of porn fiends that need 50 tabs of nudie pics. Open your mind, and think before you type!

Using the web for porn is an individual choice, and one that every person has the right to choose to use, or not. That said, I think that there is a large group of people in the United States alone that knows what it is like to be looking at that many web pages. It can be frustrating when you have to actually click on each tab to find the one you're looking for, and know that you can't close the other tabs because you need them for whatever you're doing at the time.

@ all skeptics: If you don't like the idea, use another browser! It's just like the played out debate between Mac and PC. Pick what you like, and be happy with it, and I will do the same!
@Michael Kelly What a couple of morons or empty headed baboons you two are. 90% of people here on ZDNet are tech litterate junkies or more likely normal people and the last thing on their mind is porn or even knowing what ADHD is. That said, it sounds like you two are both afflicted with these diseases and need some therapy bad!!!
@wolf_z

"You have 50 tabs open at once? Really? Why?"

info-guilt? wink

Sometimes you want to get back to something later, but don't think it deserves a bookmark, I guess.

I currently have 84 open.

I've had 100+ open before, and I think at one time I hit 200.
0 Votes
+ -
Info-guilt gone wild
klumper 28th Jul 2010
@CobraA1

Work or play, 100+ open tabs is excessive, 200 = ridiculous short of porn indulgence gone wild (lol @ Wolf wink yup). At that point you might want to start questioning your organizational or prioritization abilities - or uh, lay off the fantasy strokes. silly

It is a modern wonder and joy to be able to run lots of browser instances concurrently; most of us have been indulging as such for years. But like everything else, there are - or should be - practical limits. ''Info guilt'' overload will likely drive one bonkers if left unabated. Rein it in! [if you know what's good for you]

You heard it here first.
Dr. Klumper
Not porn, but a bunch of stuff.

-A few with ZDNet

-A few with WoW

-A few with forums

-A few others for other purposes

-And yeah, sometimes tabs do act as TODO placeholders for things I want to do or haven't decided to do.

It all adds up.
@CobraA1 When I get shopping ebay and various web sites it's not uncommon to have 200 tabs open total. In fact I think nothing of a 100 tabs being open and about 75 is average. I also tend to use session saver as a form of bookmarks. This would make my life so much easier!!!

97 tabs now with thirty of those ebay! haha...
0 Votes
+ -
I'm with you.
ye 28th Jul 2010
@wolf_z: Puzzling why people have so many tabs open.
@ye If you're in a work evironment with lots of contexts -> many tabs. That's been the case for me (information technology in a very large server environment - thousands os hosts)

At home, different story, a few will do. But I do succumb to "infoguilt" here and there.

-M
@ye I would probably have tons on at home as I "research" my chosen specialty for a home business I am starting. As it is, I currently close several tabs or toss them into my bookmarks hoping I will find them later as I read about various things I am trying to learn.

For example, I opened a good six tabs just trying to learn about signal boosters. Narrowed it down to two to save and then opened another eight relating to actual products based on what I had just learned. Which I think I narrowed down to two or three as well, but the stack and path of my tabs get a bit more extensive than that at times. I just wanted to illustrate.
@ye I dunno...I guess some of you don't really use the internet heavily. I can easily look up info on something and end up opening a ton of tabs from the first page because I want to go back and read related links throughout the page. Then on one of those pages I might find more related material. Most of the time I just open the tab and keep reading the current article.

I don't want to stop reading and go to the new page and then come back and two levels deep it really becomes impossible to finish anything. So its quite easy to open a large number of tabs and this type of grouping system would be terrific.
@wolf_z and others

Let's see... Right now, I have open:

2 tabs on CSS hacks for a Web site I'm working on
1 tab to preview said site
1 tab for Lynda.com
4 tabs for some shopping I have to do for work
2 tabs for reviews of said item
3 tabs open for stock agencies
1 tab for this site
2 tabs for an article I'm editing
1 tab to monitor network traffic
4 tabs for things I should read but don't care to bookmark or print
1 tab for e-mail to check my bulk box
2 tabs to search for a solution to an ongoing IT problem

That's 24 tabs, all for work. No porn. When you wear many hats, you have many tabs. Many days, I wish my work required fewer scattered tabs, but that would get boring. Don't assume your work flow matches that of others.

@Michael Kelly: You're too lazy to close tabs? Maybe you wouldn't be so tired if you weren't spending your time thinking about porn.
@wolf_z When I am researching a topic of cross referencing site or when christmas shopping.

It not unusual for me to have 20 to 30 tabs open.
An no I have not got ADHD.
@wolf_z: Everyone browses differently. I often have many tabs open at once while I am doing research for school, emailing friends and family, and checking on bills. This makes it easy for me to be dealing with 20 tabs or more, and I would love to have the ability to save them all so that I can move around efficiently. Why talk down on something that gives people more options?

I've been using Mozilla Firefox for 6 years now, and I have no reason to stop now. In fact, I haven't even downloaded Chrome. If Tab Candy ends up doing all that was outlined in the video, I think we will all be witnessing a new age in browsing the web! Innovation is something to encourage, not stifle with close-minded comments. Keep it going Aza!
@wolf_z

Research and shopping and sharing web sites for me. Beats the heck out of the color-coded Garanimal tabs. Let's see, what was red for?
I guess a good analogy would be setting your screen resolution so low that you have to use scroll bars to see the whole page.
It's an add-on for people that would use it. Obviously, since you don't need it, you can use another browser or choose not to add it on.
Labeling people who might use this feature is not needed.
0 Votes
+ -
@wolf_z when doing a good amount of research, it's not hard to have 50 tabs open. For instance, when compiling notes from 10 different sources of information on one subject is very easy to do.
www.dfwsupergeek.com
0 Votes
+ -
Not impressed at all
UseYourHead 28th Jul 2010
Tab Candy is very intrusive and rude as it takes up all your desktop to function properly. The trend of web browsing is that user opens a browser window with multiple tabs and navigates to a particular tab with thumbnails.
0 Votes
+ -
KISS
CobraA1 28th Jul 2010
I love the concept - but he *should* think KISS. Some of the features near the end of the video looked cool, but may bring information overload back into something that's supposed to make tabbed browsing simpler.

I do hope he focuses on the basic features and doesn't try to do everything all at once as well. Get the basics implemented and into the browser first - put the other ideas in later. Otherwise, it will never really get done.
@CobraA1
KISS is correct. I want Firefox to be fast, simple and reliable. These concepts have been lost in the recent versions of Firefox. Nobody needs 50 open windows.
0 Votes
+ -
@CobraA1 - I agree with the last part. I hope they are careful about the suggestions and additional info. I was even wary of the Awesome Bar when they first implemented it, but the execution actually turned out to be quite useful.

I suppose I just need to adapt to new technology. Just like I adapted to torrents usurping IRC...

@cdlmgmt@...

Firefox is still fast, simple, and reliable. The only people I've known who've complained about any of those things had poorly developed extensions.

Remember when webpages first became mainstream, and all the kids would just throw on a ton of images, animated gifs, and all kinds of bloat?

Also, I may not need 50 windows, you may not need 50 windows, but someone else actually might. But sometimes, I do need a lot of tabs open. If I have a lot of different things I'm trying to do in a short period of time... I need to be able to have the power and ability to do so.

It's like driving. I don't NEED to drive at redline all the time. However, if I NEED to get somewhere and FAST, then I have the ability to.
0 Votes
+ -
That is a pretty cool feature. I could use something like Tab Candy to organize my tabs a bit better. Granted I don't use nearly as many tabs as they do, but having a seperator between news/tech/hobby stuff would be great. Now they need to release a roadmap for FF4 and when it will be released.
Firefox is unstable enough the way it is now, this will really cause problems. (I have tried firefox on 5 different PC's, so it was not just one old PC having problems)
I hate the fact that you have to shut down firefox every 1-3 hours because it takes over all resources (It takes up to 5 minutes to leave the processes and 2-5 to start up again) (I only have 5 active add-ons and never more than 10 tabs open) So before adding more resource hogging feature, they need to stabilize the program.

Luckily I only have to use it at work now since Chrome.
@jcm996 Your computers are ******. 5 minutes, seriously? Google Chrome is such a hack. Their whole 'chrome fast' marketing ploy used the fricking back button. Wow, so very fast. It's as fast as a refresh rate.
only worse! sheesh i theyre betting on this they're in sorry shape...
IE already has a grid view that shows you thumbnails of open tabs. They just need to give you the option of dragging tabs into additional running instances of IE, and include sort-reorder functionality on the Quick Tabs page.
This is just begging to wipe out all your free memory. It would be better to allow multiple pages to open on one icon or favorites tab-group when needed, than keep them all open all the time. I've tried the multiple tabs open at browser start and it kill me every time I open another window.
@dolson@...
wipe out all our free memory? lol...computers coming out now have 6+GB of RAM as a minimum...I've seen $500 boxes at BB and FS that have 12GB of RAM! I could run thousands of tabs and still not run out....muhahahahahahaha
0 Votes
+ -
Fox Tabs Now tab candy
KineticArtist 28th Jul 2010
I love Firefox I dont download alot of extentions or any personas got one nice theme I love just a few extentions mostly related to web development. I wasnt a big fan of tabs when I started using firefox I was still on XP and I figured my taskbar was my "tabs" then I moved to Windows 7 and the taskbar is much different and tabs in my browser made more sense to me and again I got a productivity boost. Then I found an extention called fox tabs that gave me a 3d view of my browser windows similar to what vista and and windows 7 users can do with their desktop and I got another boost to my productivity Yea!

Now we have tab candy coming at us and As I watched raskins video I started to drool, literally started to drool I for one cant wait for Tab Candy... ...well maybe the patched later version.... definetly cools stuff
0 Votes
+ -
Fix the performance and stability (meat and potatoes) problems first then worry about adding "candy". I've been a FF user from the beginning but find myself using Chrome more and more because it is faster and more stable.
"During 2010, Firefox has had much of its momentum as an alternative Web browser stolen by Google Chrome"

And the biggest joke of it is, devious, tricky old Google took Mozilla by surprise by launching Chrome -- when Firefox had loyally promoting Google as its default homepage for years! A classic case of corporate back-stabbing.

The launch of Chrome also came shortly after Google complained to the EU about IE, pretending to be a neutral interested party, and joined the powerful lobby that successfully convinced the EU (arguably the most bloated and corrupt pseudo-democratic administration in the history of human civilisation) to penalise Microsoft.
I like to stay organized. Every product I use focuses me on staying organized. In my non-computer life I am disorganized and I use my computer to help me focus on organization. Therefore, though I rarely open up more than 10 tabs, if those tabs were organized into groups, my needs would be satisfied. I welcome this and would switch back to FF from Chrome as soon as that feature AND speed were improved.
Could there not be tabs which integrate lots of tabs and drop down aka windows with image beside and individual search box,bit like tab candy with out screen take up.
Love it! I also used Foxtabs until the latest update of Firefox made it incompatible. I really miss Foxtabs. Much faster than bookmarks.
0 Votes
+ -
Open a new instance of the browser as a group
fernande-zdnet 28th Jul 2010
The way I manage multiple tabs is by opening a new instance of the browser as a group and put all the new tabs there. When I am done with that group, I close that browser and all my other tabs are still available.
0 Votes
+ -
I Want It I Want It
dl@... 28th Jul 2010
Despite the nay sayers posting here, I want this Eye Candy in FireFox. The video does a great job of showing what Eye Candy can do and it sure seems like a great convenience and productivity enhancer. Go for it Mozilla!
0 Votes
+ -
Not all of us use tabs
akritchie 28th Jul 2010
I'm quite happy opening each window in a separate window. It saves screen space and I can keep things organized, even with a dozen or more windows open at once. It's amazing. This is just more flashy crapware. I only use Firefox because it lets me open Google in a sidebar like IE6 used to do (and that is losing its benefits since the jerks at Google got rid of the plain jane IE6 search page). Other than that, Firefox has no real advantages for me. Spend your time keeping Firefox less bloated instead of the other way around.
I have been playing with Tab Candy for about a week.

I forsee this as Mozilla's attempt to make the browser appear more as an abstraction layer over the host O/S, and allow browser based apps to behave the same way, regardless of underlying O/S.

I expected some puzzled loks from my co-workers when I demoed Tab Candy on my laptop, but, to a person, they saw the opportunity it may provide. A few of them asked me for the link to the download site. So, I guess i will not be the only one trying this out.
0 Votes
+ -
Needs "Remove unused shortcuts"
Earthling2 28th Jul 2010
My desktop is full with shortcuts to web sites and folders with shortcuts and folders full of shortcuts within folders.

Now I'll have a full new surface to fill. Fantastic.

Well, hardly any shortcut is ever used after it is saved. May I suggest another feature then: "remove unused groups", similar to removing unused shortcuts from Windows desktop.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Firefox's next big innovation: A new OS-like interface
tomlin21-24319035676893835085146735905770 11th Oct
Hey what a exceptional submit I've manifest across and therefore are convinced me I've been searching for out for this equal form of publish for previously each week and barely stumbled on this. Many thanks an incredible football jersey offer and might make an attempt to try to look for additional postings from you.

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix