Between the Lines

Larry Dignan, Andrew Nusca and Rachel King

Google, Los Angeles hit speed bumps on move to cloud

By | July 23, 2010, 12:55pm PDT

Summary: The city of Los Angeles’ transition to Google Apps has hit a few bumps in the implementation of the project and that could mean a costly delay.

Google and the city of Los Angeles have hit a speed bump in the full implementation of Google Apps into the city’s various departments and the costs of a delay could top $100,000 - for Google.

Google had a June 30 deadline to get all of Los Angeles’ city employees up and running on Google Apps but that didn’t happen, according to a Marketwatch report. The Los Angeles city council was reportedly told the costs of keeping employees on that old Novell system while the kinks are worked out could exceed $400,000 but Google says the costs will be closer to about $135,000 and that it will cover them.

One of the key issues behind the delay: security concerns by the city’s police department. From the Marketwatch post:

According to a report filed by the Los Angeles Police Department earlier this month, while a technology like Google Apps “may represent savings in hardware purchases and maintenance, and software administration, it also poses certain security concerns.”

In particular, the L.A.P.D., which must meet California Department of Justice security requirements, said in the report that it had concerns about Google Apps’ data encryption, “segregation of city data from other data maintained by Google,” and background checks for Google employees with access to police department information…

In addition, department employees who have been using the software on a pilot basis have experienced delays in receiving their mail, according to the report: “Given that the L.A.P.D. is a 24/7 operation, which relies upon email/Blackberry notifications for public-safety-related incidents across the city, these delays are not acceptable.”

Those are all valid concerns but the city of Los Angeles, in being one of the first to deploy Google Apps into an entire municipality, really should have expected a hiccup or two along the way.

A Google spokesman said that it is pleased the progress so-far on this first-of-its-kind project and that the company is working with the city and the integration company to address and resolve the concerns.

To date, more than 10,000 of the city’s employees have been switched and another 6,000 should transition by mid-August. Work on moving the city’s 13,000 police department employees will follow.

Previous coverage:

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

Sam has been a technology and business blogger for more than 18 years.

Disclosure

Sam Diaz

Sam Diaz has nothing to disclose.

Biography

Sam Diaz

Sam has been a technology and business blogger, reporter and editor at ZDNet, the Washington Post, San Jose Mercury News and Fresno Bee for more than 18 years. He's a member of the National Association of Hispanic Journalists and a graduate of California State University, Fresno.

Talkback Most Recent of 19 Talkback(s)

  • Pathetic
    Google is simply pathetic. Google had plenty of time and resources and yet they still fail. And such a simple task too. Once Apple finish dominating the consumer market and focus on the business market Google will be dead.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    iPad-awan
    23rd Jul 2010
  • Kind of
    @iPad-awan - seems pathetic, agreed. Google had time but I'm not so sure about resources? Yes, they have money, hardware, etc - do they have right people for this kind of work, maybe not yet? They will learn but, as with some other large vendors, they are a little arrogant and think that they already know everything - well, good luck anyway!
    ZDNet Gravatar
    tuomo@...
    23rd Jul 2010
  • Apple will have to take a number to dominate the world...
    @iPad-awan

    For years now, "it has been the year for Linux" (and I'm a fan of Linux). Linux called it first, so you Apple idiots will have to wait (go ahead, iPad-awan, hold your breath) for Linux to knock Microsoft of the enterprise throne, rule for a while, then it can be the "Apple in the enterprise"

    But I will give you this as far as Apple "killing off" Google, I have been very impressed with Apple's search engine thus far!

    BTW, this isn't Google's fail...this is LA's fail. One-third of the way into a migration and a department starts worrying about security???!!! Where were you during the planning stages? Didn't it cross your mind that your sensitive data was gonna be in the same Data Center as God-knows-what?

    This is STRIKINGLY similar to the "iPhone/iPad in the enterprise" debate...forget the fact that employees will be on facebook, games, or other BS all day....some are trying to make the case that because these devices are the latest thing, and alot of consumers have them, well then they must perfect for the enterprise! Let's not worry about the fact that they are about a secure as a half-patched Win 2k box w/ no antivirus.

    Both this LA gone Google and iPad in the enterprise are perfect examples of why Fads need to be kept out of the enterprise Certainly out of government, banking, hospitals, etc.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    SonofaSailor
    23rd Jul 2010
  • Nobody puts 'Google' and 'data security' in one sentence
    Another day, another victim of the "open platfrom" scam.

    You don't let a fox guard your hen house no matter how protective it claims to be. You don't give the sensitive data to Google whose expertise is spying everyone's Wi-Fi, either.

    Hopefully more and more people wake up to the "don't get caught while committing evil" IT Madoff scam.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    LBiege
    24th Jul 2010
  • RE: Google, Los Angeles hit speed bumps on move to cloud
    @LBiege

    Are you for real?
    How many major (and minor) companies entrust their human resources and financial data to third party business who can do it cheaper?

    answer: most of them
    ZDNet Gravatar
    rhonin
    27th Jul 2010
  • RE: Google, Los Angeles hit speed bumps on move to cloud
    @iPad-awan

    Get real.
    This is a "first of it's kind" endeavor and a lot of enterprises including city/goverment agaencies are taking a hard look at this.
    It behooves Google to slow down and get it right. The added cost will more than pay for itself in the long run.
    The concern of the LAPD is more along the lines of a "certification" to ensure that the security and segregation concerns are properly met.

    Let's watch and offer objective criticism, not juvenile commentary.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    rhonin
    27th Jul 2010
  • RE: Google, Los Angeles hit speed bumps on move to cloud
    As I point at Google and laugh, HAH HAH!
    ZDNet Gravatar
    Loverock Davidson
    23rd Jul 2010
  • Google is the end to everything
    I really hope someone takes them out quickly before they have a chance to spread further. Google's wares are nothing but platforms to spy on people for nothing more than making money off of targeted advertising.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    Cylon Centurion
    23rd Jul 2010
  • RE: Google, Los Angeles hit speed bumps on move to cloud
    This one is really horrible
    Why public and government data should be trusted to the company which was caught in intercepting private wifi data?
    Maybe Google did not spied intentionally on citizen, but wifi Google scandals clearly demonstrated that Google does not have any control over which data it collect. Any engineer may collect data about citizen and it will be unnoticed for years.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    azaazaa
    23rd Jul 2010
  • A logical assumption
    given Google's track record in regards to matters of privacy.

    plain
    ZDNet Gravatar
    Mister Spock
    23rd Jul 2010
  • Hey, L.A., obviously you're in need of a competent CIO
    and, obviously a bum's nutsack could do a better job than whoever is currently wasting that seat's space. I promise you, I would be quite willing to negotiate salary!!!

    They're just now focusing on security? What...did they just recently read a blog on ZDnet about Google Apps and realize their data was gonna be "in the cloud"? When this story broke months ago, the assumption was there were iron clad contracts, policies, and controls that allowed for and covered this sort of thing.

    But, if that's not the case, here are some more pointers...um, don't allow your people to login as root or local admins; filter internet traffic to some degree; purchase an antivirus solution; maybe turn on outbound filtering at the firewall level? these kinds of things

    This is not Google's fail...any migration, merger, transition is going to have it's hiccups, downtime, snags. This is L.A.'s fail...I mean, really?, a third of the way through and you start having concerns about security?

    This is STRIKINGLY similar to the "iPhone/iPad in the enterprise" debate...forget the fact that employees will be on facebook, games, or other BS all day....some are trying to make the case that because these devices are the latest thing, and alot of consumers have them, well then they must perfect for the enterprise! Let's not worry about the fact that they are about a secure as a half-patched Win 2k box w/ no antivirus.

    Both this LA gone Google and iPad in the enterprise are perfect examples of why Fads need to be kept out of the enterprise Certainly out of government, banking, hospitals, etc.

    Of course, we are talking about the government here...the same institution that won't filter employees' internet traffic because the ACLU had a hissy fit. Maybe after the TSA gets hacked, we can re-visit and reach a logical decision?
    ZDNet Gravatar
    SonofaSailor
    23rd Jul 2010
  • This is a Google and LA fail
    @SonofaSailor

    Seldom are the stake holders using IT services considered when massive changes are made. I am sure Google said-"Trust Me" we can do whatever security you need. The higher ups, not really understanding the lower level requirements said "Really?". "WOW!!". "Let's go with it".
    ZDNet Gravatar
    Bruizer
    24th Jul 2010
  • RE: Google, Los Angeles hit speed bumps on move to cloud
    It is totally incredible someone even considered moving the police department to the cloud. Police systems need a very high level of security and speed that you can't provide with a cloud solution. They should have updated the old Novell system to the most recent version of the software, then it would have done everything they needed. And it would have run on Linux.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    kees90210@...
    24th Jul 2010
  • How can you trust every Google employee?
    Sorry but that has always been the fly in the ointment with any cloud based solution.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    NoAxToGrind
    24th Jul 2010
  • Google CAN'T do enterprise
    LA on Exchange before the year is out is my prediction. At least then the city will be able to get some work done.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    hubivedder
    24th Jul 2010

Talkback - Tell Us What You Think

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources