Report: FCC chief wants hearing on AT&T, T-Mobile merger

Summary: Approval for AT&T's bid to buy out T-Mobile is looking less certain after the FCC's latest move.

Federal Communications Commission chairman Julius Genachowski is looking to set up an administrative hearing regarding AT&T's proposed bid for T-Mobile, according to The Wall Street Journal.

Citing "a person close to the matter" as the primary source, the WSJ posits that this will likely spell trouble for AT&T's $39 billion plan to become the nation's largest mobile carrier should it succeed in buying the nation's fourth largest (T-Mobile).

However, this move doesn't really look in favor of AT&T considering the FCC chairman's previous statement in response to the DOJ's anti-trust suit filed in August:

By filing suit today, the Department of Justice has concluded that AT&T’s acquisition of T-Mobile would substantially lessen competition in violation of the antitrust laws. Competition is an essential component of the FCC’s statutory public interest analysis, and although our process is not complete, the record before this agency also raises serious concerns about the impact of the proposed transaction on competition.

So far, Media Access Project senior vice president and policy director Andrew Jay Schwartzman has chimed in with support for the FCC. Here's an excerpt of his prepared remarks:

Even though this was something that we have expected all along, it is very promising that the FCC will be taking a hard look at the AT&T/T-Mobile transaction.  A decision to designate a hearing constitutes a finding by the FCC that there are “substantial and material” questions as to whether the deal is in the public interest.  It means the FCC has found merit in our arguments that a combined AT&T/T-Mobile will create a duopoly in the wireless market which will increase prices for service and for handsets.

Vonya McCann, Sprint’s senior vice president of government affairs, concurred with the following statement:

As Chairman Genachowski said in August when the Justice Department filed its antitrust lawsuit against AT&T, the record before the FCC presented, "serious concerns about the impact of the proposed transaction on competition." That record is complete and more than justifies moving this matter to an Administrative Law Judge for a hearing. We appreciate Chairman Genachowski’s leadership on this issue and look forward to the FCC moving quickly to adopt a strong hearing designation order.

Related:

Topics: AT&T, Government, Government US, Mobility

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

7 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • RE: Report: FCC chief wants hearing on AT&T, T-Mobile merger

    about time this deal was killed for good
    lthrwolftx
  • RE: Report: FCC chief wants hearing on AT&T, T-Mobile merger

    am i the only one wanting this deal to go through? I would love to get a cheap tmobile plan, but where i live their coverage is almost non-existent. I'd love to get one of their plans as soon as I heard the deal went through and get grandfathered in with a nice plan price and awesome coverage..
    ChristianJE
    • RE: Report: FCC chief wants hearing on AT&T, T-Mobile merger

      @ChristianJE

      i wouldnt mind it going thru either. ATT needs to expand its coverage with Tmobile. Then Verizon would have a true competitor. Instead of spending the money to do it like Verizon, they are spending even more to buy that infrastructure from Tmobile. Dont see why other people have an issue with it.
      tiderulz
      • RE: Report: FCC chief wants hearing on AT&T, T-Mobile merger

        @tiderulz

        If it was about coverage, why not rent some space on T-Mo towers where they need it? Why doesn't Verizon have a true competitor? They could have had Verizon-like coverage at $3.9 billion without the merger.

        The biggest red flag to me is that AT&T is simultaneously crying "ZoMg NeEd MoAr SpEcTrUm!!!1111oneone!!1" and offering some up some spectrum as a consession if the merger falls through.

        I think it's pretty much dead in the water anyway - T-Mobile's customer service started to get rather AT&T like, but now they recently got back to treating me the way I've always been treated as a t-mobile customer...which leads me to believe that they've realized that they can't get away with acting like AT&T =)
        Joey
        voyager529
    • RE: Report: FCC chief wants hearing on AT&T, T-Mobile merger

      @ChristianJE That cheap tmobile plan would never be available to you after the deal is done. Only the more expensive plans would survive. Otherwise everyone would only buy the cheap plans from them. They will only have 1 set of plans after the merger. That is why it is bad for everyone that is not a stockholder in AT&T.
      rmark@...
  • Why hold a hearing?

    Since the DOJ has already decided to oppose the merger, then it appears the issue will be decided in court (unless, of course, AT&T backs down).
    John L. Ries
  • If they merge

    For those thinking you may get a great tmobile plan/price if they merge, think again. The main reason many people are with tmob, is the fact that att customer service is the lowest you can get. Don't get me wrong, att coverage is good, so for the guys that keep up that end of the company, you do good. But the sales/customer service dept all need to be FIRED, grant it, they do have 1 or 2 that are good, but the other 9 out of 10 need to go. If they merge, you won't get Tmob prices or service. Many tmob customers will go to verizon, att will gain coverage,customers, and hopefully a few better customer service reps. In one way, I would like to see the merger, on the other hand, with att being in charge, I would hate that. I have been a att customer, both home phone, dsl and wireless. Like I said, it worked well, until there was a problem, then it is a nightmare. I had to cut my ties with them, as most people I know have also, due to same issues. Good service, nightmare customer service.ps, att mostly has a we don't care attitude. Here in SC, they opted out of control from the psc-public service commission! That should tell you something, they had so many complaints, they opted out??? How is this even legal? Wake up people, check it out before you wish for something, you just might get something you really don't want!!!
    steve_m291