The Verizon iPhone: Has Android turned those rumors into "so what?" moments?

Summary: New rumors about a Verizon iPhone don't seem matter as much now that the Android devices are all the rage

After the buzz last week, driven in part by reports in both the New York Times and Wall Street Journal, that the iPhone would finally be coming to the Verizon network early next year, a few friends over the weekend wanted to know: did this mean I was finally going to get an iPhone?

My short answer: No.

First of all, I told them, this is still a rumor. The Times is sourcing its report on a single person who is "in in direct contact with Apple" and doesn't want to "alienate his contacts at Apple." The Journal cites "people familiar with the matter." You'll excuse me if I don't jump up and down with excitement over these reports. It's not the first time I've heard this rumor.

Second, I'm just not loving the iPhone as much as I once did. I'll admit that I once had a bad case of iPhone envy - but AT&T's service in the San Francisco area was so poor that I just couldn't bring myself to pay that bill. I also said repeatedly that I would be one of the first in line if the iPhone ever landed at Verizon.

But that was then and this is now.

Don't get me wrong. The iPhone is an amazing device and is consistently raising the bar for the competition. In terms of sales, it's consistently a shining star for Apple's bottom line. And I have no doubt - as do the analysts that the NYT and WSJ interviewed - that an iPhone on the Verizon network could be quite disruptive to the industry. But not for me. I wasn't all that impressed with the iPhone 4, as well as all of that antennagate drama and now, that GlassGate problem. (Why does there always have to be "gate" for every little scandal?)

My final point is less about Apple and more about Google's Android. What can I say? I like Android - a lot - and I have no intention on dumping it just because the iPhone finally appeared on the Verizon lineup. Is it perfect? No, of course not. Battery life on my Droid Incredible, for example, leaves a lot to be desired. But I can work past something like that by keeping a charger in my car or a USB power adapter with my computer when I use it remotely. And I'm also hoping that Google and the device makers are working on it, as well. If I had an iPhone, there really wouldn't be a way for me to compensate for the poor signal that keeps dropping my calls or making me miss them all together.

Does that mean I won't ever change my mind about the iPhone? Of course not. Who knows what the next design looks like, which carriers will be supporting it or what that entry price point will be? And what about the Windows 7 Phone devices, which are being unveiled today in New York City? Or the new Blackberry? And let's not forget that HP still plans on doing something with the WebOS system it acquired in the Palm acquisition .

Bottom line: I'm cool with my Android smartphone. I like the OS, the apps, the hardware and especially the integration with Google products. The iPhone's arrival on the Verizon network - whenever that day might really be - can't take that away.

Topics: Hardware, Apple, iPhone, Mobility, Smartphones, Verizon

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

16 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • I agree on the battery life

    The battery life issue is a pest, but not a deal breaker.

    I love my Android (HTC Hero), and every 'droid user I know feels the same way.
    BrentRBrian
    • RE: The Verizon iPhone: Has Android turned those rumors into

      I find no fault with his reasoning and can completely<a href="http://www.edra41.org/"><font color="light&amp;height"> garden</font></a> to the over <a href="http://www.asklocal.biz/"><font color="light&amp;height">ask</font></a> to local people <a href="http://www.brennanstandsalone.com/"><font color="light&amp;height">stand alone</font></a> which you can <a href="http://www.actioniseloquence.net/"><font color="light&amp;height">action</font></a> without any warning <a href="http://www.hcenr.org/"><font color="light&amp;height">garden</font></a> not only understand.
      gorians
  • RE: The Verizon iPhone: Has Android turned those rumors into

    Poor battery life is a consequence of Android's multitasking design. It either needs a redesign OR a breakthrough in battery technology. Here in Europe where the iPhone is available on all networks, it's everywhere.
    Jeremy-UK
    • RE: The Verizon iPhone: Has Android turned those rumors into

      @Jeremy-UK Errrm Jeremy, I think you might be confusing what you would like to believe, with what is actual real life again!
      The iPhone is NOT everywhere, far from it in fact. The phone I am seeing more and more on the streets is an Android-powered one. Of all the people I know (and that includes some 100+ CompSci students), there are precisely 3 people with iOS devices (1 iPhone 3GS and 2 iPod Touch's).

      Not exactly flooded the market...
      Scrat
    • RE: The Verizon iPhone: Has Android turned those rumors into

      @Jeremy-UK That's the great thing about Android -- REAL innovations can happen! As far as battery life is concerned, there are a number of great solutions on the market, including JuiceDefender (http://bit.ly/d2YE5f) and Screebl Pro (http://bit.ly/9ZdUF8) to name my favorites.

      Open will always squish closed in the end.
      keyesdav
  • if it has LTE capability im getting one

    While I like the droid for web browsing, etc, it stinks as a phone. The interface is clunky and exchange integration is weak. If I run too many apps, the phone starts dropping calls and a reboot is needed. It doesnt happen often but it just shows that Android is not as polished as iPhone
    otaddy
  • No

    It is the continuous spread of these rumors by bloggers like you that have done that.
    bobiroc
  • Android Battery life

    1. Advanced Task Killer Free. Pull it up every so often and kill whatever processes start up.
    1a. Android needs some sort of "msconfig" utility that allows the user to prevent programs from starting up without user intervention.
    2. High capacity batteries for the Incredible are available for $22 shipped on eBay. They add some heft and waistline to the Incredible, but mine is still quite usable - it feels in line with my Touch Pro2 and lasts a day and a half on a single charge (albeit less if I wireless tether).
    2b. Android needs a means of doing something my WinMo phone does well - if I know I won't be using tons of data, I can drop back from 3G to EDGE and make my battery life double. I know the Incredible is CDMA, but there needs to be a means of doing "slow data only".

    Joey
    voyager529
  • RE: The Verizon iPhone: Has Android turned those rumors into

    I just want to know how you know that would keep dropping signal and missing calls all together if you don't even own an iPhone?
    David4445
  • RE: The Verizon iPhone: Has Android turned those rumors into

    I remembered when the iPhone 4 were released, how surprise some bloggers where with consumers response (pre-order numbers, long lines, trouble filling demands), even with the whole "antenna-gate".

    If the iPhone were to ever launch on Verizon and other networks, I think it will be very disruptive. Great that Android is offering alternatives but the iPhone is still the #1 phone to have (mindshare).
    dave95.
  • I'm STILL not convinced...

    Seems like Apple and Verizon would make very uncomfortable partners: http://bit.ly/alnh0F
    keyesdav
  • glassgate?

    another totally fabricated and phoney apple-outrage story "reported" by the zdnet-bloggers as fact. it is disgusting.
    banned from zdnet
  • RE: The Verizon iPhone: Has Android turned those rumors into

    It's just another rumor that I'm tired of hearing about.

    It is the continuous spread of these rumors by bloggers like yourself that have done that.
    krismartin56
  • Awe Factor Gone

    The iPhone is nice, but it simply doesn't have the same jaw-dropping aura about it that it once had. There are dozens of phones out there that do what the iPhone does; sure, there are differences, but to the average person, those differences really don't matter much. <br><br>iPhone or Android... I could care less.
    trickytom3
  • RE: The Verizon iPhone: Has Android turned those rumors into

    I love how people blame the blogger for this one. Both the Wall Street Journal and the New York Times thought it was fit to print. I do believe that they are still journalistic entities. The blogger actually said it himself, if this is true would it be enough to entice him? He answered that question with a no. I find no fault with his reasoning and can completely understand the argument both for and against people getting the Verizon iPhone, if it were to happen.
    hoaxoner
  • RE: The Verizon iPhone: Has Android turned those rumors into

    I used to be extremely happy to look out this blog site.I preferred to many thanks for this good scan!! I positively going through nearly all modest little bit of it and I've you bookmarked to start looking <a href="http://www.ny-eshop.com" style="text-decoration: none; color: black;">nfljersey</a> at out new things you publish.
    jackson1984-24316069205748857739440257893812