ie8 fix
madison

Back to School 2011: Top 3 smartphones from each major carrier

By | August 24, 2011, 4:21am PDT

Summary: There are excellent smartphones on every major US wireless carrier and this back to school guide shows you the top three from each. What is your favorite smartphone?

Back in late March I posted my top 10 smartphones of 2011 that were available or announced. I then followed this post up with my top five that were actually available and after more time with some I don’t even think those are valid any longer. It’s a bit sad that the top two and one other in my top 10 still are not available and one is never coming. There are so many smartphones available from all the carriers and to make this a helpful guide for planning your purchase I will present my top three picks for smartphones from each of the four major national carriers and all of these phones are available now. The rumored, and still not confirmed, Apple iPhone 5 may be coming to AT&T, Verizon, and Sprint, but until we get some kind of confirmation and announcement from Apple that is still all speculation.

The prices you will see in this article are from the carrier, when available. If you are new to a carrier or adding another line you will find excellent prices on Amazon.com and other online vendors like Wirefly (I buy both contract and off contract phones here). So you know where my personal perspective is coming from I am a long time (about 10 years) T-Mobile subscriber with five phones on a family plan and signed up for a Verizon account in March and had the HTC Thunderbolt then HTC Droid Charge and this week will have the Bold 9930. I had an AT&T account (mainly used only with data) for a couple of years and was a Sprint subscriber for about a year with devices like the HTC EVO 4G. I do have some experiences with each of the four major US wireless carriers and have also been purchasing SIM-unlocked smartphones for over 6 years. I personally will switch and pay the ETF to get a new device and jump to a carrier that offers me more for my money, but will most likely never try leaving T-Mobile with my family plan again (AT&T failed me big time when I tried that and my wife almost killed me due to the constant dropped calls).

Each carrier is different for all of us and is highly dependent on where you live, work, and play. I recommend you figure out which carrier works best for you before buying a device you won’t be happy with because of the carrier. There are many excellent smartphone options today and you honestly can’t really go wrong with any of the available choices. Like carriers, different smartphone operating systems work for different people because of their different strengths and weaknesses, 3rd party applications, and available form factors.

Enough about the disclaimers and warnings, let’s take a look at my list of smartphones to consider for school year 2011-2012.

AT&T

Apple iPhone 4

There is likely a new Apple iPhone coming this fall, but until now the one year old Apple iPhone 4 is still an excellent smartphone choice on AT&T. This year you can also pick one up in white and it will be upgradeable to the iOS 5 update coming out in the next few months.

AT&T made some major changes to their pricing plans after the release of the iPhone 4 so that now there is a 2GB cap on data with the ability to also tether for another $20 per month. Each additional GB of data cost $10/month. There are additional charges for text messaging other services, like AT&T Navigator.

Price: $299 for 32GB and $199 for 16GB with 2-year contract

[Check out the iPhone 4 CNET Reviews page]

Samsung Infuse 4G

AT&T may have been a bit slow to launch Android devices, but they have a good selection now and it was tough to choose between this Samsung Infuse 4G or the HTC Inspire 4G, but I went with the larger more brilliant display for my choice. The Infuse 4G has a whopping 4.5 inch Super AMOLED Plus display, runs Android 2.2, has an 8 megapixel camera, and is the thinnest 4G smartphone at just 8 mm thick.

The Infuse 4G comes with a very large 1750 mAh battery, internal 18 GB storage, and microSD card so you can load this bad boy up with storage memory. It supports AT&T’s HSPA+ network too. Customer reviews are overwhelmingly positive and the Infuse 4G looks like a definite winner on AT&T.

Price: $199.99 with 2-year contract

[Check out the Samsung Infuse 4G CNET Reviews page]

Samsung Focus

I am a major Windows Phone 7 fan and think people need to actually try one of these devices to appreciate how good it really is. The great thing about the existing lineup, like the Samsung Focus, is that they will get upgraded to Windows Phone Mango soon and that OS update is wonderful on the Samsung Focus.

The Focus has a brilliant 4 inch WVGA Super AMOLED touchscreen that is extremely responsive. The 5 megapixel camera takes decent photos and there is a lot to like in Windows Phone 7 with Xbox LIVE gaming, Zune Pass music services, Bing Search integration, and so much more.

Price: $49.99 with 2-year contract

[Check out the my Windows Phone 7.5 Mango technical preview article and the Focus CNET Reviews page]

Let’s check out Sprint’s offerings »

Matthew Miller started using a Pilot 1000 in 1997 and has been writing news, reviews, and opinion pieces ever since.

Disclosure

Matthew Miller

Matthew is a professional naval architect by day and a mobile gadget freak at all other times. He purchases his own devices and then sells them on eBay or Craigslist to buy more. Many other devices are sent for review on a 30-day loaner basis and then returned to the carrier or manufacturer. If any are provided as “long term loaner units” this will be clearly disclosed in his reviews.

Biography

Matthew Miller

Matthew Miller started using a mobile devices in 1997 and has been writing news, reviews, and opinion pieces ever since. He is a co-host with GigaOM's Kevin Tofel on the MobileTechRoundup podcast and an author of three Wiley Companion series books. Matthew started using mobile devices with a US Robotics Pilot 1000 and has owned over 125 different devices running Palm, Linux, Symbian, Newton, BlackBerry, iOS, Android, webOS, Windows Mobile, and Windows Phone operating systems. His current collection includes an HTC Radar 4G, Dell Venue Pro, Apple iPad 2, HTC Flyer, Samsung Galaxy Nexus, Nokia N9, Apple iPhone 4S, MacBook Pro, and many more, along with tons of accessories and classic devices like the Apple Newton MessagePad 2100 and Sony CLIE UX50. Matthew can be found on various discussion forums under the user name of "palmsolo".
28
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

RE: Back to School 2011: Top 3 smartphones from each major carrier
tomlin21-24319035676893835085146735905770 11th Oct
Thanks for this effective web-site .I for convinced favored each and every very last small little bit of it. We have you bookmarked your website website to find out with the modern-day things nfl football jerseys you establish.
I get the lineup, but what does back to school have to do with phones? Kids go to school to pay attention, not to play on their phones and text all day.

Want a real back to school phone? Then get a cheap prepaid phone for your kid. Otherwise you are asking for trouble.
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
Colleges and parents
palmsolo (aka Matthew Miller) 24th Aug
@statuskwo5 I was thinking about college students and also those parents looking to pick up a new phone to stay connected with their kids. Smartphones are dropping in price and more and more younger people are getting them to stay in touch after class too.
@statuskwo5

Microsoft is a patenttroll. Openess and freedom FTW
0 Votes
+ -
You're an idiot
William Farrell 25th Aug
@Sultansulan
@statuskwo5

I can agree totally but knowing most push over parents they will be getting their kids smart phones assuming the younger they know tech the smarter and more well hearsed they will be in the future. It doesn't make sense to me either but whatever. I can so though if it wasn't for having computers in the house as such a young age and me being able to do what I wanted I wouldn't be where I am today in the I.T. industry knowing all I know. If I was sheltered I would be probably flipping patties at burger king.
0 Votes
+ -
HTC Trophy
LiquidLearner 24th Aug
Picked one up on Verizon about a month ago. I still haven't had to reboot the phone, not once. I've had no application crashes and no slow downs. Coming from a Droid 2 for a year this smart phone is an absolute dream. I couldn't be happier, with the hardware or the OS. Plus, as far as I'm concerned, LTE on a smart phone (unless you heavily use tethering) is a good way to chew through all your data and not much more. 3G is just fine for basic web browsing and e-mail, which is the majority of what I use my phone for. Oh, and phone calls.
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
@LiquidLearner I have been using WP7 since last July and it has honestly been the most stable platform of any smartphone I have ever tried. I also fully agree with you on LTE.
0 Votes
+ -
HTC Arrive replaced my iPhone
gomigomijunk Updated - 24th Aug
@LiquidLearner Amen. I switch from the iPhone to an HTC Arrive, and while I admit that the apple hardware is sexy, the Arrive (and I have mango dev loaded on mine) is the most incredible phone I've ever owned. The Winphone 7 OS is so smooth and intelligent. I've decided they need to create a commercial where they tout "There is no App for that: it is integrated into the OS".

The messaging in Mango is light years ahead of anyone else. It makes no distinction between SMS, Facebook, Msn Messenger, LinkedIn, Twitter text messaging. I don't have to load a Facebook app to use facebook messaging. I don't have to load a Messenger app to perform messaging....it is all just messaging. Just choose the person you want to talk to, and then send the message. It will let you know if they are available by any of those means and you can choose which method to chat.

Yeah, if you have an iPhone, well, you just have an iPhone. If you have a Windows Phone 7, you have a real communication device.
0 Votes
+ -
WP7 is awesome!
CurryGuy123 24th Aug
@LiquidLearner
I've been using an HTC HD7 and I love it. The hardware may not be the best (especially the camera), but WP7 is realy simple and easy to use. Plus, the Metro UI and Live Tiles are awesome compared to static icons.
@LiquidLearner

I just bought a HTC HD7 loaded with WP7. So far im highly impress with the quality of the product.

The OS is very special,unique and well though. The fact that the tiles push the information toward you is simply awesome.
0 Votes
+ -
Picked up the HTC Trophy 2 weeks ago
William Farrell 25th Aug
@LiquidLearner
and it's my first HTC phone. I have to say it's quite sturdy, and WP7 OS is really nice, very fast, and easy to use.
0 Votes
+ -
Focus works great for us
Oknarf 24th Aug
picked up 3 in June switched from Sprint to ATT because of coverage issues and we couldn't be happier. 2 of the Focii are being used by my kids and people need to check out WP7. I have Mango installed and even though we loved our initial WP7 Focii Mango makes it sooooooo much better. The deep social integration works extremely well and having xbox linked to the phone is a lot of fun. Zune and the Metro design works fantastically, much more intuitive than android and iOS IMO.
0 Votes
+ -
Can't wait for Mango
LiquidLearner 24th Aug
@Oknarf

Mango really looks to be a heavy hitter in the mobile OS space. As good as WP7 is already my only complaint is when I'm doing one thing and switch out to answer a text or something and I have to go all the way back in. With fast rehydration of applications this problem should go away and make it the absolute best OS out there. With Mango giving Bing navigation and multi-tasking I don't see how it can't take off. For some reason people just don't want to try it. I had to argue with the Verizon guy who thought I was nuts because I wanted the Trophy. He kept trying to sell me on the Thunderbolt. I asked if it was more stable than the Droid 2, he said it's faster so you don't notice the slow downs as much. F.dat. It's funny that the sales people almost seem compelled to talk you out of the device just because it's Microsoft. When I pointed out that the Trophy has the best user reviews on the Verizon website he just gave me a blank stare, like he had no idea what a user review was.

Oh well, anyone who takes their smartphone advice from the pimply faced kid at their local VZW store deserves what they get.
@LiquidLearner - I had a similar experience in the Sprint store when I purchased my Arrive. The sales guy simply could not fathom that I would be willing to pay more for an Arrive than for the Evo Shift 4g... He kept trying to sell me on the 4g, which we don't have in my part of the state and are not scheduled to get anytime in the near future.

The problem with these sales guys is that they're all "geeks" like most of us on here and don't understand that some of us want phones that we don't have to screw with to make them work for us.
@LiquidLearner

I have seen reports that Verizon Sales people get a higher commission on some Android Phones, hence the pushing of them over other phones.
@LiquidLearner

I understand what you means. It was pure hell for me.

All the vendors i saw only tried to sell me android phone, not even one vendor told me about blackberry,Iphone or WP7

When i asked them how android phones compare to the others phones they didnt had any idea.Most of them told me android was more popular so it was the best pick.

So i tried them all (after all i was about to sign a 2 years contract.) I finally took the HTC HD7, event then the vendors was insisting for me to get a android phone.

I suggest people to tried at least a couple phones from different compagny before buying, and please don't listen to the vendor, he is not the one who will pay your 2 years phone bill.
0 Votes
+ -
I'm with you 100% on that
William Farrell 25th Aug
@LiquidLearner
I did my research, and found I really wanted the Trophy. My wife has the iPhone4 and likes it, and I agree, it's very nice.
But I wanted something different, with features that suited me and the Trophy was it.

I walked in to the store and the "sales boy" asked what I was interested in. Pointed it out telling him it will work perfect for me, after doing my research, and the guy looked puzzled, telling me that I would really like the Droid or whatever (maybe it was the Thunderbolt) and because its the one he uses and he likes it.

He then said he was surprised because "nobody buys that", only to find that they where sold out of it.

I guess after we left he went back to popping the pimples on his face or something.
Meh you left out the HTC Droid Incredible II from verizon and my kids are focusing on school not their friggin phones with every article you show yourself to be headline mongering ******
The best overall value for a smartphone has to be the Samsung Exhibit 4G from T-Mobile. Excellent value with high-end features and performance.
I was going to be pissed if you DIDN'T include a new Blackberry. They are great!
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
Yes, new generation are best BB devices ever
palmsolo (aka Matthew Miller) 24th Aug
@john@... If I picked top four then I may have had a BB from each carrier. They really are great devices and deserve a look, even if people think everyone should have an iPhone.
0 Votes
+ -
Do they support ActiveSync finally?
LiquidLearner 24th Aug
@palmsolo (aka Matthew Miller)

Or do you still have to run a BES? I like the features a BES has to offer if you're rolling out a large userbase of Blackberries for sure but for most people it's a huge PITA that they don't have the option to sync all their data, not just get e-mail, via ActiveSync.
@palmsolo (aka Matthew Miller)

At least BB with OS7... I can dig it otherwise WP7 with Mango is best. I'm loving Mango! happy HTC Trophy 7.5 Verizon
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
No Sprint Nexus S?
Verizon in-store sales associates are on commission.
How many kids are just sitting back waiting for the iphone 5? Com on Mom I need it for xmas everyone at school has one!
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Back to School 2011: Top 3 smartphones from each major carrier
jackson1984-24316069205748857739440257893812 11th Oct
Excellent information and facts, I would thank to writer becaus i've noticed numerous mulberry outlet store exhilarating data. I will subscribe to this webpage. Best needs happy
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Back to School 2011: Top 3 smartphones from each major carrier
tomlin21-24319035676893835085146735905770 11th Oct
Thanks for this effective web-site .I for convinced favored each and every very last small little bit of it. We have you bookmarked your website website to find out with the modern-day things nfl football jerseys you establish.

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix
ie8 fix