Will the iPhone 4 replace your digital camera (and camcorder)?

By | June 8, 2010, 10:33am PDT

Summary: Can the new camera features in the iPhone 4 render your basic point-and-shoot camera (and pocket camcorder) obsolete?

Now that the infamous new iPhone 4 has finally been officially unveiled, the big question is, will you ever carry your point-and-shoot again? Call it blasphemy, but I’ve found that even the lame-o, fixed-focus 2.0 megapixel camera on my iPhone 3G has encroached significantly on my point-and-shoot’s duties (especially when combined with cool and useful photo apps), if for no other reason than the fact that I almost always have it with me. Well, two generations later, the iPhone has made such leaps and bounds in the camera department that I could see it replacing a casual point-and-shooter in many cases and even my beloved Flip pocket camcorder, since the camera now shoots 720p HD video at 30 fps. Here are the highlights:

First and foremost, the sensor has not only been upped from 3 megapixels in last year’s iPhone 3GS to 5 megapixels, but Apple has also used a backside-illuminated sensor that should improve image quality especially in low light. As CEO Steve Jobs described it in his keynote speech at Apple’s Worldwide Developers Conference, WWDC 2010, yesterday, “it’s a way of getting a lot more photons onto the sensor by getting some of the wiring and stuff out of the way.” He also went on to say that “when most people increase their megapixels, they make those pixels smaller. When you make pixels smaller, they capture less photons. What we’ve done is as we’ve gone from 3 to 5 megapixels we’ve kept the pixels the same size -  1.75 microns, and so they don’t capture less photos per pixel and we have more pixels.”

Besides the new and improved sensor, Apple has also added an LED flash as well as easy-to-use geotagging capabilities, both of which can be used in still and video mode (as can the tap-to-focus feature).  But possibly best of all is the VGA-quality front camera, which allows you to shoot still and video portraits of yourself more easily and make video calls over WiFi to other iPhone 4s.

Speaking of video capabilities, the iPhone 4 includes built-in video editing features that look to be as easy as dragging start and end points on a filmstrip. For more editing tools, the company has created a new iMovie app that will sell on the App Store for $4.99 and allows you to combine and edit video clips and add themes, transitions, titles, music, and photos to your video.

So what do you think?

Poll

Will the iPhone 4 replace point-and-shoot cameras and pocket camcorders?

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

Janice got her hands on a Nikon Coolpix 900 back in 1998 and has been a digital camera enthusiast ever since.

Disclosure

Janice Chen

Janice Chen has no business relationships, affiliations, investments, or other potential conflicts of interest relating to the content posted in this blog.

Biography

Janice Chen

Janice Chen is an editorial consultant and has been covering technology for over two decades. Serving as editor in chief at CNET and Computer Shopper magazine for many years, she oversaw product coverage for the CNET and ZDNet websites. She has appeared on most of the major morning TV news programs and was featured weekly on CNN Headline News' Hotwired segment recommending personal tech ranging from digital cameras to notebook PCs. Prior to that, she appeared with Anderson Cooper on a monthly technology segment for ABC World News This Morning. Quoted in numerous publications such as the New York Times, USA Today, and People magazine, Janice has also evaluated tech products for BusinessWeek, USA Weekend magazine, and Parenting magazine among others.

Janice got her hands on a Nikon Coolpix 900 back in 1998 and has been a digital camera enthusiast ever since. A graduate of Cornell University, she resides in Maplewood, NJ, with her husband (a professional photographer who shot his last roll of film in 2003) and their two daughters.

Talkback Most Recent of 28 Talkback(s)

  • No optical zoom
    Watch a smartphone user carefully, they switch on the phone, they hunt for the camera application, switch it and use the screen to get into the correct mode,.... these devices really miss dedicated buttons, but that's not the least of their problems.
    Even if they ever put decent lenses on them, and optical zoom, multifunction devices just can't compete with a humble Ixus because the sensors are too small and the tradeoffs too big.
    As for the photons thing, he's trying to explain why it's a 5MP unit vs the 8MP of competitors. It's emperors-new-clothes stuff.... oooh "look at the finesse of the cloth, the delicate fibers, the way the photons light is captured in the threads of this fine garment your Majesty!".

    LED flash is no substitute for flash. The reason they don't have a flash is because the capacitor takes up too much space. Again the compromises.

    So no.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    guihombre
    8th Jun 2010
  • RE: Will the iPhone 4 replace your digital camera (and camcorder)?
    @guihombre
    Agreed. Optical zoom is a no-brainer. Apple really goofed on this one.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    Droid101
    8th Jun 2010
  • ZDNet Gravatar
    guihombre
    8th Jun 2010
  • Poor 3x optical zoom with crippled low-light pseudo 8MP photos?
    @guihombre:
    1) if you ever saw actual optical 3x zoom in action, then you know it makes really, really small effect in situations when you would like to have zoom (huge pro optics only does the trick).

    And, with cheapo optics which used for cell phones there is no such thing as actual optical (not nominal) resolution than 5 MP. That is because cheapo supersmall optics is not that presice to focus light exactly along the straight perpendicular line of sensor matrix. The light always gets focused a little bit before or a little bit after the very line of sensor matrix, so the image is out of focus on pixel level. That is why 8-14MP photos on smartphones look blurry when you see them at 100% pixel-to-pixel viewing mode.

    So 8, 10, 12, 14 MP cell cameras is marketing feature, rather than possibility to shoot photos with that quality as **optical** resolution.

    2) Additionally, Apple uses matrix with backside pixel sensors, which is not available for 8-10-12-14MP cellphone camera at all.

    3) Also, Apple uses physically bigger sensor. This, along with #2 point, allows better low light photos.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    DeRSSS
    8th Jun 2010
  • @denisrs
    Those cheap micro zooms on dumb phones, agreed, not good yet.

    The 3x zoom on point and shoot cameras are miles better than that and the CCDs are bigger.

    My guess is they did it for compactness, they have optical focus or not? Presumably yes.

    "Apple uses matrix with backside pixel sensors" que?
    Are you saying their using a CMOS silicon sensor not a CCD? I can believe it, but that's not for quality reasons. CMOS is usually picked for low power. I assume he means the stacked type (with the red, green and blue detectors stacked in layers, done to squeeze more pixels in small units.

    My point on LED vs discharge flash stands.

    Proof of the pudding is in the eating. You can make claims I believe to be false all you like, but Apple are using stock units, and not the best ones at that.

    (Edited)
    Is it one of these units? Normally demosaic'd to 10.2MP, so I assume this is a smaller unit?
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foveon_X3_sensor
    ZDNet Gravatar
    guihombre
    8th Jun 2010
  • RE: Will the iPhone 4 replace your digital camera (and camcorder)?
    @guihombre:
    1) no, I mean Apple uses sensor type that comes from pro-area (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backside_illumination);

    2) of course, actual Xenon flash is way, way brighter than LED and that is why cameraphones like from SonyEricsson usually do better work. However, with Apple's use of larger pixel sensors and backside illumination technology, the results may compete to those coming from Xenon flash enabled cameraphones.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    DeRSSS
    8th Jun 2010
  • RE: Will the iPhone 4 replace your digital camera (and camcorder)?
    @guihombre This enormously Phentermine is not come for a second time? You believe it is.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    Phentermine
    22nd Aug
  • RE: Will the iPhone 4 replace your digital camera (and camcorder)?
    @guihombre Thanks a million. I really appreciate it. replica omega oris watches panerai watches
    ZDNet Gravatar
    three-shao
    19th Sep
  • RE: Will the iPhone 4 replace your digital camera (and camcorder)?
    There is no substitute for a dedicated camera or camcorder. The iPhone is nice in a pinch but it simply can't do it all. The size of the sensor is just too small to take really any good pictures or videos.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    nothingness
    8th Jun 2010
  • Not a chance
    My wife's Moto Droid with 5MP camera takes images as well as an old Sony Mavica from 1998. In other words, garbage. Unless outdoors, the image quality is unbearable. Megapixels to not equal quality.

    You know what I've dumped my point and shoot for? An SLR.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    Gomer_Pyle
    8th Jun 2010
  • RE: Will the iPhone 4 replace your digital camera (and camcorder)?
    You already have optical zoom. It's called "your feet". Camera doesn't matter, photographer does.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    Arturius
    8th Jun 2010
  • RE: Will the iPhone 4 replace your digital camera (and camcorder)?
    replace? not even close.
    I recently picked up a pns Lumix to go with my digital slr.
    10mp with video and stablity, optical zoom plus a host of other features.
    and all for just over a $100.

    iPhone doesn't cut it. Not even close.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    rhonin
    8th Jun 2010
  • RE: Will the iPhone 4 replace your digital camera (and camcorder)?
    @zenwalker and you have one already (iPhone 4) so that you can make your claims, right?
    ZDNet Gravatar
    cfcoder
    8th Jun 2010
  • Reason that iPhone will not replace Cameras: not everyone wants an iPhone
    Who would like to lock himself into a proprietary platform and tie himself to AT&T? iPhone will do well, but not well enough so that everyone who uses a camera would also have an iPhone. iPhone is more for tech hipsters rather than every day users.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    hamobu-22333136139518773481685514128812
    8th Jun 2010
  • The hardware simply isn't available
    Quality imaging requires space for image-projection, a lot of light, and a quality piece of glass; no phone can do it.

    Granted, many innovations and advancements have been made in the point-and-shoot camera category, but even these require a decent lens which seriously outperforms anything on a cell phone. As to the previous poster's observations about optical zoom, you are absolutely correct; under no circumstances will you get a quality image that has been digitally zoomed. compete with optical zoom quality.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    tricktytom
    8th Jun 2010

Talkback - Tell Us What You Think

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources