Are Enterprise Content Management failures destroying the American system of justice?
Summary: As if dying trees and disgruntled employees aren’t bad enough consequences of poor enterprise content management systems, according to Michael Hickins, lousy Enterprise Content Management (ECM) could be chipping away at the very heart of American justice.
photo: plu.edu
As if dying trees and disgruntled employees aren’t bad enough consequences of poor enterprise content management systems, according to Michael Hickins, lousy Enterprise Content Management (ECM) could be chipping away at the very heart of American justice. This talk of justice and ethics makes me a little lightheaded, so I’m going to let Hickins speak for himself:
The shabby state of most enterprise content management implementations, combined with lady Justice’s thirst for electronic documents, has made it so that “only the rich and Microsoft (NSDQ: MSFT) can afford to litigate,” in the words of attorney Ralph Losey, who specializes in legal applications of technology.
Losey, whom I met at a conference sponsored by EMC (NYSE: EMC) Corporation, decried what he called “extortion by discovery demands,” which forces most defendants to simply settle their lawsuits rather than spend huge sums to defend themselves. It doesn’t have to be this way, he said, but “the failure of business to adopt enterprise content management is destroying the American system of justice.”
“There’s enterprise and there’s content but there’s no management,” he quipped.
Most companies, or at least those with a functioning legal department, now realize that courts expect them to make all forms of electronic communication available to their opponents during the pre-trial process called “discovery.” That includes not only email but instant messages, blogs and any other relevant documents — electronic and otherwise (hence the term “e-discovery”).And that’s where it starts getting dicey, of course — what’s the definition of relevant, and how do you find it?
Hickins goes on to explain how this problem can be solved:
According to Losey, vendors need to do a better job of explaining text analytics and other sophisticated applications that can do a better job of narrowing the haystack, which could save a lot of money. Currently, he said, “there’s a huge disconnect between technology and our dispute resolution system.”
The bigger disconnect, of course, is between our expectation of proper corporate citizenship and the shareholder-value-driven culture that permeates most companies, and in many cases creates the incentive for fraud. This isn’t something we can cure through legislation–at least not entirely.
We’re going to have to start demanding ethical behavior from companies, and using our pocketbooks to punish those that transgress. As a society, never mind an economy, we can’t afford to continue throwing litigation dollars down the drain. And imagine how much money could be saved on parsing documents if companies knew they had nothing to hide.
What are your thoughts, Doc readers?
More from “The DocuMentor”
Topics
Biography
Doc
ZDNet introduces Doc (The DocuMentor), sponsored by RICOH. Through his blog, Doc will educate you about Document Management. So who is Doc? Doc is something of an enigma. He was born to a Russian ballerina and a German electrical engineer who some believe was running covert operations for shadowy corporate interests. Doc grew up in various locations in the United States, although no one seems to know precisely where, least of all Doc. His early schooling was unremarkable except for the time he was caught trying to replace all the mimeograph machines with high-tech color copiers that had mysteriously disappeared from a shipment to Albania. At MIT, he made a name for himself by transforming a large printer into a robot that hunts and eats Roombas. Professionally, he reportedly has seen the insides of more brands, versions, and generations of printer and printer-related hardware than almost anyone. Some say his obsession with paper, printing, and mechanical movement was either started by, or evidenced by, a traumatic childhood episode when he crawled inside an old Xerox 2400 and tried to print himself.
Anyway, Doc has hands on experience with stuff like printer maintenance and fleet management, but his mastery of document management leaves no stone unturned. Important issues like sustainability, security, and regulatory compliance are top of mind for Doc, as are other business technology needs like networking and IT services, making him a true blue IT renaissance man.
Just In
RE: Are Enterprise Content Management failures destroying the American system of justice?
Join the conversation!
Quick Poll
Which imaging and document management trends are you most likely to consider?
Related Links
- New White paper: Managed Print Services and Beyond: How You Can Cut Costs and Go Green While Increasing Employee Productivity
- Learn how document management systems can help reduce the tide of paper that is swamping our offices
- Use software to cut costs by scrapping paper
- My printer, my social letterbox
- Doc on Twitter
- Doc on Facebook
- Doc on LinkedIn
Vendor Showcase
Blog Archive
White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
-
Office 365 Migration Guide: Approaches, Techniques and ChallengesNo Headache, No Hassles Microsoft 365 Migration
Your company is ... (Quest Software)Download Now - The Best Ways to Migrate Lotus Notes Applications to SharePoint and Office 365Migrating Notes to SharePoint Online/Microsoft Office ... (Quest Software)Download Now
- Solve the 6 Top Problems in Your Data CenterWhat are the top 6 problems in your data center and how do you solve them? ... (Hewlett-Packard (HP))Download Now
