Still Debating Saturday Mail Delivery
Despite a strong recommendation from the Postmaster General that the USPS eliminate Saturday mail delivery (along with other cost-cutting moves and a rate increase), the issue is far from settled. In late July, Senator Jon Testor (D-Mont) said that the senators who oversee the US Postal Service’s budget will block the proposal to stop delivering mail on Saturdays. The USPS cannot cut services without agreement from Congress.
Doc’s a bit on the fence about the Saturday mail delivery conundrum. The USPS is on track to lose $7 billion this fiscal year, so something has to be done. But there is a large concern among direct marketers and transactional printers that eliminating Saturday mail delivery will have a measurable affect on commerce, and hit rural areas particularly hard.
For a good read on the subject, check out this article from the New York Times.
As federal regulators consider a proposal to cut most Saturday postal deliveries, the business community is sharply divided about the consequences of switching to five-day service.
The post office estimates that cutting Saturday delivery would save $3 billion a year.
Some, like Donald J. Hall Jr., chief executive of Hallmark Cards, said that eliminating Saturday delivery and raising prices even incrementally would drive more business away from the United States Postal Service, resulting in a “slippery slope.”But others, like Andrew Rendich, the chief service and DVD operations officer at Netflix, said five-day delivery would be a better alternative to significantly higher postal rates. “Big rate increases will absolutely squash business and will absolutely slow growth for a company like Netflix,” Mr. Rendich said.
Doc wonders where you stand on the issue, especially if you do a lot of transactional printing and regularly send out customer correspondence. Many people I’ve talked to wish the USPS would eliminate one of the weekdays, since Saturday is traditionally a good day to get mail directly in people’s hands (when they are not at work and have time to deal with it right away). So which is better, elimination of Saturday mail delivery or a big rate increase? The way it’s looking now, we may be headed toward a combination of both!
More from “The DocuMentor”
Topics
Biography
Doc
ZDNet introduces Doc (The DocuMentor), sponsored by RICOH. Through his blog, Doc will educate you about Document Management. So who is Doc? Doc is something of an enigma. He was born to a Russian ballerina and a German electrical engineer who some believe was running covert operations for shadowy corporate interests. Doc grew up in various locations in the United States, although no one seems to know precisely where, least of all Doc. His early schooling was unremarkable except for the time he was caught trying to replace all the mimeograph machines with high-tech color copiers that had mysteriously disappeared from a shipment to Albania. At MIT, he made a name for himself by transforming a large printer into a robot that hunts and eats Roombas. Professionally, he reportedly has seen the insides of more brands, versions, and generations of printer and printer-related hardware than almost anyone. Some say his obsession with paper, printing, and mechanical movement was either started by, or evidenced by, a traumatic childhood episode when he crawled inside an old Xerox 2400 and tried to print himself.
Anyway, Doc has hands on experience with stuff like printer maintenance and fleet management, but his mastery of document management leaves no stone unturned. Important issues like sustainability, security, and regulatory compliance are top of mind for Doc, as are other business technology needs like networking and IT services, making him a true blue IT renaissance man.
Just In
On your point about lobbys: one relatively minor fix the USPS could attend to is simply to make post office interiors more attractive and consumer-friendly in many ways. Sheesh, it's 2011 and lobbys have hardly changed in a hundred years. Except that these days most interiors are dumps with ugly advertising plastered everywhere, and broken/missing pens on dirty writing surfaces -- a place that customers do not look forward to going to. (Duh.)
Some may think this point trivial (and they run the USPS), but I feel pretty certain that getting rid of the "warehouse office" interface at post offices across the country would help the USPS bottom line. And it is not an expensive fix, if done by smart people.
But will this get done by a bureaucracy which stifles innovation as a religion? Same story as Amtrak. And so sad.
Nevertheless, I feel pretty strongly that stopping Saturday delivery by the USPS would be a boon for private carriers, and nothing more. No, more like a giveaway. And it would accelerate a decline in a great, necessary institution, one that is important to communities in so many barely visible ways (/invisible/ ways to rabid right-wingers). And it would hurt those in the lower economic strata disproportionately.
But while many clueless consumers will lose out when they lose Saturday delivery, they're conditioned to support higher profits for those invested in package carriers that this change will bring, and that's what it's all about in this era of idiots like Palin, you betcha.
But not the entire path from source to destination.
Let the USPS deal with the first and last miles.
In-between can be any of the transportation firms; e.g., FedEx, UPS, et al who firms now doing business on their own terms.
How is it privatized services make a profit and the USPS doesn't?
Part of why the private companies make money while the USPS does not is that they have the option of choosing to only do the profitable parts of the service. The USPS offers money losing services: delivery to remote rural areas (note that even UPS and FedEx depend on the USPS to deliver to some of those locations), hand addressed first-class mail sent by individuals, bargain rate Media Mail and second-class (magazines). Oh yes, and Saturday delivery without an extra fee, a day on which mail delivery volume is lower because many businesses don't accept mail.
Exactly!
As far as privatizing the whole thing? When the German Postal Service was privatized, the cost to do mail went through the roof. Imagine what it would do with the USPS and it's perennial deficit.
Why do I need a USPS e-mail account on top of my 5 current address'??? I can secure my own e-mail probably for a lot less then the USPS would charge!!
Yes, obsoleting is a verb
obsoleting - 3 dictionary results
ob?so?lete? ?/??bs??lit, ??bs??lit/ Show Spelled
[ob-suh-leet, ob-suh-leet] Show IPA
adjective, verb, -let?ed, -let?ing.
?verb (used with object)
6. to make obsolete by replacing with something newer or better; antiquate: Automation has obsoleted many factory workers.
Most important: The Postal Service may provide the country with an enormous economic value, much more than its losses. Pending an analysis, we the citizens (quaint term) may be better off and have more money at the end of the day by paying off the post office deficits than by closing it because of its losses. Did anybody look lately at UPS Ground rates?
People who call the USPS obsolete fail to see one thing... Show me one private company that can send a card across the country for the price of a 1st class stamp, currently 44 cents.
Loosing Saturday delivery, is something that I think most people can get used to. DKramer3 did have an interesting idea, I don't know how feasible or how much of a demand there would be, but interesting to say the least.
I agree regarding the Saturday delivery thing, and I live in a rural area
ob?so?lete? ?/??bs??lit, ??bs??lit/ Show Spelled
[ob-suh-leet, ob-suh-leet] Show IPA
adjective, verb, -let?ed, -let?ing.
?adjective
1. no longer in general use; fallen into disuse: an obsolete expression.
2. of a discarded or outmoded type; out of date: an obsolete battleship.
3. (of a linguistic form) no longer in use, esp., out of use for at least the past century. Compare archaic.
4. effaced by wearing down or away.
5. Biology . imperfectly developed or rudimentary in comparison with the corresponding character in other individuals, as of the opposite sex or of a related species.
?verb (used with object)
6. to make obsolete by replacing with something newer or better; antiquate: Automation has obsoleted many factory workers.
Use obsoleting in a Sentence
See images of obsoleting
Search obsoleting on the Web
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Origin:
1570?80; L obsol?tus, ptp. of obsol?scere to fall into disuse, perh. equiv. to ob- ob- + sol ( ?re ) to be accustomed to + -?scere -esce
?Related forms
ob?so?lete?ly, adverb
ob?so?lete?ness, noun
non?ob?so?lete, adjective
sub?ob?so?lete, adjective
sub?ob?so?lete?ly, adverb
sub?ob?so?lete?ness, noun
un?ob?so?lete, adjective
?Can be confused: ? 1. archaic, obsolescent, obsolete ; 2. obsolescent, obsolete .
?Synonyms
2. antiquated, ancient, old.
?Antonyms
1, 2. new, modern.
But yes. Saturday delivery should be eliminated. And Mondays too, if necessary!
No other federal agency of for that matter any private business is required to prepay to this extent and with this burden was to become reasonable then the USPS would have been in the black four (4) or the last five (5) years.
dkramer3's statement of "By not keeping pace with the state of technology they are obsoleting themselves."
Yes technology is always changing look what has happened to the phone in the last five years as it use to be a device to talk on and that was great. Now it is something to type on excuse me "text on" and now instead of having to listening to you inane conversations I have to listen to just as inane laughing while you text. This may seem like advancement to you and the death knell to the Postal Service, but there still millions of people out there that get their medications through the mail. Try that with your phone text!!
johanpdx@... sounds like a good idea to consider. like the fire department being trained to serve as EMT's as well, since they are available and well located to respond.
Direct Mail a.k.a. Junk Mail is a large portion of the revenue channel. Cutting direct mail for fuel efficiency is like amputating the arm for a finger prick.
Where do you think the bulk of the revenue comes from? John Doe's 20-some-odd post cards a year, or the constant influx of direct-market saturation?
The USPS provides uniform service to the public, and is funded not by tax payer dollars, but by the revenue generated from business mail.
I already accept (and require!) payment from clients via ACH. I charge them a fee if they want me to mail them a invoice (as opposed to email) to recover the cost of paper, envelope, postage etc, as well as the extra administrative time in printing, folding, inserting and placing postage as well as the inconvenience of getting them mailed since the USPS has removed all convenient post boxes, and my carrier can't figure out how to pick up outgoing mail from my box when the itty bitty box they provide is packed to the point of the mail coming back out the slot.
So don't deliver on Saturday, it will just be one more reason not to use US mail, IMO.
As the postal service was "Part of the Government" and assumed all the benefits (health insurance, retirement, etc.) of many military and other government employees... There is no way to balance out and become a viable private operation.
>My Nickel's worth
Fire 1/2 of workforce.
End of $7G problem.
Yeah, ask around. Tuesday is the lowest volume day.
As for the reduced cost of bulk mail, advertisers should pay more than they do because of the extra labor needed to meet this demand some of which requires overtime pay.
Dan
For myself and the businesses I support (most of which, admittedly, don't 'post' much any more unless it needs a 'flat rate box'), it's probably likely that cutting all the way down to ONLY Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays wouldn't kill anyone long-term -- so long as the Post Office itself is still open for business through the other weekdays.
Billions of dollars in the red makes for a compelling argument against any throwback entitlement issues customers might feel. Either make it self-sustaining (by raising rates, cutting expenses, etc.), or leave the business. The tax payers have plenty of OTHER bailouts to pay for now, thank you.
Join the conversation!
Quick Poll
Which imaging and document management trends are you most likely to consider?
Related Links
- New White paper: Managed Print Services and Beyond: How You Can Cut Costs and Go Green While Increasing Employee Productivity
- Learn how document management systems can help reduce the tide of paper that is swamping our offices
- Use software to cut costs by scrapping paper
- My printer, my social letterbox
- Doc on Twitter
- Doc on Facebook
- Doc on LinkedIn
Blog Archive
White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
-
Office 365 Migration Guide: Approaches, Techniques and ChallengesNo Headache, No Hassles Microsoft 365 Migration
Your company is ... (Quest Software)Download Now - The Best Ways to Migrate Lotus Notes Applications to SharePoint and Office 365Migrating Notes to SharePoint Online/Microsoft Office ... (Quest Software)Download Now
-
Quest Migration Assessment Tool (QMAT)Get a Free Migration Assessment
Considering a migration? The ... (Quest Software)Download Now



