The Over-Hype about Digital Books
Summary: Seems that Amazon and others have been using statistics that skew the data in a way that makes it seem more meaningful than it really is.
Doc loves the idea of digital books, but he has been a bit skeptical of some of the data out there which would make you think we were already past a tipping point in the move from print to digital. Not so, says Marc Boer, Vice President of IT Strategies, in this video from Whattheythink.com.
Seems that Amazon and others have been using statistics that skew the data in a way that makes it seem more meaningful than it really is.
More from “The DocuMentor”
Topics
Biography
Doc
ZDNet introduces Doc (The DocuMentor), sponsored by RICOH. Through his blog, Doc will educate you about Document Management. So who is Doc? Doc is something of an enigma. He was born to a Russian ballerina and a German electrical engineer who some believe was running covert operations for shadowy corporate interests. Doc grew up in various locations in the United States, although no one seems to know precisely where, least of all Doc. His early schooling was unremarkable except for the time he was caught trying to replace all the mimeograph machines with high-tech color copiers that had mysteriously disappeared from a shipment to Albania. At MIT, he made a name for himself by transforming a large printer into a robot that hunts and eats Roombas. Professionally, he reportedly has seen the insides of more brands, versions, and generations of printer and printer-related hardware than almost anyone. Some say his obsession with paper, printing, and mechanical movement was either started by, or evidenced by, a traumatic childhood episode when he crawled inside an old Xerox 2400 and tried to print himself.
Anyway, Doc has hands on experience with stuff like printer maintenance and fleet management, but his mastery of document management leaves no stone unturned. Important issues like sustainability, security, and regulatory compliance are top of mind for Doc, as are other business technology needs like networking and IT services, making him a true blue IT renaissance man.
Just In
Every aspect of human commerce has come to be dominated by one question: "What can we get away with?" And with today's consumers, the answer is, "Almost anything."
Since putting the Kindle app on my iPhone I've read over 25 books (all bought and paid for except for the old public domain titles) in a period that I would have read, maybe 4 at best. Having several books in my pocket all the time is revolutionary. I care more about reading than I do about putting ever more paper in my house.
Add to that some of us continue to use the traditional form even as we embrace the digital form. I am in a doctoral program and the cost of books would be astronomical. We use digital texts, and from that I choose the ones that I may want to keep around as hard copies.
For non-fiction especially, updates can make the traditional books fairly dated and of reduced value. Take my old encyclopaedia sets for example. Great bindings but truth be told, we would be better of with the trees still around. They are unlike terrific stories that only get better with time and would make great boxed presents or shelf ornamentation for generations.
My wife is a voracious reader and she's getting a Kindle Fire for Christmas. I am tired of dragging boxes of spent novels to the basement!
I love being able to carry around enough books, music, movies and other media to last me for weeks, maybe months! My goal is to replace the hundreds of boxes of books, comics, video, CDs and records that are clogging up my front room with a single external drive, smaller than a box of chocolates, but with the same amount (or more) of content as I have buried and (mostly) inaccessible in those cardboard boxes.
I am always dissapointed when a book I want to read is not available in ePub. It is very dissapointing, and usually ends in me looking for a competing book if it exists. I have moved house 17 times in adulthood, and 5 bookcases + several boxes is more than enough books.
I'm the exact same way. I've moved from place to place, and the last time I threw my back out moving books. Now if a book isn't available digitally, I don't buy the paper edition- I just buy a different e-book.
Digital books are about selling things, not using things. I believe that most people who read prefer print, for many reasons. That may change in twenty, forty, or sixty years, but so will the delivery technology.
Digital books also offer instant gratification. Again, it's about buying and having, not about using.
I resent the suggestion - I am way too cheap to buy a book without actually readin it.
Secondly, you have it exactly backwards. Obviously those who need the physical book are ALL ABOUT HAVING IT versus using it. An e-ink reader is lighter (by an almost inifinite amout), easier to carry (than even a single book), better (with its bookmarks and access to libraries and shops). I am once again reading as much as I did in my teens, because now I can do it conveniently, without the burden on my conscience about filling more shelves with books I hate to part with, but hate to move with.
Here's one person who disagrees with you and enjoys reading on his Playbook (...hey what's that?)
Part of what makes your comment invalid is that the pervasiveness of the computer has made us digital readers, period. We have learned to read and assimilate through that medium to earn a living so we have become good at it. Reading novels that way is simply an extension of something we practice routinely.
We may overtly attempt to 'reclaim' tradition by reading paper but it's now a lifestyle choice. Even leaving PCs aside, phone displays, train and airport schedules, miscellaneous kiosks, supermarket checkout counters, digital payment devices...on an on...the LED rules. We all have become digital readers.
I switched to reading ebooks exclusively because of how much smaller and lighter ebooks are. They're easier to dust, and to move. In addition, most services will let you re-download the file (for those that don't - a good offsite backup will work) so that in the event your house is destroyed, you can't lose them.
I beg to differ. As an IT person the books we read are:
1. thick and heavy (and I'm scared to think about similarly thick and heavy textbooks students need to carry to and from school).
2. the information could become obsolete in a short time (so those thick and heavy books become thick and heavy trash)
3. requires references to other books, Web resources etc. (what is better, having a hyperlink in your digital book that connects to the Internet in an instance, or sit around a computer to type a printed URL? If the book needs to reference a video, is it better to link to youtube to have others watch it in an instant)?
I don't think there is any argument here that real books are inferior to digital ones. Paper books will not entirely go away, but in a few decades I see them cease being distributed and sold in paper. By then those who love paper books, will be asked to print digital books and bind together the paper themselves.
It's not about instant gratification. It's about real value proposition.
What an interesting idea. When codex books were first produced, the purchasers were responsible for binding together the gathered pages by sending them to a binder. I love an old volume;but, I have purchased a Kindle device and see the value in being able to enlarge the print and read when I am working out on the elliptical machines. I also see real value to the adaptive features of having a book read to you with an electronic voice. This will give books to readers with print disabilities. I don't think that we are at the end of five-hundred years of the codex book any more than that the format of 33 and one third LP is gone. There is still a market and many advantages to the codex book. Perhaps the addition of readable (non-backlit) books will change the market and make a move away from perfect and perfect-case bindings and toward quality books with great paper and string bindings. The purists might be willing to pay for these features. For the rest of us, lower costs for readable copies is a good deal.
I'm not sure I understand your position, Old Gray Wolf. You do not wish to have a kindle edition of your novels because you are not interested in paying for this, or because you expect everyone to share your exclusive/exclusionary appreciation for a library of volumes? My own library of volumes is the only possession I deeply value, and I love handling a book, turning its pages, making notes, flipping effortlessly between various sections for comparison. Yet, work keeps me forever bouncing from city to city, country to country, and often enroute to fairly austere locations. I travel light, by necessity; my kindle allows me to read an old Platonic dialogue, work through French exercises, review high school chemistry, pick out a travel guide, and generally re-read old favorites or find new ones--so effortlessly. That is, through digital media, the books become both available (quite the selling point, when you are overseas or otherwise disconnected from your permanent address) and breathtakingly easy to cart around from one flight to another. I am merely one of countless others whose work puts them in the same position, not to mention expatriates working for the state department, expatriates married to non-English speakers, and troops deployed to overseas stations or wars. I suspect, Old Gray Wolf, that you've never been stranded for months at a time in a country where no good English books were available to you; and if this were sometimes your reality (as it is for hundreds of thousands of others), you would latch upon a kindle/nook like a famished pup put before the feast. In other words, I wouldn't presume to argue with your decision not to pay a publisher for producing ebooks (--and I don't understand what's going on there, businesswise), but. . . I feel you take the position too far when appearing to argue that your own distaste for digital books should suffice equally for everyone else.
I normally buy both. a digial copy and a hard book copy. But normal books need to be like a lot of tech books. I buy the hard cover verison of a cisco book and I get a pdf copy for free
But i'm grudgingly adapting!!! Newpapers, books, everything on screen in front. It sounds quaint but I didn't like it! There are OTHERS w my complaint!
There will be a lot of empty bookcases if everything goes digital...besides sitting down to read a paper book is relaxing...holding an e-reader that scrambles the cells in my body or causes cancer doesn't sound relaxing.
Eventually, I think most if not all books will be published in digital format, but that most publishers will also retain a small arm of their physical publishing business so that customers who want to have their favorites around to flip through as real books will place enough value in those books to justify printing and selling them.
I have several bookcases full of books which I have collected over the years with the conviction that "books are my friends." I have, however, noted that every time I move, my "friends" turn on me. I have not purchased that many books for my Kindle because I generally despise DRM -- I do have quite a number of public domain titles, however. But eventually I expect that where books are concerned I will likely grow to consider DRM the lesser evil compared to gravity and volume.
- Les
Doc actually did try to press flowers in his Kindle and the results were less than satisfactory! You make some good points, OldGrayWolf, but Doc thinks you may be a bit out of step with modern publishing. Would you agree to e-book versions of your works if they dramatically increased the audience for them? Seems like every author wants the widest audience possible, and e-books are becoming a great way to reach more readers.
Doc agrees, paperowl, and has a large library of fine books that I'll always treasure, especially those that highlight art and other visual material. There is certainly room in this world for both print books and e-books. It should always be a matter of personal choice. And it's fun, by the way, to give a child a real book.
And how many trees to slaughter to send all the junk mail we receive on a daily basis?
Just to read outdated news, and ads about chinese made clothing.
format.
Bottom line if you love reading, Who gives a Damn about how it's delivered.
All of those folks whining aobut leather-bound with gold lettering, GROW UP!, MOVE UP! stop wasting time in the past!
Join the conversation!
Quick Poll
Which imaging and document management trends are you most likely to consider?
Related Links
- New White paper: Managed Print Services and Beyond: How You Can Cut Costs and Go Green While Increasing Employee Productivity
- Learn how document management systems can help reduce the tide of paper that is swamping our offices
- Use software to cut costs by scrapping paper
- My printer, my social letterbox
- Doc on Twitter
- Doc on Facebook
- Doc on LinkedIn
Blog Archive
White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
-
Office 365 Migration Guide: Approaches, Techniques and ChallengesNo Headache, No Hassles Microsoft 365 Migration
Your company is ... (Quest Software)Download Now - Seven Keys to Success in Managing Your Business-Critical CloudNeed a few tips on how to manage your cloud infrastructure? Here are seven ... (Hewlett-Packard (HP))Download Now
- The Business Value of Adopting Advanced Support Tools and UtilitiesWhat are the difficulties associated with supporting advanced technology ... (Hewlett-Packard (HP))Download Now



