Apple iPad: Is iBooks enough to get Apple back into education?
Summary: Not yet. And maybe it never will be, but I think the more interesting question in education is what changes it will force in the textbook market this year.
Not yet. And maybe it never will be, but I'm not quite as willing to write off the iPad announced Wednesday as I was last week. I'm also not as convinced that my midnight snack tonight should consist of too much crow, either. Like most pundits, I was completely underwhelmed by the device, surprised by its price, and dubious about what it brings to the table. I think the more interesting question in education, though, is what it will force to the table in the next year.
iBooks is what really has me wondering. Wednesday, Apple announced partnerships with Penguin, Harper-Collins, Simon & Schuster, Macmillan, and the Hachette Book Group. Macmillan/McGraw-Hill, of course, is one heck of a big textbook publisher and the iPad just happens to be the first multitouch color e-reader(-like) device that can go with interactive textbooks where the Kindle, Sony Reader, and Nook never could.
The iPad, however, has less than a 10" screen, no keyboard, and no stylus (I know, there are accessories and who wants a stylus, right?). What this means is that it's a nice, if small, platform for viewing textbooks, but taking notes via keyboard or handwriting is out. Apple, however, did a couple big favors for education, whether or not any of us embrace the iPad. First, they standardized to EPUB for their iBooks application. EPUB documents can be read on an awful lot of devices, can be implemented with or without DRM, and EPUB is an extensible standard that will grow as ebooks mature.
The second and arguably more important gift that Apple gave us was to partner with a textbook publisher, push them towards interactive book development, and drag them to the EPUB party. Given Macmillan's size, it isn't a significant stretch to expect other publishers to follow a model that lets them get in on the game.
That game, although centered around iBooks and its iTunes-like store for e-books, will ultimately make a lot more interactive (or simply electronic) content available in a format that is highly usable on netbooks, laptops, and desktops. In fact, one could argue that, despite the lack of multitouch, netbooks with their generally larger screens, built-in keyboards, and lower prices might make better e-textbook readers than the iPad. Without the iPad, though, how long would it have taken publishers to jump on the bandwagon?
That being said, there are a few missing links. Although Jobs mentioned textbooks today, I saw a lot of leisure reading and the New York Times. No revolutionary interaction with texts. It's early though, and I'm more than happy to give this time.
The second is price. $499 was shockingly low. Kudos to Apple on that one. Greedy public educator that I am, though, I want more (or actually, less). We haven't seen if Apple will offer an educational discount, but even $50 would bring the iPad in line with Intel's convertible Classmates (which have built-in EPUB reader software, keyboards, styli, and touch capabilities, but aren't nearly as pretty).
The iPad is, as Jason Perlow puts it, most likely a "game changer". In education, though, I think it will change the e-textbook market far more than it will make most of us want to run 1:1 programs with iPads. Anyway it goes, I'm glad the game is finally changing.
Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.
Talkback
prefer netbooks
this iPad. Netbooks can do more- multitask,
camera, more memory, for less money than the iPad.
My son's 9-inch netbook, which cost $300, pulls up
his 7th grade math textbook from the publisher's
website.
RE: Apple iPad: Is iBooks enough to get Apple back into education?
same size as a laptop keyboard, and I for one am happy
that the face of the iPad is not marred by some ugly (and
greatly limited) chicklet key keyboard. Also, at least one
company has already demonstrated a concept for doing
sophisticated annotations, creating multiple bookmarks,
tagging cross-references, and other actions that are either
more difficult or impossible with a physical textbook, so I
think there's some real promise here. On the first day the
original iPhone was out, who could have dreamed how the
functionality of the device would be exponentially
enhanced by creative and powerful third-party software?
RE: Apple iPad: Is iBooks enough to get Apple back into education?
can do far more than most netbooks plus is true innovation.
Netbooks are just notebooks thrown in a hot clothes dryer.
Small Keyboards, Small Screens. Using a styles on a Netbook
is very uncomfortable. Ergonomics are terrible and to be
quite honest..... they are lousy for kids with special needs.
Now tell me again why I would want one???? It runs Windows?
??? and that is positive Why????
RE: Apple iPad: Is iBooks enough to get Apple back into education?
1) $499 + for an iPad
2) An AT&T line charge
3) $xxx per download of say the New York Times or
a movie
They then want me to pay
1) yyy for an iPhone
2) An AT&T line charge
Then they want me to pay
1) zzz for an iPod
2) xxx per music download
Who can afford all this? Steve Jobs obviously. But the average? I don't think think so. These guys are living on a parallel planet. Sales of the
iPad will be arguably very low. Not because it isn't a fantastic looking device. Its great. But
nobody out here in the real world has unlimited resources. So Apple guys great ideas but until the cost is realistic I'll say no need for an iPhone, no need fo an Ipod and no need for an iPad. Feeding myself comes first. Sorry guys!
RE: Apple iPad: Is iBooks enough to get Apple back into education?
RE: Apple iPad: Is iBooks enough to get Apple back into education?
education market, I would say Mr. Dawson, you have jumped
the shark.
RE: Apple iPad: Is iBooks enough to get Apple back into education?
get these into colleges that are switching to digital
textbooks (like my own, Full Sail Online). Reading
textbooks on my Macbook Pro is not much fun, hard on
the eyes, and not quite as portable or acceptable in some
social situations. These are also great options for law
schools and medical schools where the books are BIG and
HEAVY and there are lots of them. A law student would
much rather carry an iPad than 30 or 40 lbs of law text
books to and from law school every day. This could do for
med students what PDA's did just a few years ago.
I think if higher ed penetration is good enough they could
move down into high schools. They could even bundle
these with a discount to schools in a 1:1 laptop program.
RE: Apple iPad: Is iBooks enough to get Apple back into education?
RE: Apple iPad: Is iBooks enough to get Apple back into education?