Goodbye, Dictionary.com...Hello, Google Dictionary

Summary: And in the more-cool-resources-from-Google department, Google has formalized its dictionary offering. Although google.

And in the more-cool-resources-from-Google department, Google has formalized its dictionary offering. Although google.com/dictionary used to provide aggregated definitions for words from various dictionary resources online, it's now a full-blown dictionary tool that leverages Google's translation technology and provides concise definitions and synonyms.

Although Google's attempt to compete with Wikipedia via its Knol offering has been a remarkably dismal failure for a company that tends to get things right, this is a tool that could displace plenty of other properties like dictionary.com and answers.com. Not only does it provide a really uncluttered interface, but the extensive translation tools are quite useful. While Google Translate is useful for passages or entire sites, often ELL students simply need to clarify a single word; Google Dictionary fills the bill.

Better yet, for those of us who have adopted Google Apps, users can star words and definitions and store them in their Google accounts for reference. While this seems a small thing, like most things Google, it may lend itself to sharing and classroom use in the future as the company expands this offering.

My youngest son recently mastered the dictionary. Guide words, alphabetizing, you name it. He can use a paper dictionary. Great. Guess what? The paper dictionary can't translate the words he finds into 40 languages. It can't offer synonyms and contextual sentences faster than he can get the dictionary off the shelf. And he can't carry the Webster's Dictionary of the English Language (Deluxe Edition) that I won in a spelling bee 20 years ago in his backpack. I really should have titled this post Goodbye Dictionary, shouldn't I?

Topics: Collaboration, CXO, Google

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

22 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • Goodbye, Dictionary.com...Hello, Google Dictionary

    Another pro-Google and nothing to do with education post. Seriously dude, just get with Garret Rogers and combine your blogs with his.

    Google will struggle with this dictionary site just like their other sites. One reason being that Google's employees will forget about it after 6 months. The other reason being that when people think of dictionary they are going to go straight to dictionary.com.
    Loverock Davidson
  • RE: Goodbye, Dictionary.com...Hello, Google Dictionary

    Three words:

    Google, Google Google (or is that just one word)!

    -Happy Holidays
    wallace_marke@...
  • Did you try it???

    Did you try it or even compare it to dictionary.com?? The couple words I entered as tests are a far cry from the resource that is dictionary.com. Before you cry the about the demise of their competitors you should at least give the service a try and make a few comparisons.

    I'd have a lot more respect for this post if you had sited a few differences between Google's dictionary and others.
    XenoChron
    • I think he's hit on a money making scheme

      All he has to do is say that "I just found this Google offereing to be the best" and the replys come rolling in!

      Does he have to try it? Not really, just dump it on the kids, say they all love it, and we do the actuall reseach for him, post the pros and cons for him.

      Not bad.
      John Zern
    • I tried few:-

      Can you please put few examples you tried ?

      I tried few

      1) netbook

      Google dictionary:- netbook is a small portable laptop computer designed for wireless communication and access to the Internet.

      dictionary.com: netbook - no dictionary results

      2) KDE
      Google dictionary:- KDE (K Desktop Environment) is a free software project based around its flagship product, a desktop environment for Unix-like systems. ...

      Dictionary.com:- KDE - no dictionary results

      3) naranga

      google dictionary :- Naranga is a genus of moths of the Noctuidae family.

      dictionary.com: no dictionary results

      4) surendra :-

      google dictionary: Surendra is a genus of butterfly in the family Lycaenidae. It belongs to the sub-family Theclinae often called Hairstreaks. ...

      dictionary.com: surendra - no dictionary results

      5) Balan:

      google dictionary: B?lan (Hungarian: Bal?nb?nya, German: Kupferbergwerk) is a town in Harghita County, Romania. The northernmost municipality in the unofficial region of Felcs?k (Ciucul de Sus), it is also one of Romania's most important centres for copper mining. ...

      dictionary.com:- balan - no dictionary results
      mKind
    • Few more

      1) Lego:

      google dictionary: (trademark) a child's plastic construction set for making mechanical models

      dictionary.com: lego - no dictionary results

      2) HDMI:
      google dictionary: HDMI (High-Definition Multimedia Interface) is a compact audio/video interface for transmitting uncompressed digital data. ...

      dictionary.com: HDMI - no dictionary results

      3) suresh

      Google.com: Suresh (sure?a) is a Sanskrit word which means "Ruler of Gods"; from surya ?god? + ??a ?lord?, which is an epithet of the god Indra.


      Dictionary.com: suresh - no dictionary results

      My point is - It not good enough if a web based dictionary just gives you the meaning of the plain old English words. It has to adapt and learn to stay relevant in the modern globalized world.
      mKind
    • check the dictionary

      Sight - vision
      Site - a location
      Cite - quote
      larason
  • Stop using chrome

    And add dictionary.com search at your search bar in FireFox/IE and words will get much faster for you. IE 8 give power of quick view with google dictionary with its exclusive accelerators.( I don't use it, but just for knowledge)
    And please, for heavens sake... stop being such a big fanboy.
    ArnavM
  • Just another way for Google to expand its database

    Why does Google, just like Microsoft, have to reinvent existing apps and technologies? Just like Microsoft, they do it to make more money. We have no need for another dictionary. Especially one from Google.

    When will you learn that everything you use from Google goes towards building a bigger database on you. And that database is forever. You will regret the day you started depending on "big brother Google" for so many things.
    jorjitop
    • Google's database

      To be abruptly honest, there is nothing that Google produces that doesn't ultimately contribute to their databases. But then, using Firefox, or IE, or Yahoo, or any of the dozens of search engine/browser/toolbar combinations isn't going to hide you any better from the powers that want to know everything about you. Remember your ISP? Have they got the dirt on you!
      Joey1058
  • Why don't you just put a Google logo on your blog?

    You seem to be one of their biggest cheerleaders. Sure glad I don't work for your school district.
    IT_Guy_z
    • And, like why do you get so frustrated that Google comes out with one good

      product after another.
      DonnieBoy
      • Because it's all spyware

        That's why.
        jorjitop
  • Google doesn't have audio recordings

    To help with correct pronunciation, Dictionary.com & MW online have audio links. I don't see this feature from Google. For me, this is a huge part of what make online dictionaries so nice.
    ShadowT
    • Audio etc

      Google translate has audio (for English), thus it will probably show up pretty soon in dictionary too.

      I do like the clean interface and integrated image results in Google dictionary - and I am sure it will improve _fast_
      pfrandsen
  • RE: Goodbye, Dictionary.com...Hello, Google Dictionary

    Google dictionary does not do well with indonesian language.
    iscab
  • Goodbye, Dictionary.com...Hello, Google Dictionary

    I'd say it's a bit premature to say goodbye to dictionary.com, they currently have good features such as the voice clips of the words, that google lacks.

    I do like how Google dictionary is clean and simple whereas dictionary.com seems a bit cluttered. But for now I'd use google dictionary as a secondary resource.
    mrdt
  • RE: Goodbye, Dictionary.com...Hello, Google Dictionary

    I shall show it to my students. The older ones all feel like Google is a their second home anyway.
    deowll
  • Unacceptable for Education. Here's why...

    I wouldn't call myself a "fanboy" of Google, but I do think some of their products are pretty good (Gmail, Calendar, Voice, Notebook, Sites, Blogger). In fact, I go so far as to require all my students to have a Gmail account for school projects that require the use of Google Notebook, Google Docs, and Google sites.

    That said, I'm far from impressed with Google Dictionary. Typical for Google, Google Dictionary is visually cold and uninviting. Why can't Google put just a little effort into making the graphic interface friendly? This is especially important in education, where students are fickle and used to slick interfaces from Apple and sites such as Facebook.

    The absolute deal-breaker for Google Dictionary in education is its complete inability to suggest similar words. If students misspell a word (and that is the norm and not the exception), Google Dictionary simply finds no results, leaving the user with a blank screen. This is unacceptable for an online dictionary--especially for use in education.

    I'm all for supporting a free product. This one, however, doesn't deserve support or use when there are a myriad of other online sites that offer a vastly superior product and are also free of charge.
    poharra
    • Probably the next product...

      I expect Google will probably come out with a 'fuzzy' spelling product... this is Dictionary 1.x anyway.
      RpDnn