Google Wave: Begging for a classroom
Summary: I got my Google Wave invitation Saturday night and, as much as I wanted to race home, log in, and see what all the fuss was about, I decided instead to relish the rest of my 3-day weekend. Now, however, the weekend is essentially over, the sham of a holiday we call Columbus Day is passed, and I'm sitting with my laptop in front of a fire, digging into Google's latest hype-machine.
I got my Google Wave invitation Saturday night and, as much as I wanted to race home, log in, and see what all the fuss was about, I decided instead to relish the rest of my 3-day weekend. Now, however, the weekend is essentially over, the sham of a holiday we call Columbus Day is passed, and I'm sitting with my laptop in front of a fire, digging into Google's latest hype-machine.
And you know what? It's awesome. Not that regular readers would expect anything else from ZDNet's resident Google fanboy, right? I'm not even sure that fellow blogger, Garett Rogers, is quite as enamored of Google's products as I am. Certainly, my district's successful move to Google Apps has reinforced my really positive impressions of the GOOG, even with a clear understanding of just how much they know about me.
That being said, I couldn't agree more with another fellow ZDNet blogger, Dion Hinchcliffe, who recently gave Wave a brief review:
Wave’s complex interface and open-ended feature set provides an unexpectedly steep learning curve, particularly from a company that is famous for simple, powerful user experiences
Wave is, in fact, a bit overwhelming. There are a number of videos that Google has posted on YouTube describing the various features, giving basic how-to's, and orienting users to the service, but it definitely takes some getting used to. The following video only touches on highlights.
So if it's overwhelming, has a steep learning curve, and is only in limited preview, why am I so excited? Wave is overwhelming for 2 reasons:
- It has a fairly rich interface with new, unfamiliar components when the Gmail interface (and webmail in general) is so easily recognized by so many people.
- More importantly, Wave represents a paradigm shift in group communications.
There, I said it: paradigm shift. I'm sorry, I tried not to, but it's hard not to use Wave and think those two horribly overused words. Wave dispenses with email as we know it and moves to what Google calls a "hosted conversation." I won't belabor the features of this conversation. It's been well-reviewed elsewhere. What strikes me about Wave, though, and makes me so willing to climb that learning curve (and drag my users up the slope with me) is its potential.
If you use Wave by yourself, it's an interesting exercise in user interface and building documents with interactive components. However, add some collaborators and things change very quickly. Google's Jeff Keltner reports that some organizations are using Wave in preview, but that this is fairly limited at the moment. Once Wave is more universally integrated in Edu Apps, imagine the possibilities: Each class meeting could have a wave (remember that a "wave" is a conversation hosted in the cloud with access to a variety of Google and third-party tools ranging from flowcharts to Wolfram Alpha). Waves could be used for single days, or extend through multiple meetings and could continue to take contributions after class. Students and teachers can contribute text, video, documents, files from their local computers (Wave supports drag and drop), and can communicate in real time. Waves can interact with blogs and Twitter as well, making the contents of a wave available to a wider audience. The waves can serve as both a record of conversations and notes in the class, but also a platform for groups to generate and review content.
It's different. Different enough that any adoption will require demonstration, training, coaching, and modeling of use cases, many of which don't even exist yet. It's also interactive, engaging, and transformational enough to justify the extra work. We've seen what teachers can do with Web 2.0 tools, videoconferencing, Moodle and other learning management systems, and even vanilla Google Apps. What happens when we give teachers an entirely new platform for sharing with their students and encouraging students to share with each other? I can't wait to find out.
Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.
Talkback
Using Wave to interconnect academic institutions
This would be attractive because:
1. younger generations are very adaptable, to new technology.
2. there is a great deal of collaboration, in the academic world.
3. technical glitches are likely to be more tolerable than at commercial companies.
4. it would offer a large & distributed environment, to stress the technology.
5. it would allow students & researchers to study & contribute enhancements/optimizations to the Wave platform.
6. academic projects, to extend Wave, could lead to an explosion of new startup companies.
7. tech graduates, with Wave experience, would be instrumental in bringing the technology to commercial companies.
IRC going nuclear
I don't feel at ease in an IRC chat, myself. In fact, I hate it. It doesn't allow for careful reading and responding. No time to ponder. Reactions have to be almost instantaneous, or they will be amiss, because the conversation has already drifted elsewhere.
No time for the participants, to thoroughly read a response by one of the inhabitants of the chat room. Even when that person has taken the trouble to prepare a good concise text in advance: everything above three lines of text, won't be read.
So... Google Wave... Great if you're into IRC, I suppose. But if not, then it's not so great.
RE: Google Wave: Begging for a classrom
of Wave rich interface?
RE: Google Wave: Begging for a classrom
RE: Google Wave: Begging for a classrom
Its hard to believe that the best and the brightest working at Google and this is all they could come up with. A rehash of technology. Like I said a million times before, Google doesn't do anything nor do their employees, they wait for others to invent it then they try to stick their name on it. They would much rather sit around and play with office toys then actually do work. And you will be disappointed when they close this service down within 6 months like they have done with other services.
You forgot your pill, love
Well, at least that's treatable. Your stupidity isn't. That makes you utterly unfit for decent society. Which cave do you dwell in, troll?
Star Trek girl is (re)posting again?
It is IRC
Moronic.
code. All computers are pocket calculators.
I'm not sold by the 'paradigm shift' myself, but saying it's
IRC+Whiteboard is like saying Photoshop is just MS Paint with some
filters. Retarded.
ditto moronic
Does that mean gmail is nothing new?
The web is essentially ftp with a visual interpreter. HTML is a subset of SGML which had been around long before Andreesen apparently did NOT create anything new using existing technology.
IRC on steroids just might be the wave of future collaboration.
Google Wave is an application of XMPP/Jabber.
Do you know the difference between a computer salesman and a used car salesman? Hint, the used car salesman knows when he is lying. Now get back out on the floor ans sell that computer stuff for Best Buy!
IRC?
wasn't an F-22 Raptor, nor an A380, and it wasn't even
close, not even recognizable as the same genus.
Neither is your comparison.
RE: Google Wave: Begging for a classrom
Google Wave Invite
RE: Google Wave: Begging for a classrom
harnessed correctly could become a powerful learning tool.
However, this all lies in potential rather then current
usability. Wave as it is now is too much of just another
service I have to check. Group conversations is like
everyone talking at once and confusing. Wave also needs
to interact (maybe with a bot) with traditional mail to hook
in new users. Some of the usability tweaks and tightening
of functionality will happen, but it will be interesting to see
where this ends up. http://jumpcloudsolutions.com/
And everything will be fine...
Wave Sugar?
Wave is about collaboration.
Sugar is about collaboration.
Sugar + Wave = collaboration on steroids?
A pretty good overall description of Wave...
You've pretty much nailed my Wave experience in your article. It was pretty interesting assembling documents as a single user and then things take off with other participants.
For those wanting to see what it's all about, it took about a month to get an account so get cracking and sign up for one if you're interested: https://services.google.com/fb/forms/wavesignupfordev/
The peanut gallery shouting IRC in the back of the room might want to see what it's about before flouting their opinions. They might be surprised. I can understand why they would confuse Wave with IRC & Whiteboard but it really is much more than your daddy's ICQ.
For one thing this is built for the masses. Not for a bunch of geeks living in their parent's basement (Damn I wish the internet were around before I moved out... I'd still be there...).
Another key differences is the ability for developers to create our own plugins and bots as well as the ability for us to embed Waves inside otherwise static web pages. Oh, that and the fact that it runs in a browser and you can drag and drop applications into a Wave that will provide further interactivity, like a game of Chess.
Paradigm shift?... Yeah, I think this could be a paradigm shift when it releases.
RE: Google Wave: Begging for a classrom
My only other concern in all of this is that they are swiftly being seen by the computer dummies and "tech savvie" young as the only avenue for innovation - hopefully others' innovations are not totally overlooked in the process or we ultimately lose out.
Interesting, but will it take off?
What I'd [b]really[/b] like is for all of these social networks to quite being so hyperactive and settle on something. Doesn't have to be something perfect, but has to be something that works.