Egyptian sentenced to three years for defaming Islam on Facebook

By | October 23, 2011, 11:00am PDT

Summary: Ayman Hassan Mansour has been sentenced to three years in prison for Facebook posts found to be insulting to the Islamic religion.

A Cairo court has sentenced Ayman Hassan Mansour to three years in prison for postings on Facebook. He was charged with “exploitation of religion to promote extremist ideas with the intention of inciting sectarian strife, damaging national unity, and insulting the Islamic religion.”

Mansour reportedly confessed to the charges, but did not provide justification for his actions. Police tracked Mansour online and arrested him in August. Judge Sherif Kamel, head of the Azbakiya Court of First Instance, said Ayman Youssef Mansour created the Facebook Page “Al-Monadel Mard” and used it to express opinions that threaten national unity.

The MENA state news agency reported the misdemeanor court found the defendant willfully used “outrageous and scurrilous” words to defame the Quran, the religion of Islam, the Prophet of Islam, as well as Muslims and members of his household, according to CBS News. It did not say what exactly he had written that was deemed to be offensive.

See also:

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

Emil Protalinski has covered the tech industry for five years for multiple publications.

Disclosure

Emil Protalinski

Emil has nothing to disclose.

Biography

Emil Protalinski

Emil Protalinski has covered the tech industry for five years for multiple publications, including Neowin for two years and Ars Technica for three years. He has written 1,000s of articles for both, with a particular focus on scrutinizing Microsoft products and services. Recently, Emil has expanded his coverage to non-Microsoft technologies, including the social networking giant Facebook.

30
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

I agree
stephen714 14th Apr
I totally agree with you.
Thank you religion for the thousands of years of war and supression of free speech and science!
@Martijn2
You don't need to blame that on religion itself, but specific ideas and beliefs of certain religions, and how many people misuse them for their own power and control.
@doh123
Name a religion that has cured a disease.

The whole concept of faith over evidence is destructive and counter-productive by definition.
That's impossible, as religions are ideas.

That would be like saying which scientific theory has cured a disease. The answer would be the same: none.

Ideas can't do anything, it takes a person with an idea to do something.
@Onaka
You assume faith has no evidence, or are separate things. Many who have never experienced faith, or have closed their minds to it, do not understand it, but rationalize what it must be to try to explain it for themselves. Some people do believe just to believe, so I cannot speak for everyone. For myself, as a Christian, I have a personal relationship with Jesus. i have had his existence proven to me. But proof in this type of endeavor is usually very personal, so what might be undeniable proof to one person, can mean nothing to someone else. Many people miss it, or just find it later on... not everyone is saved. Also many times many people do horrible things in the name of some religion, but thats just that person misusing a religion to try to get their own way. Don't assume everyone who claims to follow some certain faith is telling you the truth.
@Martijn2 Actually religious people are the ones that largely brought about free speech and science. I'm most familiar with astronomy on science so how about Copernicus, Galileo, Kepler, Newton? Mendel? For free speech how about the founding fathers who wrote about God given rights? If you want to get picky and only draw from one side then science has brought us mustard gas, atomic bombs, pollution, child labor (industrial revolution), etc.
@boomchuck1 ; your post is GREAT! Thankyou!
@boomchuck1 - our founding fathers were mostly all deists and had a healthy and well founded distrust of the clergy. It has been the clergy (not religion, per se) that has practiced oppression and misogyny since the beginning of human culture. You can't deny the history.
@Martijn2 Islam is not a religion in those parts of the world, it is a government.
In islam there is no such thing as faith over evidence. We have faith, evidence and common sense pls google proofs of islam and click the first link for some of them stay blessed
Their day is coming, very soon you'll see the lot of them at war and it is likely to end bad for them. Of course they'll cry foul while never owning the guilt of their own oppression!
0 Votes
+ -
"the defendant willfully used ???outrageous and scurrilous??? words to defame the Quran, the religion of Islam, the Prophet of Islam, as well as Muslims and members of his household, according to CBS News. It did not say what exactly he had written that was deemed to be offensive."

Because I'd reproduce his posts on my page if I thought they had merit.
so much for the freedom the people revolted for!
Thank you for the Author of this Article.

Let's see how much time it will stick in the web, before the dictators of political correctness attack.

Where are the advocates of free speech, and the ones who promote the "Arab spring" Democracy and Freedom?
Where are the defenders of the Minorities?

Either way this page is already in Zotero.
0 Votes
+ -
Obama helped topple Mubarak
richardschennberg 24th Oct
Obama practically demanded Mubarak to step down, gave him no support in effecting a peaceful transition, and did so while consulting none of Egypt's neighbors, not even Saudi Arabia. The resulting "Arab Spring" is not led by normal mainstream Muslims, but by a coalition of leftists and religious fanatics who crush both economic and personal freedoms. Yet our President is happy about the outcome. Could this be what he also wants for America?
I am a Christian, and don't like some of the things that (radical) Muslims do...however, if we were to ban it from the US we would be no better than the militant practitioners and go against everything our Country was founded on. I don't believe in bombing abortion clinics, burning witches, or going on crusades killing infidels either.

PS. @ Boomchuck1 and Doh123 - Nice posts.
Religion of peace...
0 Votes
+ -
Ha! That's rich!!!
omb00900@... Updated - 24th Oct
This poor fellow is accused of exploitation of religion to promote extremist ideas with the intention of inciting sectarian strife, damaging national unity, and insulting the Islamic religion.

Gee. Isn't that EXACTLY what the Muslim Brotherhood is doing? Talk about the pot calling the kettle black!

This story tells me that the "Arab Spring" in Egypt is doomed, as it likely is everywhere else in the Mideast. You can't have liberty without codifying our 1st Amendment, word for word! And what chance is there of that in any single Islamic country? The clergy wields too much power and wouldn't allow it. I wrote the following little ditty, which says it all...

Arab Spring

All across the Middle East, an Arab Spring doth bloom,
and all the free world wonders if for liberty there's room.
Amidst the din of pundits, there's one real truth that I know.
Without our First Amendment, freedom has no chance to grow!

Of all the tenets in that brilliant codification,
the keystone without which all the others surely fall,
it's not redress, assembly, speech or publication,
it's separation of church from law that trumps them all!

Good government can't be had without a fair debate,
but discourse becomes fixed, if religion must abide.
One needn't be a prophet to see an argument's fate,
when one side can make the claim that God is on their side!

(that's my story, and I'm sticking to it)
"exploitation of religion to promote extremist ideas with the intention of inciting...."

Then why aren't their courts going after all the ones promoting and inciting the death of infidels, the enslaving of women, etc???
0 Votes
+ -
Islam
stephen714 14th Apr
Because Islam is a sick and evil religion, if you could even call it that.
you keep believing, I'll keep evolving!
amazing that one can be accused of defaming (only) one of the many gods worshipped. What about the hundreds you do not believe in?
0 Votes
+ -
Muslims
stephen714 14th Apr
Didn't you know Islam is special? They get to kill other religious people because their religion is the only truth. What a creepy religion.
0 Votes
+ -
Islam Sucks
acyron 26th Mar
Ok I'm defaming the Islamic religion, " They're a bunch of devil worshipers" Ok I've ???exploitation of religion to promote extremist ideas with the intention of inciting sectarian strife, damaging national unity, and insulting the Islamic religion.??? What you devil worshipers gonna do about it?
0 Votes
+ -
Islam Sucks
acyron 26th Mar
I also wish I had two copies of the koran so I could deficate on one and cover it with the other just before I burn them in a garbage dump..
0 Votes
+ -
I agree
stephen714 14th Apr
I totally agree with you.
0 Votes
+ -
The Arab spring is a disaster. Instead of stable, tolerant government we have precisely the opposite. Western leaders cheered on thousands to their deaths to see dictators removed, but yet again had no ideas for what was to follow.
0 Votes
+ -
Islam is evil
stephen714 14th Apr
The actions of Muslim countries prove that Islam is an evil and sick religion. The Arab spring is truly a mess that will benefit no one except the Muslim clerics. This religion should be outlawed around the world, just as they are intolerant of other relgions.

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix