Yahoo warns Facebook may infringe 16 patents with open source

Yahoo warns Facebook may infringe 16 patents with open source

Summary: Yahoo has warned Facebook that the social networking giant allegedly infringes on 16 more patents. This time, the patents are about open source technology used in Facebook data centers and servers.


When Facebook amended its initial public offering (IPO) filing the second time, the third time, and the fourth time, the company kept updating it with new information about Yahoo's legal threats. Facebook today amended its IPO a fifth time and released its IPO prospectus. Sure enough, Facebook has more to warn about the Yahoo threat.

Here's the relevant excerpt:

Yahoo could in the future assert additional patent or other claims against us in this or in other proceedings. For example, we received a letter dated April 23, 2012 from Yahoo indicating that they believe 16 patents they claim to hold "may be relevant" to open source technology they allege is being used in our data centers and servers. Yahoo has not threatened or initiated litigation with respect to matters described in this letter but it may do so in the future.

The letter in question is embedded above. Facebook has responded to it by saying it has no plans to back down.

"Yahoo's letter takes aim not just at Facebook but at open source and energy-efficient green technologies developed and employed by countless innovative, forward-thinking companies and engineers," a Facebook spokesperson said in a statement. "We're defending vigorously against Yahoo’s current lawsuit, and would likewise do so against any new assertions."

The disputed patent total is currently at 22: first 10 Yahoo patents, then 10 Facebook patents, and finally two more Yahoo patents. Will we see that number jump to 36? I think Facebook will add more patents to its side of the battle first: some of its own, some of the patents it bought from IBM, and some AOL patents it's buying from Microsoft.

The first slew patents Yahoo used in its legal attack against Facebook were regarding Web technologies. Now, Yahoo is considering doing the same for patents it has regarding Web infrastructure, including a lot of the open source technologies that run it. In other words, Yahoo is insisting that since it was on the Internet first, it not only invented the Web that users see in their browsers, but the underlying hardware that powers it as well.

See also:

Topics: Legal, Banking, Open Source, Social Enterprise

Emil Protalinski

About Emil Protalinski

Emil is a freelance journalist writing for CNET and ZDNet. Over the years,
he has covered the tech industry for multiple publications, including Ars
Technica, Neowin, and TechSpot.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


Log in or register to join the discussion

    What no one has picked up on or discussed is
    "We also understand that at least oneYahoo! employee who had responsibility in connection with Yahoo's data centers and now has responsibilitys over the operations of Facebook???s data center" This raises the spector of intentional infringement, perhaps theft of trade secrets, treble damages and attorney fees. We do not knoew the employee, but if he is a key inventor on any of these patents it could be major..major point in any litigation, and perhaps more importantly negotiations.
    Anshu Aggarwal
    Geoff Hardy
    Kevin Epstein
    Paul Andre Gauthier
    Peter Mattis
    Marco Lara
    Stanley Yamane
    Jason DeBettencourt,
    Scott Noteboom
    Albert Dell Robison
    Jesus Suarez,
    Norman Holt,
    Stefan Reitshamer
    Freeland Knight Abbott III
    Arthur Charles Thomas Huston
    Depankar Neogi
    Matthew Denis Haines
    Adam Louis Beguelin
    Michael Alexander Chowla
    Swapnil Shah
    Keith Weng
    Arthur Mateos
    John Plevyak
    Brian Toty
    David Gourly
  • take a Personality Test zuck

    Mark Zuckerberg says that he never saw the Leader white papers, Fenwick did not disclose this information about facebook to Michael McKibben .
    zuckerberg sent david a copy of this white paper, david contacted Michael McKibben about this, Patent No. 7,139,761 as a ???prior art Fenwick did not disclose this