Neither the windows tablet devices nor the iPad really satisfy what I believe will the the mass users needs. I have been using a windows tablet device since they first came out and will not get the iPad as it is currently configured with available software. My perfect tablet device, (taken from my own experience and my non-tech wife's habits are as follows:
1. Portability: light and small enough to carry around with you all the time. To be fully productive and used, its got to be with you most of the time. iPad fits this bill nicely.
2. Long Battery Life: Without overstating the obvious, the longer the better. With that being said, there will be times that you will need to recharge the battery so you will need the ability to carry a replacement battery or a small enough recharger to be able to carry with you most of the time. Kudos to the iPad.
3. Instant On: This is where the iPad really shines and Windows lags significantly. If I have a thought or need to write a note right away, I can't wait for Windows to load. As much as I have used a tablet, it just doesn't work well for this. For my wife, who rights on stickey notes and leaves them all over the place, this also would be a big one. Again, the iPad shines.
4. Handwriting with a stylus: This is where Windows tablets shine and the iPad flutters. At a moments notice, and no matter how fast I type, if I have to write a quick note, typing on a tablet doesn't cut it. I still like to hand write quick notes and that is an absolute definite for my wife. I'm pretty good at typing on my smart phone, but it is still not the same as handwriting a note on a pad or sticky note.
5. Handwriting Recognition: Again, the Windows Tablet shines here. I am not talking about conversion of handwritten notes to text, although that is a good thing, I am talking more about recognition for the purpose of accessing the data in a database for later use. Big thumbs up to the Windows Tablet.
6. Software Database Applications using handwriting recognition: Not this takes all of the above and puts it all together in a meaningful way to the average and vast consumer and user base out there. This is coming up with software that not only a geek could use but my wife would use. With this type of software, (the pieces are already out there), my wife could write, in her handwriting, using a stylus, a note on a yellow sticky on the screen as follows: "Call Joe Smith at 949.399.4555, next Wednesday to discuss Erin Jones new position with Yogi Company in Dallas regarding their new regional director job." The software would automatically recognize the handwritten words and calendar the task for next Wednesday in her calendar, connect the sticky or note to Joe Smith, Erin Jones and the Yogi Company as well as the project relating to the new regional director job in Dallas. What I see is a blog or wikki like log that can also be viewed by date of entry or searched in any other fashion. She wouldn't need to file anything but the sticky would be totally organized for her so that she could find it and not forget it later on. Another example would be a sticky, "Pick Lauren up at school at 2:00 pm." Without doing anything further it gets put into her tablet calendar which is synced with her desktop and phone and she gets an automatic reminder at 1:45 or any other time that she chooses. The is taking technology and molding it for the way that most people work while allowing them the great benefits of the technology. Now this is something that I would like to see in my lifetime.