If Forrester likes Macs for IT today, they’ll love Chromebooks tomorrow
Summary: A new Forrester report suggests that IT should start embracing the use of the Mac - but for reasons that suggest they'll soon be singing the praises of Chromebooks, too.
Forrester Research has had a change of heart when it comes to Macs in the workplace - and while that headline appears to be somewhat of a blow to Microsoft, it also validates what Google has been touting with its Chromebooks.
A new Forrester report, as told by Fortune, explains that Macs are now the computer of choice by the power users of a company - "executives, top sales reps and other workaholics" - for two reasons. One reason is silly but true: just as execs and other high-profile employees drive luxury cars or wear expensive suits, the computer they carry into a business meeting is also a status symbol of sorts.
The second reason has a bit more meat to it. Fortune, which obtained a copy of the $499 report and excerpted it in a post, quoted one of the report's reasons why power users prefer Macs over Windows:
Time is the only thing that these fierce competitors can't make more of. Many of today's corporate PCs are saddled with management, backup, and security agents that can bog down a PC. Employees want their PCs to boot in 10 seconds, not 10 minutes, and they don't want to have to get a cup of coffee while opening a 20 MB spreadsheet in Excel. They're drawn to uncluttered Macs — especially those with solid-state drives, which are more responsive and boot in seconds.
Did you notice that fast boot times were mentioned twice? Since the beginning, Google has been selling fast boot time as part of its Chromebook pitch, arguing that browser-based computing in a cloud environment is not only more efficient but also much faster. The report also noted that users are impatient about the time it takes to open programs like Excel - but that's a bit misleading. Boot times for those bloated Office programs can also take some time on a Mac, as well.
Google's other selling point has been around Google Apps, which competes with Microsoft for business productivity programs. While not nearly as feature rich as Word or Excel, Google Docs and the other productivity programs open quickly in the browser and allow access from any Web-connected device.
It wasn't that long ago that Forrester and others were suggesting that there was no reason for an IT department to support anything outside of a Windows world, that Windows was the standard. Now, they realize that Mac users are "information workers who use new technologies and find innovative ways to be more productive and serve customers more effectively."
"Mac users are your HEROs," or Highly Empowered and Resourceful Operatives, and should be embraced by IT departments, not hinder, the report said.
As a Mac user, I'm glad Forrester is finally recognizing the importance of the power user. As someone who also sees value in what Google is trying to do with Chrome, Android and the browser, I think Forrester will soon be recognizing that Google users, more so than Mac users, are the real HEROs of IT.
Related:
- New Chromebook pricing scale targets businesses, schools
- Google's Chromebook for business: Interesting math, but your mileage will vary
- Can you live in the Chromebook Cloud?
- What's wrong with Google's Chromebook?
- The first Chromebook review: Samsung Series 5
Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.
Talkback
well..
cheers
Anshu Prateek
RE: If Forrester likes Macs for IT today, they�¢��ll love Chromebooks tomorrow
As for Chromebook, the old "let's make that functional PC a proprietary terminal" scam, never dies.
RE: If Forrester likes Macs for IT today, they�ll love Chromebooks tomorrow
As you can imagine, I'm not a huge fan of an OS that in only one week destroyed 30+ hours of work. I now print lecture pdf's to write notes on, and make my powerpoints on my windows machine because it actually works.
RE: If Forrester likes Macs for IT today, they�ll love Chromebooks tomorrow
I switched to mac for that very same reason many years ago.
That's my experience...
I wonder how much...
I agree. It is rather odd that they would base their user assesments
from what the user purchases, instead of what they actually do.
also the line is highly imaginative:
[i]Employees want their PCs to boot in 10 seconds, not 10 minutes, and they don???t want to have to get a cup of coffee while opening a 20 MB spreadsheet in Excel[/i]
What is also odd is that they claim that [i]PC's are saddled with management, backup, and security agents that can bog down a PC[/i]
If a Mac is on a corporate environment, would it not need to be saddled with management, backup, and security agents also?
To propose that a Mac does not need to be backed up indicates that the research was taken from a biased approach, the researcher being a fan (shareholder) of Apple possibly?
One, I have never seen a Windows PC take 10 minutes to boot. I have never seen a 20 MB Excel file either. The largest Excel file I have seen opened in less then 30 seconds.
I imagine it would take much longer on the Mac version.
RE: If Forrester likes Macs for IT today, they�ll love Chromebooks tomorrow
Besides which, there are plenty of computers that have SSDs in them. My desktop at home has antivirus, backup tools and all the rest, and it boots up in 20 seconds thanks to its SSD.
At the end of the day, the Mac is ONLY a status symbol. There are no other true advantages.
Argh, you beat me to it
Completely in agreement here. Corporate policies will dictate that *any* PCs hooked up to the corporate network will be required to have monitoring of the machines by security & backup systems, so Macs won't escape there. The faster boot time of an SSD-equipped OS X is primarly due to the *SSD* drive; try putting one into a Windows machine, & see the boost to boot time you'll get. Plus, the *only* Windows PCs I've ever seen take even close to 10 minutes to boot up were machines with a) virus infections, b) insufficient memory to run Windows and/or the software the user had installed to run at startup (toolbars, iTunes, etc.), or c) had a hard drive about to fail.
As for 20 MB Excel files...haven't seen those either. But I work with a 20 MB Access database at work, stored on a network drive. Even with having to log in with a username, it pops up within 15-20 seconds tops. That's not even enough time to walk to & from the fax machine, let alone get a cup of coffee.
Plus, even if a PC takes 1 orf 2 minutes to boot up,
RE: If Forrester likes Macs for IT today, they�¢��ll love Chromebooks tomorrow
<a href="http://bedavaoyun.eu">bedava oyun</a>
RE: If Forrester likes Macs for IT today, they�ll love Chromebooks tomorrow
Also, what about the stuff that needs IE?
RE: If Forrester likes Macs for IT today, they�ll love Chromebooks tomorrow
You must live in another planet
Lack of budget and the high initial cost of moving away into something else prevent the move from happening. On top of that, new garbage (like Sharepoint) add loads of weight to the problem.
Sounds like a bad IT policy, then
There shouldn't be *any* sites at *any* company that are "Optimized for Browser X/Recommend that User uses Browser X". That's just bad IT & web design policy.
Business software that still is not on Mac is extremely rare, so by far ...
RE: If Forrester likes Macs for IT today, they�ll love Chromebooks tomorrow
Yet the only passing reference to this important new change in doctrine by Forrester Research is a Google spin on the topic by Sam in the "Googling Google" ZDNet section weeks
Interesting.
RE: If Forrester likes Macs for IT today, they�ll love Chromebooks tomorrow
Who are these "power users"?
They will NOT be happy when their cloud-based apps and/or data are unavailable. For most "power users", tomorrow is a long time from today. Save for those ensconced in modern, densely-populated regions of the planet that have the infrastructure to support cloud-based computing. However, most of the planet lacks this infrastructure. Do any of these "power users" travel? Not to mention that cloud providers and ISPs still have issues with downtime that always makes for good headlines here at ZDNet and elsewhere.
Distraction
RE: If Forrester likes Macs for IT today, they�ll love Chromebooks tomorrow