Dear Congress, guess what? We already have copyright laws.
Summary: What you need to do, my dear politician friends, is to stop listening to the lobbyists and start listening to the innovators.
I know some of you in Congress are baffled by all the fuss us Internet geeks are making about your precious little SOPA and PIPA. I know some of you think you're protecting intellectual property and all us digital types just want to freely do whatever we want online, without regard to who owns what.
You are incorrect and misinformed.
In fact, most of us digital types make our living from our intellectual property. When some sleezebag in a foreign country republishes this article (and does so over, and over, with slightly changed wording using a tool called "spinning"), that criminal will be stealing money I'd otherwise use to feed my family.
Most of us make our living online. And, for the record, we're the ones who have given you what little economic boom we have left in this country after your buddies at the banks and the mortgage companies tried to pick your constituents clean.
I can speak personally about how demoralizing it is to find a digital product I spent years creating -- years with little sleep and bills to pay, years missing the social life I'd otherwise have had, years of actual, true sweat equity -- being sold on a foreign web site, without a dime coming to me or my family.
I can also speak personally about the frustration of having to make the choice of whether or not to support customers who paid real money for the software I wrote, but paid it to someone I had never met, someone who didn't have my permission to sell it, someone who kept all the money, stealing my hard work. In the end, I chose to support those customers, because I felt it was the right thing to do.
So let me make it clear that we, the people of the Internet, understand software piracy and we hate the scum who steal our work. But just because we dislike the people who steal our work doesn't mean we want you to dismantle the foundations of the most astounding human creation since the wheel.
When your legislative ancestors were in Washington, they actually did some good. They wrote laws, they created agencies, and they set up systems that would, in fact, stand the test of time. We have copyright law, with lots of depth and nuance. When someone steals our intellectual property, copyright law comes into play.
International copyright law is more complex, but even there, we have a Commerce Department, we have international treaties, and we have enforcement procedures.
The reason we, the people of the Internet, have pushed back so hard on SOPA and PIPA (and will continue to do so, even though you'll inevitably try to sneak something nasty in somewhere else) is that we know we have laws that can be used to protect us.
We also know that SOPA and PIPA and their ilk aren't designed to protect artists and writers, musicians and producers, programmers and filmmakers. We know SOPA and PIPA are designed to line the pockets of the lawyers and lobbyists at the MPAA and the RIAA.
After all, while we were creating the greatest communications transformation since the Tower of Babel, your MPAA and RIAA friends were terrorizing grandmothers and college students, bullying them into turning over their remaining life savings or college tuition savings, just so your friends could increase their war-chest, strike fear into the hearts of their loyal customers, and all those lawyers could get paid their $500/hour rates.
We, the people of the Internet, may not have the normal infrastructure for influencing politicians, but we have the ability to communicate in ways that will take your breath away. We invented this stuff, we can reach billions of people in a heartbeat, we can shock voters into awareness with an impact you can only dream of, and our power will only get stronger.
You, and countries like China and Belarus and Iran can try to squelch us, but we will route around. And, sadly, so will the criminals. So if you ever try to legislate an ill-advised technical fix to a societal behavior problem, it won't work. People are infinitely adaptable, and just as we will adapt to keep the lines of communication open, so too will the criminals.
What you need to do, my dear politician friends, is to stop listening to the lobbyists and start listening to the innovators. No, we're not going to wine and dine you with the fancy lunch you've been promised by the lobbyists, but if you listen to us, we might allow you to go back to Washington for another term.
Do not try to break the Internet. It was designed to survive nuclear war for a reason. It is stronger and more resilient than you can possibly imagine, and it will fight back.
We the People of the Internet, in order to form a more perfect world, establish justice, insure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity, do ordain and establish that you shall not muck with our pipes.
See also:
- 5 reasons why SOPA, PROTECT-IP and other legislative idiocy will never die
- SOPA: So how much does it cost to buy off America's Internet freedom?
- Everything that's wrong about politics: latest SOPA and PROTECT-IP outrage
- Dear Congressman Posey, SOPA is both dangerous and un-American
- Technology policy challenges faced by the U.S. Federal Government (video seminar)
- Google to protest SOPA, alongside Wikipedia, Reddit, others
- Wikipedia confirms site blackout to protest SOPA anti-piracy bill
- Geeks 1, Congress 0: Controversial anti-piracy bill SOPA 'shelved'
So, what do you think? Should Congress wise up? Heh, there's a leading question! TalkBack below.
Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.
Talkback
RE: Dear Congress, guess what? We already have copyright laws.
RE: Dear Congress, guess what? We already have copyright laws.
+10
RE: Dear Congress, guess what? We already have copyright laws.
+10, +100...
David, that matches my sentiment exactly.
Congress - please have the Executive Branch (ala the DoJ) enforce the copyright laws we have on the books before introducing new ones. If the DoJ isn't enforcing the laws passed by Congress, then you have the authority to question the Exec Branch on it, and if they refuse to enforce the laws you passed, then impeach where necessary. Constitution is there for a reason... But instead of following that, its more fun to pass more laws...
RE: Dear Congress, guess what? We already have copyright laws.
Think about it, China, Iran, Venezuela and Cuba can censor whatever they want, it only affects their own people who can decide how long they will take it, but it does not really affect people from other countries, if SOPA and PIPA pass, the rest of the world will have to either sit and silently accept what one small group in one country decides, or find a way to bypass the US and do our own.
You might say: go ahead, you filthy foreigner and do your own, but this would set the US on the fringe of the internet and would make you lose even more jobs, plus it would be a painfull startover.
We all need a free internet and we'll get it regardless of what these money mongers do.
RE: Dear Congress, guess what? We already have copyright laws.
Exactly.
RE: Dear Congress, guess what? We already have copyright laws.
If these laws had passed, the US would have been an online 3rd World Country overnight. Not to mention the number of jobs lost. Our whole economy is internet based now, not Hollywood based. Lose the internet, and it's all gone. In the US entertainment industry, isn't Hollywood smaller than the video game industry economically? But they obviously have more friends in Washington than the video games industry...
all very well
RE: Dear Congress, guess what? We already have copyright laws.
Casual theft is just part of the cost of doing business in human society. The goal should be to reduce it, but the idea of nobody doing anything dishonest will never happen.
exactly
RE: Dear Congress, guess what? We already have copyright laws.
RE: Dear Congress, guess what? We already have copyright laws.
Why is everyone so obsessed about the thieves? This has nothing to do with the thieves. These are the people that called VCRs the Boston Strangler and compared themselves to a poor woman alone at home. This was NEVER about piracy. It doesn't target pirates. This is about abrogating due process and violating first amendment rights. Period.
RE: Dear Congress, guess what? We already have copyright laws.
Let parents (and you know what little kids can do to a dvd/cd) make a digital copy of their movies. Digtal copy and Ultraviolet are not consumer friendly.
Quite simply - stop treating the paying customer as a potential criminal.
RE: Dear Congress, guess what? We already have copyright laws.
It's not even about price. I think paying $3.99 to stream a bad movie is absurd. Did I steal it? No. Read a book. Go to codeyear and sign up to LEARN something. For $3.99 you can subscribe to TIME for like 6 months. It's like a week for digital delivery of the NYTimes. Ride a bicycle. Go to the gym. If you're an American and you're reading this, you're probably fat. In short, it has nothing to do with piracy. If the industry wants to have a expensive product constrained to shoddy distribution channels, I will exercise a legal alternative for the use of my time.
RE: Dear Congress, guess what? We already have copyright laws.
oh dear
RE: Dear Congress, guess what? We already have copyright laws.
I agree that our freedoms are being eroded one by one and very slowly so we don't notice it. It's time to make the government for the people and by the people, not for big corporations and conglomerations to tell us how to live.
RE: Dear Congress, guess what? We already have copyright laws.
RE: Dear Congress, guess what? We already have copyright laws.
defend?
"a general address to any who would defend Draconic laws such as the ones proposed (you being the first I came across).'
you got that from my post? you got from my post i'm defending this?
you care to enlighten me how you did that?
RE: Dear Congress, guess what? We already have copyright laws.
Yeah, well, I accuse you of stealing cars. You sir, are a car thief. You should go to prison. You are scum. In fact, lets codify it into law. It should be a law that if I see anyone driving a car, I can decide if I think they're a thief, take their car for myself and send them to prison for up to five years.