Outsourcing: End-run around privacy restrictions

Outsourcing: End-run around privacy restrictions

Summary: Strict limits on the information government can collect are not applicable when the collection is done by contractors. A GAO report recommends changes.

By outsourcing the building of rich dossiers, the government is sidestepping checks on surveillance approved in the wake of domestic spy scandals involving the FBI, Army and other agencies in the 1960s and 1970s.

That, according to the Washington Post, is the essence of an 83-page Government Accountability Office report on privacy rights.

The problem is that private companies are not held to the same standards as government, even though the effect on citizens' privacy is the same.

According to the Post, GAO studied the information buying practices of the Justice Dept., the Dept. of Homeland Security, the State Dept. and the Social Security Administration, and found the agencies
often do not limit the collection and use of information about law-abiding citizens, as required by the Privacy Act of 1974 and other laws. The agencies also don't ensure the accuracy of the information they are buying, according to the GAO report. That's in part because of a lack of clear guidance from the agencies and the Office of Management and Budget on guidelines known as "fair information practices," the report said.

At the same time, the contractors are not bound by those "fair information practices," and they often don't comply with all of them, the report said. Companies do not notify individuals when information is collected, for instance. They limit individuals' access to records about themselves, and they generally do not have provisions for correcting mistakes, the report said.

Congress should pass rules requiring private companies to adhere to the stricter rules, the report says.

Topics: Government, Outsourcing, Privacy

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


1 comment
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • End run around privacy

    I agree. Too much information is being collected by commercial interests. The credit bureaus are just the tip of the iceberg. At least the credit bureaus are regulated by law. Other "data aggregators" collect all sorts of information, such as what items you purchase with your credit cards or debit cards and where you buy them, what magazines and newspapaers you subscribe to, and the Lord only knows what else. Merchandizers, banks, landlords and employers then use this information to tailor advertizements, decide whether to hire you, rent to you, allow your child into their private school, and much, much more. It is time for Congress to put a stop to all of this data collection. The first step - strictly regulate who may know a person's Social Security Number. The Social Security Number should only be used for communication with the IRS and the SSA - NOT FOR ANY OTHER PURPOSE. Violation should be considered a felony - in the case of a corporation, for both the officers and the employees.
    Jalapeno Bob