ie8 fix
madison

Broadcast networks blocking Google TV's access to shows on their Websites

By | October 24, 2010, 5:58am PDT

Wanna watch full episodes of your favorite shows from the networks’ own Websites using your new Google TV device? Well, you can’t, thanks to ABC, CBS, and NBC blocking their sites using Google’s just-released platform.

You can probably figure out why. The big three can still sell a lot more advertising for their TV broadcasts instead of their online streams, so they have no interest in allowing easy ways for viewers to circumvent those commercials. Of course, if you record those same episodes with a DVR and fast-forward through those ads, it’s apparently not as big an issue, but the networks seem to be digging their heels in to face this latest threat to their business model. Disney, which owns ABC, and NBC are also unhappy with how Google deals with (or doesn’t sufficiently deal with) links to pirated content that shows up in its search results.

ABC and NBC are allowing Google TV owners to view episode trailers on their sites, and Fox hasn’t blocked full-length episodes on its site — yet. Cable channels like HBO and TBS/TNT have worked with Google to optimize their site videos for Google TV. Ironically, episodes on sites of some cable channels that the networks co-own, like Lifetime and CNBC, are still available to Google TV customers.

One thing we don’t know is how many people have thus far tried to access full-length episodes via Google TV. Was it a sufficient number to be worth the PR hit the networks are taking from looking a tad oafish in blocking content?

[Via The Wall Street Journal]

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

Sean Portnoy is a freelance technology journalist.

Disclosure

Sean Portnoy

Sean Portnoy is a freelance technology journalist; currently, all work that Sean does is on a contractural basis. Sean has also written corporate communications documents for CA.

Sean does not accept gifts from companies he covers. All hardware products he writes about are purchased with his own funds or are review units covered under formal loan agreements and are returned after the review is complete.

Biography

Sean Portnoy

Sean Portnoy started his tech writing career at ZDNet nearly a decade ago. He then spent several years as an editor at Computer Shopper magazine, most recently serving as online executive editor. He received a B.A. from Brown University and an M.A. from the University of Southern California.

Related Discussions on TechRepublic

Did you know you can take part in these discussions with your ZDNet membership?
37
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

Buon Natale
lossangel 9th Dec
Oggi nel negozio online per acquistare un paio di scarpe MBT, lo stile ?? anche un bene, bianco e ho sentito la scarpa arco suole nave simile, in modo che l'usura nel processo di giorni in piedi e camminare per produrre un
MBT scarpe logo naturale sensazione di instabilit??, stimolare il corpo del proprio meccanismo di regolazione del bilanciamento di mobilitare il corpo per bilanciare i muscoli e le ossa coinvolti nella regolazione, e quindi di esercitare i muscoli del corpo, la colonna vertebrale, le articolazioni e altri aspetti del ruolo. Regalo di Natale dato alla madre di fare meglio.
http://www.sistishoes.org/negozio
0 Votes
+ -
What PR hit?
Mister Spock 24th Oct 2010
Most people do not understand, or know. I am sure those that do understand that the networks are a for profit business, and that companies like Google are interested only in using someone else's property for their own profit.
plain
@Mister Spock
So are the networks paying you to make up lies? Google is not using someone elses "property" for anything. They have made a browser - just like microsoft makes a browser, just like apple makes a browser.
And as google says, the networks are free to block it. If the networks wants to try and stay in the past century they can try that - for what little time they will then have left to function.
Or they could come into the future and start making money again.
0 Votes
+ -
Google TV is NOT A BROWSER
wackoae 24th Oct 2010
@Everq Google is charging a licensing fee to use their product and using their logo. That means they are making money out of other people's product.
0 Votes
+ -
never have I lied.
"so they have no interest in allowing easy ways for viewers to circumvent those commercials."

And where does Google aquire it's broadcasts for Google TV?
That is correct, from the television companies. Does Google pay to bring that content to a television, when bypassing the current model? They do not, nor do they wish to.

You talk as though streaming content is the future that all want, but I have seen a very small minority interested in that, the majority watching television the current way.

If that is the case, it would be logical for Google to start it's own online network, and bid on the shows as do the networks, if they feel confident that this is the future that the majority wish to embrace.
plain
@Everq
MBT shoes

Mbt shoes

reebok zigtech

cheap moncler jackets
[URL=http://hotantishoes.com]MBT shoes[/URL]
[URL=http://www.mbtshoeson-sale.com]MBT shoes Kisumu sandle[/URL]
0 Votes
+ -
Not correct....
linux for me 25th Oct 2010
@Mister Spock
If you bought a TV and were "blocked" by the networks from watching those channels, you would be screaming. Google's application is nothing more than a variation of a TV set, displaying the same info as over the air broadcasts, which are already paid for by advertisers.

There is nothing here that consists of using anybody else's property. Your hatred for all things Google is obvious. Time to grow up.
0 Votes
+ -
Buon Natale
lossangel 9th Dec
Oggi nel negozio online per acquistare un paio di scarpe MBT, lo stile ?? anche un bene, bianco e ho sentito la scarpa arco suole nave simile, in modo che l'usura nel processo di giorni in piedi e camminare per produrre un
MBT scarpe logo naturale sensazione di instabilit??, stimolare il corpo del proprio meccanismo di regolazione del bilanciamento di mobilitare il corpo per bilanciare i muscoli e le ossa coinvolti nella regolazione, e quindi di esercitare i muscoli del corpo, la colonna vertebrale, le articolazioni e altri aspetti del ruolo. Regalo di Natale dato alla madre di fare meglio.
http://www.sistishoes.org/negozio
Don't forget to mention that users can change their user-agent setting in the browser and bypass these blocks. What would be nice is if GTV already had a firefox app, which would allow the user to leave it customized to omit any mention of the GTV origin, and thus let the user view normal web content via firefox, and GTV-optimized content via an untweaked chrome.
0 Votes
+ -
It's a little damning of your product
matthew_maurice 24th Oct 2010
@Wayniac42 If you have to disguise the way it "looks" to get full functionality.
0 Votes
+ -
No, it is damning of the competition
NonZealot Updated - 24th Oct 2010
@matthew_maurice
If you have to disguise your product to a 3rd party so it doesn't look like it is competing with a product being sold by one of the directors of the owner of the 3rd party. Why should Google TV have to pretend to be anything different just because it is competing with Apple TV?

Apple is being anti-competitive by trying to cut off the oxygen supply of Google TV. That isn't allowed. I truly hope the DoJ AND Disney shareholders demand an investigation. Both consumers of Google TV and Disney's shareholders are being harmed by Steve Jobs here.
@Wayniac42 That doesn't work. They don't check the user-agent, they get Flash to report what operating system it is running on.
0 Votes
+ -
Google blocks web access too
guihombre 24th Oct 2010
Well Google does block access to its services on it's own terms, so this is a negotiation process not a right-wrong process.
0 Votes
+ -
Disney, which owns ABC, and NBC are also unhappy with how Google

And Steve Jobs is trying again and again and again with Apple TV to compete against Google. There is no better way to kill Google TV than to remove Google TV's access to TV shows.

Disney shareholders should demand an investigation into Steve Jobs for a breach of his fiduciary duties. It is clear that Steve is putting Apple's needs ahead of Disney shareholders' needs. Also, the DoJ must investigate to uncover Jobs' blatant anti-competitive practices.
0 Votes
+ -
Jobs is a master at playing dirty
OS Reload 24th Oct 2010
@NonZealot

The recently announced Mac OS X Lion new features are an Ubuntu Rip-Off.

http://www.muktware.com/blog/45/290/23/2010/396

Yes, Apple is ripping-off Canonical's innovations and when Lion launches Jobs will be claiming them as his. Just wait and see.
0 Votes
+ -
Really?
Michael Alan Goff 24th Oct 2010
People are claiming that Canonical created multitouch gestures? An app store? I can't debate the other two, but the writer of the article is a joke with HALF OF THEM.
@OS Reload
You make it sound like this is something new for Job to have done.. Dont forget he stole the GUI and the mouse from xerox
@NonZealot How about we demand that you back up your blatant anti Apple/Jobs claims with some proof.
0 Votes
+ -
NBC not blocked
jpfieber 24th Oct 2010
Actually, NBC seems to be working fine, so it's just ABC and CBS.
0 Votes
+ -
And in other news NonZealot blames Hurricane RICHARD on Steve Jobs.
0 Votes
+ -
@CowLauncher
So you think it is totally fine that a web server refuse to provide content over an HTTP connection because the owners of the web site don't approve of the OS that you are using?

Are you SURE you want to say that you are okay with this?

And yes, the connection to Steve Jobs in this case is far stronger than many of the times that Bill Gates was blamed for something that had nothing at all to do with MS. Jobs is a director of the company that owns these TV companies. Jobs is competing directly against Google in general and Google TV specifically. That is a very strong connection to Steve Jobs.
@NonZealot I think it is complicated and has to do with lots and lots of money. Google has a revenue stream that is not attached directly to other peoples content but relies on it to make money. Google must pay for this right in the eyes of the content owner. For Google it's all unicorns and rainbows in its free and open fairyland but the reality is nothing is free. Google can't compete in TV land unless content is free, which we know is not. It is astounding that they thought otherwise. Someone once said there was no go to market strategy for 3rd internet broadcast TV that is obvious.
0 Votes
+ -
Terrible argument
NonZealot 25th Oct 2010
Google has a revenue stream that is not attached directly to other peoples content but relies on it to make money. Google must pay for this right in the eyes of the content owner.

The exact same argument could be made for any and all web content. If MS paid the New York Times to add code to its web servers that stopped providing news to any OS other than Windows, you would be FREAKING out.

As for Google having to pay for this right, you have the model all wrong. It is all based on advertising and unless Google is somehow pulling out the ads that are built into the stream, Google is doing nothing wrong. If the TV companies can't make money by streaming TV shows to browser, that is the problem of the TV companies. It isn't the problem of Google, Mozilla, Opera, Apple, or MS. Stop streaming TV shows if you can't make money.

I'll ask you again:
So you think it is totally fine that a web server refuse to provide content over an HTTP connection because the owners of the web site don't approve of the OS that you are using?

Yes or no. Simple question. Simple answer.
@NonZealot A very strong connection in now way backs up your claims no matter how many times you post them.
@NonZealot The exact same argument could be made for any and all web content. If MS paid the New York Times to add code to its web servers that stopped providing news to any OS other than Windows, you would be FREAKING out.

This argument has no basis here, your talking about one company paying another to block all their competitors but have no proof that this is the case here.
0 Votes
+ -
...you would all be dancing with glee. Remember...Google IS Evil.
To be honest, I have gotten to where I won't watch network TV all that much. When ABC had Flash Forward on, then took a break, then it came on for only a couple of weeks to be cancelled again, it left a bad taste in my mouth for all of the networks and I refuse to pay for cable.
0 Votes
+ -
Create Your Own GoogleTV Box
lamarwatts@... Updated - 25th Oct 2010
I went out and bought a GoogleTV box last week and had it for 3 days, that's when I figured out that this was nothing more than a CPU with a browser, so I took a CPU that I had and downloaded Firefox and installed WinTV USB Card (cost $79.99) and then bought a wireless key board and mouse (cost $54.99) connected the CPU to my wireless home network and viola I have GoogleTV my way, nothing is blocked and I can watch Live TV while surfing the web, GoogleTV only works with a set top box which is cable or satellite service, I canceled my cable because I was not watching it but paying for it, I only kept my high speed internet (cost $59.00 monthly) ok I have saved $165.01 by creating my own GoogleTV box and I now have a hard drive to download content and a DVR and Camera built in my WinTV USB card.
Many people who read this site don't know that the BIG MAJOR TV SHOWS are also broadcast into other countries.... AND from those other countries is where the links often come to see full tv shows. YES the content might be a few days old but still the content is still relatively new. HBO Movies can be seen through many ASIAN PIRATED streams. The only thing is if you do not mind looking at CHINEESE/JAPANEESE LANGUAGE TEXT AT THE SCREEN BOTTOM you can see the entire HBO movies with english sounds all for the price of FREE
GOOGLE = FREE TV STREAMS LISTS and do the search yourself to find all the free & interesting major broadcaster shows....
PS - Some come from LOCAL [usa/canada] TV STATIONS BROADCASTING ON THE INTERNET THEIR FULL DAILY CONTENT.
0 Votes
+ -
Networks don't really understand IT
AllAroundIT 2nd Nov 2010
They should work with Google, not against them. They don't realize that driving traffic to their properties is a good thing, not a bad thing.

Nobody is stealing anything. No different than if I hook a netbook up to the tv (which many do). Pointless really - and stifles innovation.
Well I just got the Google TV from DISH where I work. I haven?t had any issues but I have just been watching my shows right off the TV and then surfing the net. I know that so far since I have had Google TV it has been great and the apps work flawlessly. The features searching my DVR viewing schedule by program title or actor name, etc. It also searches the web, Amazon VOD, Netflix, etc. It can automatically schedule programs and automatically download and queue podcasts and look at YouTube videos full HD screen size and browse the web. I have currently no complaints and I recommend this to everyone.
0 Votes
+ -
hot annti shoes
hotanti 15th Jun
MBT shoes

Mbt shoes

reebok zigtech

cheap moncler jackets
[URL=http://hotantishoes.com]MBT shoes[/URL]
[URL=http://www.mbtshoeson-sale.com]MBT shoes Kisumu sandle[/URL]
0 Votes
+ -
good antishoes
hotanti 15th Jun
thanks for post i will vist aggain
MBT shoes Mbt shoes reebok zigtech cheap moncler jackets[URL=http://hotantishoes.com]MBT shoes[/URL][URL=http://www.mbtshoeson-sale.com]MBT shoes Kisumu sandle[/URL]
0 Votes
+ -
chi flat iron
ghdAustralia 27th Jul
That was interesting.I like your quality that you put into your post.Please do continue with more like this.
0 Votes
+ -
wilson tennis racket
huangml 14th Oct
babolat tennis racket
wilson tennis

racket
ping

g20
titleist 910D2
From the window she could see across the branches towering cliffs on a canoe, canoe since the night is behind, shrouded in silence up She did not entrusted by sister, for her husband to discuss a job She got up early every day to help my sister and her husband prepared to pot the store early I asked how the answer Liuming Hao, Liu Minghao still unyielding, said he began to come forward, then bell rather hard and soft, and even threatened Liuming Hao: Taekwondo engineering balance due you do not want it, rather the company's business after the country you do not want to do it We are not there to live the old, the house does not always pick up a little popularity did not like to go back, so that houses on stilts and wave, live there and more uncomfortable ah I also proposed the second time on the road "just something to eat", she became more determined attitude up, that has eaten do not want to eat
0 Votes
+ -
wilson tennis racket
huangml 14th Oct
babolat tennis racket
wilson tennis

racket
ping

g20
titleist 910D2
She does not dry, she said: what should I accompany you to your point a lot of dishes, eat too wasteful man one of a certain age, would not be so romantic" In making this statement may Youyou, they would not clear what she actually form a state, is said to do I do
0 Votes
+ -
titleist 910d2
linqli 29th Nov
The last one in the corner under the sunset that face is still beautiful, still delicate, pure and innocent, this deliberately to keep her quiet voice is inevitable that some do not match City in South Devon, private cars also have this very little If you become a member of our family, it certainly does not help me less busy and you went to college, but also a man, people are smart, you follow me a good school, a few years will be able to practice it This is not easy man to friends The end of that dream is not ideal, the problem also lies in the documentary too, it is ruthless demonstration of weeks after being on sick, suddenly did not know her desert can we have to say this thing clear, first you wrong, titleist 910d2
titleist 910D3
Ping G20
Taylormade r11
titleist 910d2
titleist 910D3
Ping G20
Taylormade r11
titleist 910d2
titleist 910D3
Ping G20
Taylormade r11
titleist 910d2
titleist 910D3
Ping G20
Taylormade r11
Wilson Tennis Racket
Babolat Tennis Racket
Head Tennis Racket
Prince Tennis Racket
Wilson Blxyou and that girl is you and Ningning's a good hand later Reassuring voice, clear faces in the darkness to see a rare show of maturity, a little dumb that the language of deep and almost like a woman tells a vintage vicissitudes of the past I think this next image I have in her mind, but completely destroyed, she certainly heartbroken, as did Mao Jie for her the kind of mood

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix
Click Here
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix
ie8 fix