RIM launching PlayBook without native email client; Shoots itself in both feet

By | March 29, 2011, 1:21pm PDT

Summary: The BlackBerry PlayBook will launch without a native email application - arguably the key feature to BlackBerry’s success.

I’ve been pretty positive about the BlackBerry tablet up until now. I even defended the entire BlackBerry brand a few days ago even when analysts and journalists were hammering down a fiery reign of molten arse vengeance upon Research in Motion, the enterprise-class smartphone and tablet manufacturer.

But according to an internal Verizon document, the BlackBerry PlayBook could lack a native, core email application at launch, which may well be the final nail in the ever increasingly heavy coffin.

Page 5 has it all, saying:

“In a future software update for the BlackBerry PlayBook, we will also provide native e-mail, calendar, and contact apps for those customers who prefer to have these apps directly on the tablet.”

However, while there may be no respite for those longing for out of the box email functionality, there could well be a good reason why the BlackBerry PlayBook will lack a significant application to the device.

According to CrackBerry:

“The reality of the matter is that RIM simply does not yet have this functionality ready for the new QNX operating system in the way they want to roll it out (and trust that it’s secure), and with the usage case of the tablet being different from that of a smartphone, RIM figured it wasn’t necessary to wait for it to go live in order to get PlayBook sales rolling.”

In short, Research in Motion is pushing the release of the tablet out even though a core product feature may not launch with the device at all. It’s just a shame the decision wasn’t made over a month ago to predate the iPad 2 release, which would have given the tablet a chance to claw at least some of the marketshare.

It seems that the BlackBerry Network Operations Center (NOC), which keeps the email, contacts and calendars ticking over and the enterprise security and reliability features intact, cannot ‘connect’ entirely with the QNX-based operating system that runs on the PlayBook.

Of course, Gmail and Hotmail, and other cloud based email applications will be accessible using the browser which will be in-built into the tablet upon release, but not through a preinstalled application.

That, apparently, will come later.

But granted, the silver lining is that the BlackBerry smartphone and the BlackBerry PlayBook are not the same device, and one would expect the smartphone to be always on and plugged into the email mainframe as it is. The PlayBook is a complimentary device to the smartphone and probably always will be.

It’s as if Research in Motion wants you to use the smartphone more than the tablet.

Nevertheless, this will annoy a great number of prospective consumers of the tablet. But rest assured, though the original iPhone launched without an App Store application, and Windows Phone 7 was let loose in the wild without cut, copy and paste functionality, Research in Motion will bring out the email application after the launch - probably in time for the PlayBook 4G, CrackBerry reckons.

Related content:

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

Zack Whittaker, a criminologist who studied at the University of Kent, Canterbury, is a journalist, writer and broadcaster.

Disclosure

Zack Whittaker

I worked briefly with Microsoft UK in 2006 but no longer have any connection with the company. Regardless, I remain impartial and unbiased in my views.

I don't hold any stock or shares, investments or industrial secrets in any company, but have signed confidentiality agreements with a number of UK and U.S. organisations, whose names I am not at liberty to disclose.

I was involved with Kent Union, the University of Kent's student union, undertaking voluntary, non-salaried, elected positions between early 2009 and mid-2010.

No other company, body, government department, non-governmental organisation or third sector organisation employs me or pays me a salary in any capacity whatsoever.

As a freelance journalist, whenever expenses are given and taken by a company that is not CBS Interactive, these will be disclosed in each relevant post to ensure transparency.

I currently work with a UK law enforcement unit, but this is an entirely separate position which bears no connection to other work.

(Updated: 23rd October 2011)

Biography

Zack Whittaker

Zack Whittaker, criminologist who studied at the University of Kent, UK, is a journalist, writer and broadcaster.

After studying criminology at university, though still in his early-20's, he has already had a series unconventional work and voluntary positions. He has worked with researchers studying neurological illnesses like Tourette's syndrome (which he suffers from), has given lectures on the nature of disabilities in the public community, and occasionally ends up speaking on television and radio discussing the events of the day.

He first had academic work published at the age of 22, then still an undergraduate, and has been cited by a wide range of publications: from the Huffington Post, Business Insider, AllThingsDigital, The Atlantic Wire and CBS News.

Related Discussions on TechRepublic

Did you know you can take part in these discussions with your ZDNet membership?
45
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

Well, everything is about security and get things done
cloudexus 14th Dec
So give RI a time and it will be the best system from corporate to small businesses
Of course governments, media and everyone who is aware about necessity of basic security in today;'s world.
BTW PB and BB is a system, PB is a perfect extensions to BB and is working as a set perfectly, and it has build in hardware encryption. It is a tally different philosophy then Android and Apple stuff. Less flashy, spectacular but it is a real working horse for real businesses.
handheld product and be able (or prefer) to use that for email in the short term. What they should have figured was to concentrate on their efforts on their floundering mobile handheld space to stem the tide of consumers leaving RIM completely. They already have no play here the future of tablets. No matter what they do they are going to see Win8 tablets grab 90%, ipads 8%, android tablets 1.2%, and themselves and hp/webos tablets fighting eachother for that last 0.8%. Get out and focus on coming up with a way to stop your mobile handset share from hitting single digits but because you'll be there shortly if you dont do something. And by something I dont mean giving brutal dictatorships access to your clients emails/txts.
0 Votes
+ -
ROTFLMAO!!!!
i8thecat 29th Mar 2011
@Johnny Vegas

Win8 Tablets??? BwaHaHaHaHaHa!!!! OMG!!! Whew!!!! Dude... That was hysterical.... Win 8 tablets grow 90%... HaHaHaHaHaHa!!! Oh Stop HaHaHaHaHa!!!! My Sides are starting to hurt!!! HaHaHaHaHaHa!!!!
@Johnny Vegas What are we basing this on? Do we have ANY idea what Windows 8 Tablets will be like? (I'd imagine pretty horrible, the needs of desktop/laptops are utterly different to iPad-a-likes... but who knows, maybe Microsoft can square that circle).

And aren't we now talking about a product due 2013?! At what mythical time are you thinking they'll get 90% market share? 2015? 2016? Later?

I'm assuming you don't think Apple, Google et al will just "stand still" - right? You're assuming none of them will have significant new innovation in this space? What's that based on?
0 Votes
+ -
Wait, what?
Pete "athynz" Athens 30th Mar 2011
@Johnny Vegas Win 8 tablets getting 90% of the market? Dude you are on some seriously good ****... got any to spare?
0 Votes
+ -
They do have an email client
nexus120 Updated - 14th Apr 2011
@Johnny Vegas
The PlayBook looks to be an awesome device, and now that they have an email client coming out for it, it's looking even better!!!

A company called Pepper.pk has developed Early Bird, an email client for the PlayBook!

http://pepper.pk/early-bird/
We knew this already!

Essentially QNX (Tablet) isn't finished. Not even close. There is no proper SDK. The Android support is via a VM, a heavy messy proposition at best. The Android support is Gingerbread only, and won't have the Android Marketplace (instead applications can be added via some kind of RIM marketplace). To be clear, the Android compatibility on this thing is a huge stinking pile of suck. Why bother? Well there's no SDK, so no apps. They know they need lots of apps (as a feature checkbox) so this gives them this. They refer to this as the need for "apps tonnage" [sic], a clear "never mind the quality, feel the width" if ever I heard it.

The PlayBook will use a RIM Blackberry smartphone for email.

If ever there was a product that shouldn't be inflicted upon the world this is that product.
@jeremychappell "Android support is via a VM" and that's somehow a bad thing? Whereas on android phones themselves? Do you even know what "Dalvik" is?
Zack Whittaker,

I would like to commend you on your decision to jump on the bandwagon that the majority of "journalists" have jumped on. Your weightless facts are impeccable.

If there is one thing that's true, it's that Apple's marketing scheme has definitely worked on journalists. They do nothing but repeat the same garbage over and over.

Until you use the Playbook, please, stop regurgitating what Steve Jobs has told you.

Ps-I even own a MacBook, but I am still over the fact that this is continually repeated. It's annoying and it's not based on anything. RIM isn't going anywhere and it's been reported time and time again that they are picking up in the consumer market, particularly young people.
@WhateverAZ
You are dreaming. PlayBook running Android under VM and supporting Flash is a guarantee for poor battery life, maybe 4 hours. That sucks even more than the lack of email client...

The OS they are using was designed to run in cars where battery life is not an issue. In contrast, iOS was designed specifically for superior battery life...
@prof123 ....
you are making the same negative assumption that because flash is present on a device its going to be used 100% of the time.
@prof123 You are misinformed. First, Android devices themselves run Android apps in a VM on a Unix environment. So I don't see how a VM on QNX would be much different. It should run similar to an Android device, but inefficient compared to a natively designed QNX application.

As for Flash & battery life---Flash (AIR) support runs as a server that plugs directly into the QNX kernel, whereas on iOS it would pass through 3 abstraction layers. The issue isn't that Flash is CPU intensive, it's with the approach iOS takes to support flash. If Apple really wanted to, they could've made very good use of Flash products by building it from the ground-up with this support instead of making it an afterthought.

Second, QNX operating system was not designed 'for cars', while it is used in pretty much every car manufacturer for their telematics (i.e. deploying airbags, ABS brakes, etc.) systems, and infotainment (GPS, satellite radio, etc.) systems, the QNX microkernel (not a hybrid or monolithic kernel) was designed for efficency and stability, and used in a huge number of places other than cars (assembly lines, nasa space shuttles, unmanned military aircrafts, casino gambling machines, etc.)

The QNX neutrino microkernel is only 100,000 lines of code and supports any number of processors. Whereas WinCE (hybrid kernel) is 3,900,000 lines of code and iOS's XNU (hybrid kernel) is 9,000,000 lines of code. Quite inefficent in comparison.
0 Votes
+ -
a gamble
DarthCyclist 29th Mar 2011
I suppose they are gambling here. How much damage could it do versus how much extra profit could they make by releasing early. If they have a good app service then maybe someone else will create programs good enough that there future native versions won't be needed anyway.
@DarthCyclist
That would work a year ago, before the iPad came along...
@prof123 I agree. Having a good app service now is getting in kind of late in the game. Going up against the iOS app store and the Android app store, not too mention the new Amazon app market place is going to be a losing battle.

RIM needs to pull a rabbit out of their hat to come out of this year alive, though I can't stand BB devices so I hope they crash and burn in a magnificent fiery blaze.
The Playbook doesn't "need" apps, it'll get over a millon just by fully supporting Adobe Flash and AIR. Something iPad users will never get...
Native email support is only a matter of time, if anything RIM is just making sure they take their time with stuff that really matters: security and reliability.
@SinfoCOMAR So not the SDK, not email (why do people by RIM devices? "Email")...

This is a product rushed to market, it won't look good and will probably ruin its reputation forever. Better to get the product actually finished rather than "rush" to get their "iPad-killer" (some hope in this state) to market.

Compare this with HP's iPad response.
@jeremychappell
Don't know about others, I buy RIM devices/services because:
*They work as advertised.
*They are reliable and secure.
*I'm not obligated to use the apps approved by the manufacturer (no need to jailbreaks).
*They are built with suitability to task in mind: I still can't believe Apple left Flash out on purpose. I'd buy a tablet mainly for browsing on the go with a bigger screen than that on my cellphone. The Ipads just don't cut it because they don't support the technologies that make web browsing great. Any way, just my opinion. Cheers!
@SinfoCOMAR You know there is no Android Marketplace don't you? RIM have their own proprietary version for Android apps on the PlayBook - so it fails: "*I'm not obligated to use the apps approved by the manufacturer (no need to jailbreaks)." anyway.

I can't really see the VM being totally reliable, given how rushed the whole thing is... Maybe you'll be more willing to give them the benefit of the doubt.

We also know that the performance of the VM is going to leave a lot to be desired (this is a resource limited system, and we all know that VMs work far better with more RAM).

Flash support has it's own downsides. Security is a big one. If you have a Flash player then the attack foot print is far larger. Look at how Google's desktop browser goes to great lengths to isolate Flash (for this very reason). On something as resource strapped as a iPad-like Tablet such isolation is too much of a resource hog (before you even think about Flash itself). Apple have worked very hard to reduce the attack footprint of iOS, so it doesn't need AntiVirus. Google have taken the approach of "OK, let people make AntiVirus software". But again, is this the best choice of a system with such limited resources?

On iOS devices you really don't miss Flash that much - mostly because content creators have added code to their sites that deliver alternative content when they encounter iOS. Sure, this might seem rather backwards, but as an end user does it really matter?

As someone who has created Flash content, I can tell you, Flash does indeed represent a "blank cheque", and you can burn through a lot of processor time (battery on a mobile device) and bandwidth (data, which again is limited on mobile devices with fixed data plans).

I think Flash is to the iPad as a Floppy Disk was to the iMac; We'll get over it.
@jeremychappell To be fair, iPhone did not have an SDK until over a year after launch, and a lot of core services were not available at launch either. Even the app store was not available for a long time while Palm and RIM had app stores available. And look at the remarkable success of the iPhone still---it was successful without apps and third party development because it was simply a superior user experience compared to anything else at the time.

Also to repeat something I posted earlier. (in response to your comment at the bottom of this thread) As for android software running on a VM on the Playbook---Android software also runs on a VM on android devices. (it's actually a unix environment). In theory, time will tell for sure---android software should run quite similar to on actual android devices, but not even close to as efficient as software developed for any of QNX's native languages which do not have to go through that extra layer.
@jeremychappell You keep responding to all these blog posts about the Playbook citing the same misinformation over and over again. There is nothing wrong with being 'for' or 'against' any product, everyone is entitled to their opinion---but if you have arguments to make for others to read (for or against), PLEASE make sure your points are accurate, otherwise you will continue to lose credibility by spreading misinformation.
But they run android app isn't it? Therefore plenty of android email client?
what a load this article is.
0 Votes
+ -
Canadians don't get it....
i8thecat 30th Mar 2011
@mpgme

Rim is proof of the fact the Canadians don't get it... But even Canadian customer are scratching their heads and saying, "What the fook is that aboot?"... Eh.
@mpgme And RIM has guaranteed that we will not get email with the Playbook right out of the box...
"But granted, the silver lining is that the BlackBerry smartphone and the BlackBerry PlayBook are not the same device, and one would expect the smartphone to be always on and plugged into the email mainframe as it is. The PlayBook is a complimentary device to the smartphone and probably always will be"

-It's complement. Not compliment.

Also, is it really that hard to have a bookmark to gmail.com? I don't use an email client.
@hoaxoner What if you don't use gmail as your primary email? (And this is RIM - that guts their primary market).
@jeremychappell gmail is able to link to multiple email accounts / exchange servers. even non-gmail accounts can be read from their web accessed gmail client.
0 Votes
+ -
Compromise
MobileAdmin 30th Mar 2011
Consumers are not the primary market for Playbook. RIM's focus are their enterprise deployments who already have large Blackberry rollouts. There are security benefits for the Blackberry Bridge for companies:

- Do not need to worry about securing the Playbook as another data destination. All corporate data is on the Blackberry.

- This also allows the Playbook to be shared among users as no sensitive data is stored on the device. This is a impossible with iPad as you need to switch the iTunes accounts when dealing with multiple users.

RIM is working on intergrating Playbook with BES/NOC but that is likely a tall order to complete along with a whole new OS. People seem to think they can slap on some native client and all the Blackberry security just works. I'm unsure native email will be POP/IMAP/Exchange ActiveSync based. It would be nice to provide that option but would do nothing to drive RIM's other services. It's like Apple selling an iPod that doesn't use iTunes.

RIM as well 3rd party apps will address this gap. Shame it won't be there day 1 but Bridge will full the gap and has its own benefits for corporate users (who already have a Blackberry).

Consumers / other smartphone users will need to decide if web based email works for them. They still have their smartphone which to me is the primary email device. Is there that big of market that only wants a tablet and nothing else??
@MobileAdmin
E-Mail on my Blackberry sucks.

RIM- How hard can it be to port standard Blackberry OS App's to QNX, you were going on about how easy it was to port stuff the other day, or was that all bollocks. Unless the Playbook has the full default Blackkberry App set, it will be a nightmare to administer via BES.
@neilpost

How so? I've used all the devices on the market and for the heavy email users it's still the best IMO. I can plow through 100 emails much quicker. Sync all the changes (wirelessly) back to my mailbox (read status, flag, file, reconcile). RIM has the deepest Exchange intergration on the market.

Now I guess the UI might not appear as nice and looks basic but I'll take function over visual every day.

Blackberry Bridge is a solid option as they did not have the BES intergration at the same level as Blackberry OS. Once you extend all the corporate data they would need to match all the policy and security corporate have used the past 10 years. If they can get that soon for Playbook it will be killer as nothing on the market would match that from an enterprise perspective.
0 Votes
+ -
Joe consumer
RealGem 30th Mar 2011
Joe consumer might not care if the native email app comes bundled. But the corporate user, whose BB is synched up via BES to corporate email might. If the Playbook can't access corporate email, but the BB can, then you can't replace the BB yet.
@RealGem Playbook accesses corporate mail via Blackberry Bridge.
Wow, imagine that. Somebody wants a POP client on a tablet and whines there isn't one. Will wonders never cease?
0 Votes
+ -
no problem
m3kw9 30th Mar 2011
Should be ok, RIM is pretty much near rock bottom anyways with or without this. hehe
What is the news here Zack? This was known for a while now. Your article leads you and other miss-informed analysts and impulse buyers thinking something really bad was just announced and therefore must trash BB and jump on or support other devices .

Sorry man, you need to do better job. I'm not hear to support or trash blackberry. I have criticized their miss-aligned strategy a while back and I'm growing frustrated of their latest unreliable devices being rushed to market because they have to catch up to the competition. Nevertheless I wont just publish such shameful articles just because I can.
0 Votes
+ -
Ha ha. It's not even the 1st of April yet.

Blackberry is known for Push E-Mail. It's what everyone will expect of the PlayBook and to not have it at launch is suicide. I certainly wouldn't buy any tablet without e-mail/contacts/calendar apps.

Webmail just doesn't cut it. It's fine for holiday, away from home, internet cafe etc... use but it doesn't and never will replaced a dedicated e-mail app.
@bradavon

For users that have a Blackberry they will have push email via Blackberry Bridge. I don't see why people don't grasp this.

A native email client is coming and will likely be included on the LTE/WiMAX/HSPA+ models coming in the summer.
Forget the specs of each of these Tablet devices for a moment and have a look at what is happening in the business world with Tablets.

Corporate Management are taking to Tablets like ducks to water, as they basically provide most of the functionally they require when working out of the office. And the device management are asking for? The iPad.

If this article is correct and Blackberry are not including a native email client, that is utter madness. Corporates will not even take a second look. And secondly, the biggest problem of all, it's name. Calling the device the Playbook is also just not going to work in Corporate land.

Blackberry I think have really lost their way with this device, and yes it may sell well in the domestic market, but I think they can forget anything else.
@tbrowne@...
They'll be in the bargain bin in Best Buy soon.
since no one has acutually ussed the playbook in a consumer enviroment maybe we should wait until people like me the consumer use it and decide if it worth the money. with every oher tab and tablet being around 200$cdn to 400$cdn the playbook will be blackberry users like me who have always used one and passed on the steve jobs love-in i will buy and use the playbook email or no email just let me get my work done.
0 Votes
+ -
EMAIL CLIENT FOR PLAYBOOK
nexus120 Updated - 14th Apr 2011
The PlayBook looks to be an awesome device, and now that there is an email client coming out for it, it's looking even better!!!

A company called Pepper.pk has developed Early Bird, an email client for the PlayBook!

http://pepper.pk/early-bird/
Hey guys get over it...the "Early Bird Email App is out there, and "$ to donuts",it will be in the Blackberry App store, more over in a couple of Months, Inhouse Email will be in place, which means when Playbook hits the european and central asian market everything will be in place even 3G and 4G...pull your heads out,the Playbook has good solid bones, in the form of QNX, and at least RIMM is looking at the future, in looking at a whole new OS for their Playbook, and smartphones..
0 Votes
+ -
good idea about android
gavin.chan 20th Sep
A good post. Thanks for sharing.Hi, do you own a tablet pc? We supply kinds of tablet computers, including windows 7 tablet pc and windows 7 tablets. Buy 9.7 inch tablet pc from China at wholesale price.
Zcj12
So give RI a time and it will be the best system from corporate to small businesses
Of course governments, media and everyone who is aware about necessity of basic security in today;'s world.
BTW PB and BB is a system, PB is a perfect extensions to BB and is working as a set perfectly, and it has build in hardware encryption. It is a tally different philosophy then Android and Apple stuff. Less flashy, spectacular but it is a real working horse for real businesses.

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix