Smartphones bring families together? Doubtful

Smartphones bring families together? Doubtful

Summary: A recent survey on American women suggested that mobile devices bring families closer together. You missed the point.

SHARE:

You're perched on your bed, absorbed in Facebook, wasting time looking at the latest 'meme' image floating around the web, or researching for a latest post.

Suddenly, a shriek powerful enough to shatter the delicate bones in your ears reverberates from downstairs. You are being called again to answer the phone. Without realizing it, you've ignored the last four summons.

Shifting from one technological device to the next, you suffer later for then missing the call for dinner.

Tablets and smartphones, in a latest survey, were concluded to bring families closer. Not glue children to the latest app they've downloaded, or keep parents in a constant state of checking their work email while helping the kids out with their homework.

A recent survey conducted by CTIA -- the Wireless Association -- collated data on over 1000 U.S women and how they use wireless devices.

85% said that mobile devices help families feel closer, and 45% said that it helps families spend more time together, through schedule organisation.

Robert Mesirow, vice president of CTIA, said in a statement:"It’s undeniable that wireless devices have changed the way we live and work. As our survey has proven, mobile technology is also changing the way families interact and improving the quality of time they’re spending with each other."

Quality of time? I can't say I agree. If anything, mobile devices simply add yet another distraction that takes away interaction in the present with those around you. Is it quality time when you are pulled away from a game with your child to take a work call, or spend time checking Facebook instead of communicating with your partner?

Mobile devices like smartphones and tablets have caused a shift in how we live and work, and that is almost undeniable. Children use iPads in schools, smartphones give us immediate access to data and contacts, work can reach us at any hour.

It no doubt has its uses, and in points of safety and emergencies I agree. Knowing you can contact your loved ones instantly if something goes wrong can be an emotional safety net for family members.

But the survey missed the point.

There's a difference between having information concerning the activities and status of someone, and having quality communication with them.

I'd suggest that mobile devices make families feel more informed about their families, and make scheduling time shared together easier based on this information. However, 'closer', to me, is the wrong phrase to use. 'Closer' suggests that it improves individual relationships, and with Facebook being mentioned in many a recent divorce, can the two sides truly correlate?

It may make families feel closer, but perhaps it has affected the way they communicate on the whole. Knowing things about people around you may make you feel more connected with them, but if the trade-off is a distracting environment and less quality time spent with them physically present, what one believes to be true may not be the case.

(Image Source: Andrew Malone/Flickr)

Related:

Topics: Smartphones, Hardware, Mobility

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

2 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • RE: Smartphones bring families together? Doubtful

    Yes, and what if the game you're playing with your child just happens to be on that smartphone? I know I play a lot more games and interact with her in general now that we both have smartphones. Likewise with my parents. I find it amusing trying to help my dad cheat at Words with Friends because my sister is just a little too good. Know what we would be doing without them? Nothing. Not even a phone call. Families have been becoming dysfunctional way before tech became an issue (and I use that term lightly, my family would be considered dysfunctional and I wouldn't have it any other way). If anything, it helps us reconnect.

    Hell, one of the top reasons people use Facebook is to keep in touch with relatives or old friends.

    Gotta look at the whole picture.
    Aerowind
    • They're just a new tool to use, not something that actually improves

      @Aerowind <br><br>the situation.<br><br>Psst... I have this great invention that lets me keep in touch with a) my parents just a few miles down the road, b) my in-laws that live 1-1.5 hours away, and c) my sister who lives 5 states over (~ 1000 miles away). It's called... the telephone. Not a smartphone, an actual phone.
      spdragoo@...