Video walkthrough of Windows 8 for tablets: Already a tough selling point for tepid Gen Y tablet prospectives

By | June 1, 2011, 4:57pm PDT

Summary: A video demonstration of Windows 8 in action. Could this really rival an iPad, and why should I ‘go tablet’ when I can ‘go netbook’?

Well, this is it. Windows 8 in “tablet mode”, as demonstrated at the D9 conference.

The operating system will split in two, as two versions of Windows in the same product: one for the desktop, and one for the tablet.

It will function as a fully-fledged desktop operating system, slimmed down for performance steady tablet hardware, but will have a tiled Windows Phone 7 style interface to support the mobile user.

But I suspect the concept of ‘Windows on a tablet’ will be immensely difficult task to sell to the younger generation.

It’s the tablet part which holds the crux of the problem.

The Generation Y, on the most part, do not seem to have taken to the tablet revolution. I cannot understand why, though perhaps it is for the same reason that I myself do not want a tablet. I feel no emotion towards the gadget: no empathy, no feeling of ’sexiness’; just a benign cramp in my stomach.

It’s a luxury item, and I simply have little space for it.

As of yet, the tablet market is yet to fully explode. The iPad has the market dominance over competitors, without doubt.

Yet I would argue the vast majority of the younger Generation Y that own an iPad are doing so because they are impressionable to the gods of Apple, and are buying the tablet through sheer support of the company rather than the need for an extra peripheral.

Hand a younger user a block of cheddar with an Apple logo on it, brand it ‘iCheese’ and they’ll empty their wallets out without thinking twice. The Generation Y are innately spendthrifty when it comes down to technology.

Maybe Apple has the balance just right. Like the Goldilocks of the technology world, by separating out the desktop Mac OS X to the iPad iOS operating systems, it can provide a two-pronged approach to a lucrative business model of a ‘just right’ temperature. Apple gets the big bucks, and the consumer knows little different.

It’s clever, I’ll hand them that.

For now, though I do see the appeal in a fully-functional desktop operating system on a tablet device, offered by Windows 8 yet not by Apple’s iPad, the younger generation still needs the hook to draw them in.

The technology is there. The hardware, the compact processors, the battery life. The one thing that lacks, for which the busy student will require over anything else, is a keyboard.

Why the tablet? Why is the tablet so great? It’s great for X, Y and Z, but it is not directly compatible with the students’ A, B and C.

It is as simple as that. The student market may be tempted by the handiness and the splendour of a Windows tablet, but disdained by the lacking of a simple, overlooked appendage.

One simple question has yet to be answered. Why a tablet, over a netbook or a laptop? Tablets may be on the rise, but the PC isn’t dead. Windows 8 will prove that; I’d bet money on it.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

Zack Whittaker, a criminologist who studied at the University of Kent, Canterbury, is a journalist, writer and broadcaster.

Disclosure

Zack Whittaker

I worked briefly with Microsoft UK in 2006 but no longer have any connection with the company. Regardless, I remain impartial and unbiased in my views.

I don't hold any stock or shares, investments or industrial secrets in any company, but have signed confidentiality agreements with a number of UK and U.S. organisations, whose names I am not at liberty to disclose.

I was involved with Kent Union, the University of Kent's student union, undertaking voluntary, non-salaried, elected positions between early 2009 and mid-2010.

No other company, body, government department, non-governmental organisation or third sector organisation employs me or pays me a salary in any capacity whatsoever.

As a freelance journalist, whenever expenses are given and taken by a company that is not CBS Interactive, these will be disclosed in each relevant post to ensure transparency.

I currently work with a UK law enforcement unit, but this is an entirely separate position which bears no connection to other work.

(Updated: 23rd October 2011)

Biography

Zack Whittaker

Zack Whittaker, criminologist who studied at the University of Kent, UK, is a journalist, writer and broadcaster.

After studying criminology at university, though still in his early-20's, he has already had a series unconventional work and voluntary positions. He has worked with researchers studying neurological illnesses like Tourette's syndrome (which he suffers from), has given lectures on the nature of disabilities in the public community, and occasionally ends up speaking on television and radio discussing the events of the day.

He first had academic work published at the age of 22, then still an undergraduate, and has been cited by a wide range of publications: from the Huffington Post, Business Insider, AllThingsDigital, The Atlantic Wire and CBS News.

34
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

RE: Video walkthrough of Windows 8 for tablets: Already a tough selling point
preciolandia 22nd Sep
I don't think Microsoft Tablets can compete with Apple's Ipads . They are too late into the game. That's why innovation ends up winning the game, always.
What's your point..? If "Generation Y" doesn't want a tablet, they will purchase a desktop or laptop, which will run Windows, so like Microsoft cares.
@ian.aldrighetti That's exactly my point. Thanks for the comment!
@zwhittaker . Zack, you forgot to include the "Y Generation" part at the end of the title of your article. You r right, it would be a tough sell for the Y generation as far as tablets go. (ipads are much more hip, fashionable) As we can see though that MS is solidifying its ecosystem, (aiming to being there everywhere in our lives). They want future windows users to start in the y generation thru netbooks and laptops (student age, which pcs and laptops still work best, purchased by parents and used in schools).. Once the users grow older, they will be much more accustomed to win environment w/ metro UI, less likely to adapt another OS (a solid ecosystem will ensure this)... when users get to my age and realize being cool isn't as important...., by then they probably have a pc laptop already, work with pcs at work, have a desktop at home , but one device they have yet to buy ( a luxury consumption item) is the tablet, we'll let us see should we get a WIN tablet or an apple or android which we will have to invest from the beginning. .....and learn a new way of doing things. We are less likely to change as we get older. For example, my wife does not like using Mac just for the fact that it is not familiar to her and she refuses to learn the Mac environment from scratch, which she sees as a waste of time to do. I think millions of people are in the same boat as my wife, and that is what MS is counting on too.
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
Thanks
zwhittaker 2nd Jun
@logic103 Hi. I went by the assumption (as I often do) that people come to this column to read from a Gen Y perspective. But, nevertheless, I amended the title per your suggestion. Hopefully now it will be made clear that Generation Y members react in a 'tepid' way towards tablets -- bar the iPad, for the "it's an Apple product" reason. happy
@ian.aldrighetti

Actually, Gen Y is more likely to purchase a Mac than a Windows box, which MS doesn't like. And MS's declining market share (albeit small) is proof people of all ages are starting not to like their products.
@itguy08 - The reason some people buy into Mac is because they are frustrated with PC problems not realising that they are the problem and then they buy a Mac and within time they realise it's not what they wanted. I khave a few friends who went that route and bought an expensive Mac only later to back to Windows. Lookt at what happened recently to Mac users falling for the Mac Malware issue, a knowledgeable user would not have fallen for it but you average user will because they did the same with a windows PC, it is not about liking or disliking its all about having lacking the skills on the function of the PC and the internet and not visiting or doing things you shouldn't, just like how you live your life, its no different.
This is what the world has been waiting for from Microsoft. It's funny because event though Apple and Android are dominating the Market right now, they are only doing it in the Vacuum of Microsoft's presence.

I'm pretty sure that when this comes out it will be BIG.
0 Votes
+ -
@darkriderdesign Sorry to kill your excitement, but looking at the base products that is driving the UI changes, I don't see how you can claim that this is what people are waiting for.

The UI was originally used in the Kin ... total failure.
This is the WP7 UI on a desktop ... and WP7 is NOT SELLING. It is being over 6 months and it hasn't sold hit 1M (in official sales).

If UI is not selling on small screens, why would anybody think that it will be "big" on a bigger screen. If anything, it will probably be the main reason people will not upgrade and actually start looking at other choices.
@wackoae Think this through before you post...

This isn't Windows Phone, this is Windows 8! People who look at this will say, Oh, it is running Windows, that's cool... of course you Apple fans might not but others will.

This OS already has iOS and Android bet in the volume of information right at your finger tips and it also has them beat at multitasking on a touch screen...
@wackoae

You still here?

My WP7 phone is working well and the UI is just so much better than last century's crowded desktop of static icons.

Starting to get worried, aren't you wacker.
0 Votes
+ -
@Peter Perry, @tonymcs@...

Somebody states THE TRUTH but your limited fanboys brains are unable to comprehend simple facts.

Hey, but I guess according to their brains I'm an Apple fanboy .... that works on Windows, Linux, Solaris, Irix and OS X. Guess my "limited" experience is too much for your brain to handle.
@wackoae windows on big screen will always be big, no matter what. it's the market share they have.. and no competition. Macs are expensive and Ubuntu etc just plain confusing. after win8, people will be.. oh apparently they have win phone as well.. let me try. wp7 is amazing, you just need to try.. i can see how win8 will pull demand for wp7
@wackoae WTF are you talking about?

I have an Android Phone, Android Tablet, Windows Desktop and Apple Laptop! How does this make me a fanboy?

I guess like you said, I stated the truth and you couldn't handle it...

Now if I were on here saying that iOS was the best thing ever, you would not dream of calling me a fanboy... I guess that just shows your true colors huh?
@wackoae "The UI was originally used in the Kin ... total failure."

The KIN didn't fail because of UI problems. The UI was actually pretty nice and functional. It was directed to a young market and clearly overpriced. Didn't have a complete feature set to justify the price. It appears this is another Windows 95 Revolutionary jump for Microsoft. This is the WOW moment Microsoft has been trying to generate. Windows Phone 7 ?Mango? and Windows 8 is a helluva one two punch.
@darkriderdesign People who look at this will say, Oh, it is running Windows, that's cool..

Like those netbooks running Windows that took a 40% hit because of the iPad? Like how running Windows of some type saved UMPCs? Like how WinCE kept Microsoft relevant in mobile?
@wackoae I finally got my HTC Trophy WP7 from Verizon Wireless. Now that Verizon has WP7, the sales should increase pretty readily. The UI is awesome, slick, fast, and useful. There are some changes from what I'm used to, but I like this UI a lot.
@darkriderdesign

10 years or so?
the BIG thing is that the iPad came in at less than half the cost and worked well if you'd already bought into the Apple ecosystem.
and Android works well if you're willing to buy into the Google ecosystem.
people buy into the Microsoft ecosystem because business and government force them to.

i personally hope the field remains wide open so smaller vendors may thrive in the in-between spots.

happy
.
If somebody (Microsoft, chemists, processor designers) can give us 8 hours for this system, in a lightweight design, then it will be a super success
@Roque Mocan ... it will be a miracle if it got 4 hrs of usage.
@wackoae It will match the battery life of competing products.
@wackoae

Gee my 1 yr old Acer convertible tablet/netbook running Win 7 gets 8 hours.

So I don't think it's a problem
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
Batter life
zwhittaker 2nd Jun
@Roque Mocan I think you're right. But it has to equally rival or be better than the battery life of a netbook. Having said that, it should be if they use lower-power ARM processors.
0 Votes
+ -
Best of Both Worlds
jpr75_z 1st Jun
You will have the tablet/WP7 UI of Metro, along with the "traditional" UI of Windows 7 - and you can run them side by side! I think this will be a re-thinking of Windows for many people, but has a lot of promise. Could be a real shock though in the corporate world - where many companies are stuck in an XP time warp circa 2001 and are way behind in Windows UIs.
This is a good step in the right direction seeing the tiles explained makes a lot more sense to me than just using icons.
Zack .. I truly wish your input on this because your viewpoints expressed in your blog took me completely by surprise.

I just saw the Win 8 tablet preview video and was incredibly impressed. If released today, I would say it would become the ideal tablet form.

I'm not being facetious. This Win 8 tablet concept has enough potential to dominate the market place. (Apple ecosystem and all.)

But here comes the question. Are you sure about your generalization that tablets are a "non factor" for your age bracket? Or that students or members of your generation, who own tablets (or iPads in particular) do so out of a "targeted marketing campaign designed to stimulate a need to belong to something else .. whatever that might be .. rather than for a genuine desire to satisfy an informational or creative want or need which an iPad (or tablets in general) provide?

(Personally, I can't support your opinion that your generation's iPad usage is a direct result of a marketing "brainwash" operation targeting your age group although I acknowledge some marketing campaigns in the past had similar objectives. For example, Camel cigarettes used "Joe the Camel" to target the sub 18 year old demographic .. at least that was the consensus opinion of the time.) That viewpoint is simply too "alien" to me.

And yet, you more or less are stating that an ideal Win 8 tablet would be just as much as a "non factor" in your age bracket as an iPad tablet is. Truly, that viewpoint is a "You really LIKE that music?!" generational issue for me.
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
Well, kenosha...
zwhittaker 2nd Jun
@kenosha7777 I honestly think that the 'Apple syndrome' is in fact a massive contributing, if not the contributing factor into buying an iPad or any other Apple product that distinguishes itself from the rest of the product lineup.

I stand by my assertions happy
@kenosha7777 I agree and could see myself using one of these Tablets...

People have to remember these things support keyboards and MS has an ecosystem to compete with that of Apples.
0 Votes
+ -
Running on all devices?
Chemlan 2nd Jun
Is it going to run on smartphones? Nokia could probably take advantage of Microsoft's new windows. What are the odds?
0 Votes
+ -
Please Explain This...
His_Shadow Updated - 3rd Jun
Why is it that almost no one writing about non-Apple tablets is capable of passing on vacuous carping about the iPad?

and are buying the tablet through sheer support of the company rather than the need for an extra peripheral

That's right, Zack. It couldn't be because the iPad just fvcking works, now could it? It must be blind allegiance! Steve Jobs RDF! drugs in the water!
0 Votes
+ -
Surprise me
Robert Hahn 2nd Jun
I promise to eat a large helping of roasted crow if it turns out that what people are waiting for is the machine from their office in a tablet form-factor.

I think the people who believe that don't understand what is attractive about tablets. They think tablets are general-purpose computers without keyboards. If they are right, Microsoft will succeed at this.

I think that unless WP7 gathers a following Real Soon Now, the Windows 8 tablets will fare no better than the last ten years' worth of Windows tablets. I think if people wanted Windows on tablets, we would have seen one of the numerous attempts to make one succeed.
0 Votes
+ -
Tiles? THAT'S the big innovation?
daboochmeister Updated - 2nd Jun
I feel like i'm watching that youtube spoof of what it would really be like if Batman tried to work alongside Superman - where Wonder Woman ends up saying, "A ROPE? Your superpower is a ROPE?!?"

Seriously - doesn't Honeycomb already have live widgets that you can setup however you want, resize, layout how you want? How is that less yummy goodness than the tiles in Metro? And you can bet iOS will have a similar feature, well ahead of Windows 8 availability on tablets. And ... ultimately, how many things does it make sense to have visible in this way - weather, inbox glimpse, online contacts, major news maybe - what else?

Honestly, i don't get it. It honestly sounds like the only people who think it's great (compared to alternatives) are those who for whatever reason feel some vested interest in it succeeding.

Other minor comments:

- Premature and totally speculative to say "fluid interface" etc., till it's actually running on lower power processors (what was the processor on that demo unit? Probably not an ARM). Likewise any battery life assertions.

- Side by side apps, meh - you can do this already on Honeycomb, no? Maybe you can't resize with a slider, but that seems like pretty weak tea.

- New Honeycomb 3.1 tablets start shipping in the next couple days, right? (Xoom has had it for a couple weeks) Like the new Samsung 10.1, etc. May very well raise the bar again.

Cue the fanboys and critics.
0 Votes
+ -
You are, I hope, aware that the alpha and omega of your evidence for that statement appears to be a second-hand description of an MRI done on one guy at a trade show? Scientifically speaking, that's not worth the electrons it took to post it. And it certainly doesn't constitute evidence for some sort of inexplicable religious devotion to a particular brand by an entire generation of computer users.

Hell, it barely makes the cut as evidence for the thinking of the one guy they scanned, especially since it was at a trade show where everything is carefully arranged to light up as many pleasure centers as possible. I wonder what you'd get if you ran an MRI on some guy watching the models in bikinis at an auto trade show?
0 Votes
+ -
Message has been deleted.
thomasrex100@... Updated - 5th Jun
I don't think Microsoft Tablets can compete with Apple's Ipads . They are too late into the game. That's why innovation ends up winning the game, always.

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix