B&N nook content test results and info from the user guide

Summary: I put together my initial impressions of the B&N nook yesterday and then we saw reviews from Pogue and Mossberg that offered quite a contrast to my mostly positive review. I spent 3 more hours reading content and using my nook last night and found I like the device even more as I get used to the navigation methods and discover the outstanding content support from various sources. The Sony Reader 505 set the standard for a readable eInk display, more so than the Amazon Kindle, and I am very pleased to say the nook meets that high standard and is also better than the Kindle. I found the second Kindle to have a less viewable display than the first Kindle (fonts were not as good on 2nd Kindle). I was actually able to read content on the nook just by the low light of Christmas lights, which is something I could not do with the Sony Reader Touch Edition.

I put together my initial impressions of the B&N nook yesterday and then we saw reviews from Pogue and Mossberg that offered quite a contrast to my mostly positive review. I spent 3 more hours reading content and using my nook last night and found I like the device even more as I get used to the navigation methods and discover the outstanding content support from various sources. The Sony Reader 505 set the standard for a readable eInk display, more so than the Amazon Kindle, and I am very pleased to say the nook meets that high standard and is also better than the Kindle. I found the second Kindle to have a less viewable display than the first Kindle (fonts were not as good on 2nd Kindle). I was actually able to read content on the nook just by the low light of Christmas lights, which is something I could not do with the Sony Reader Touch Edition.

Content tested and confirmed to work

As I stated previously, the promise of the nook and a primary reason I believe it stands out above the Kindle and Sony Reader devices is the support for multiple content sources. I have tested the following on my new nook and transferred the ebooks in various ways.

Through Adobe Digital Editions app on my MacBook Pro:

Sideloaded through a USB cable:

  • Ebooks from eReader.com (secure eReader format)
  • Ebooks from Fictionwise (secure Ereader and EPUB formats)
  • PDF files from Google and own conversion

For the secure eReader books purchased through Fictionwise and eReader.com you need to enter your credit card info just once for each service and it will be applied across all the ebooks in your library from that store. I receive coupon and discount offers just about every week from these ebook vendors so you can really save a lot of money buying ebooks through these sites rather than directly from Barnes & Noble. You do need to sideload this content, but that is quite easy with the nook.

I understand Sony is transitioning all of their Sony Connect eBookstore content to EPUB format in the next couple of days and wonder if this content will also be able to be used on the nook through Adobe Digital Editions.

My public library card is acting up, but I will try it as soon as I can and understand from others that it is working just fine through Adobe Digital Editions. This was expected, but I still want to confirm the same myself.

Info from the manual

There is quite a long user guide for the nook loaded on the device by default. I spent some time reading it and found a couple things I thought you might like to know:

  • You automatically get a 14-day free trial with magazine and newspaper subscriptions so you can try them out before committing to paying anything.
  • Subscriptions are delivered between 2 am and 5 am local time onto your device.
  • 10 issues of most subscription content is saved so if you want to keep longer you need to save/archive.
  • You may need to Check for new content after sideloading books if they don't appear automatically.
  • USB 1.1 is used to sideload content.
  • You can swipe the lower touchscreen (when turned off) to turn pages.
  • The AT&T wireless radio is 850/1900 MHz and connects via GPRS, EDGE, UMTS, and HSDPA.
  • Even though the manual states other titles should be in the my documents folder, I placed them in a custom folder with subfolders and they worked just fine.
  • The eInk display is 800x600 so it is easy to format any image to use for wallpaper.

Things I would like to see in an update

Like most all gadgets today, the nook is not perfect at the moment. There are some things that would be nice to see implemented, but I still think the nook is the best device available at the moment. The page turn/refresh rate is slower than other devices, but this doesn't really bother me since the display is fantastic. Here are a couple things I would like to see implemented though:

  • Let me choose to go to a page number, rather than just a chapter
  • Ability to sort through B&N ebook store by price, rating, release date, etc.
  • Get rid of Read confirmation on color display. If I open a book then I obviously want to read it so why have me confirm this fact?

If you are looking for a device that is open to multiple content sources, has an excellent eInk display, has multiple wireless connectivity options, and is reasonably priced then you may just want to consider the nook.

Topics: Hardware, Mobility

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

10 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • What it lacks...

    What Nook lacks is the Apple logo. That pretty much guarantees a positive review from Pogue and Mossberg.

    (I have never used it, so I have no opinion on whether it is good/bad.)
    Tom12Tom
  • Great Article

    Now this is the type of article I'm interested in reading.

    This type of information should have been on the B&N site before released. What B&N planning for their next ebook release? I know it's suppose to have color. Is it going to be competitive to with Apple or Jo-jo in the near future? What is the standard ebook reader suppose to be since Time, Cosmopolitan, Better homes and gardens, etc is coming together together? I'm being patient and waiting for the industry standard. Hopefully everyone can update their ebook with onboard storage like the kindle. Can the Nook software be upgraded?

    It's going to take some time before the industry get it right.

    Signed, The Truth..
    kwallyg
  • e-book availability and prices

    But the Kindle has multiple sources for its books too.
    See this list of sources
    for free books (and other places for books for sale):
    http://ireaderreview.com/2008/01/19/free-books-
    for-the-amazon-kindle/
    You can download wirelessly on Kindle from
    Feedbooks.com and get books from Fictionwise as well
    (see http://www.fictionwise.com/help/kindleFaq.htm).
    So not sure why you think Nook is so much better in
    terms of content availability.

    Furthermore, according to a study done by Inkmesh
    (http://inkmesh.com/blog/) Amazon's e-books are
    much cheaper on average than B&N and
    substantially cheaper than Sony's ebook store
    (the $9.99 is only for the top bestsellers).
    daedalus2
    • I read on Gizmodo

      That the B&N e-book store was in the process of
      adjusting their prices to be similar to Amazon's.
      I haven't checked this out myself yet, but it may
      be worth a look.
      lostarchitect
    • Book Sources and Prices

      It is a little more difficult to get books from other sources onto the Kindle than the Nook, because of the limitation on formats. This means you need to have Amazon convert it and then you can put it on the Kindle. Nook has more options for native formats including EPub (closest thing to an industry atm), which can be put directly on the device without any need to convert.

      As for the article on pricing study. It is now outdated. B&N has stated they will bring prices inline with Amazazon. In either case, it is often easy to find prices online that is better than either Amazon or B&N.
      tristanfey
  • RE: B&N nook content test results and info from the user guide

    Perhaps you could define what "sideloading" means, I am not familiar with this term.
    frankmiller
    • Sideloading

      The author is referring to placing the e-books on a SD Card and puttign that into the Nook.
      tristanfey
  • quick Amazon vs.B&N ebook comparison:

    OK, you got me curious so I am going to do a quick comparison for some of my favorite books. This is not
    comprehensive, and it only represents books I
    personally might buy...

    B&N prices on the left, Amazon on the right. Prices in
    USD.

    Neal Stephenson: Anathem
    BN: 7.99 Am: 7.99

    Neal Stephenson: The Diamond Age
    BN: 9.99 Am: 9.99

    Best of Gene Wolfe
    BN: 14.76 Am: 15.37

    JRR Tolkein: The Hobbit
    BN: 7.99 Am: 7.99

    Cormac McCarthy: The Road
    BN: 7.99 Am: 7.99

    Philip K. Dick: VALIS
    BN: 9.99 Am: 9.99


    Looks like the prices are mostly equal, at least for
    books in my tastes.
    lostarchitect
    • Best ebook prices not always available from Amazon or B&N

      In a previous post, <i>lostarchitect</i> gave a list of their favorite books and sample prices from B&N and Amazon which showed pretty equal prices.

      But usually you can get better prices for ebooks for the Nook elsewhere, there's some very competitive prices out there if you include discount vouchers and rebate prices into the mix.

      Current prices showing for the Nook from my website ebookprice.info for the same list are:

      <pre>
      OK, you got me curious so I am going to do a quick comparison for some of my favorite books. This is not
      comprehensive, and it only represents books I
      personally might buy...

      B&N prices on the left, Amazon on the right. Prices in
      USD.

      Neal Stephenson: Anathem
      BN: 7.99 Am: 7.99
      </pre>

      Fictionwise: $4.80 (price includes future rebate)

      <pre>
      Neal Stephenson: The Diamond Age
      BN: 9.99 Am: 9.99
      </pre>

      Fictionwise: $6.00 (including future rebate)
      CyberRead: $8.21 (including immediate 25% discount voucher code)

      <pre>
      JRR Tolkein: The Hobbit
      BN: 7.99 Am: 7.99
      </pre>

      Fictionwise: $4.00 (including future rebate)
      CyberRead: $7.49 (including immediate 25% discount voucher)

      <pre>
      Philip K. Dick: VALIS
      BN: 9.99 Am: 9.99
      </pre>

      CyberRead: $8.21 (including immediate 25% discount voucher)
      </pre>

      So before you make a choice on which reader you buy, check out all the bookstores available.

      Rachel
      <rachel@ebookprice.info>
      rwillmer
      • Interesting, thanks for the info! [n/t]

        .
        lostarchitect