iPad's versions of iWorks apps not fully roundtripping

iPad's versions of iWorks apps not fully roundtripping

Summary: iPad versions of iWorks apps are leaving behind some of your original doc's content

SHARE:

If you're debating about buying the iPad versions of Keynote or Pages, make sure that you don't care about presenter notes, comments, 3D charts, and other assorted pieces of functionality.

According to a post by Adrian Kingsley-Hughes, a fellow ZDNet contributor, Apple has released somewhat crippled iWorks apps for the iPad, and users are frustrated. Apparently, there's a laundry list of features that won't make the trip from standard OSX to iPad. However, to find that list you have to dig into the FAQs like this Keynote for iPad one, or wait until you perform the conversion and then receive a detailed list of what didn't make the cut.

I'm glad that I spotted this news today since I've been debating about getting the Keynote and Pages apps, along with the video dongle. Bad roundtripping is something I dealt with for far too long with Windows Mobile--Microsoft finally fixed it--and I have zero interest in repeating the experience, especially with something like Presenter Notes and Comments not making it to the iPad. How is a presenter expected to do a solid job presenting without her notes?

There are plenty of alternative presentation options, including saving your original Keynote or Powerpoint as a PDF and then showing the PDF from the iPad. And that alternative didn't cost an extra $10.

Topics: Mobile OS, Apple, Wi-Fi, Software, Operating Systems, Mobility, iPad, Hardware, Collaboration, Windows

Joel Evans

About Joel Evans

With more than 15 years of mobile, Internet and wireless experience, Joel specializes in taking existing brands and technologies into the mobile and wireless space. Joel is currently the VP of Strategy Integration for Mobiquity, an enterprise-class mobile solutions provider.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

6 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • Its just rev 1.0 Apple will update it !

    It will take them a bit of time, but the pages app will get updated as
    more people start to use it. Rev 1.0 always have some shortcomings
    MacNewton
    • pay up

      And apple as usual will charge for the update
      like they demand for the iPod touch and now
      ipad. Apple and the new Microsoft and with
      linux pads coming I think they will be better
      value in the long tun.
      slowe@...
      • Re: Pay Up

        Well, i can't WAIT to get Windows 8 for free. Or perhaps, the next
        version of Office - that's going to be free too right?

        I can't wait to get my free updated copy of Expressions, Visio, Outlook...
        This whole new free-for-all business model for the Software
        industry is going to be SO amazing! Can you believe it? No more paying
        for ANY software ever again! slowe, this news is incredible!
        /A\V/
    • But surely...

      file compatibility with their own products is something they should get right out of the box?

      If this was something like converting ODF or MS Office documents, I could understand it, I'd be annoyed that I'd have to waste time reformatting, but I'd understand it.

      But this is Apple's Pages documents being opened by Pages and destroying formatting and automatically generated text! And something like a ToC field is fairly standard and found in nearly every document I write.

      I would accept Pages going "I don't understand/can't generate a ToC and leave a marker for it in the text, but to delete the ToC marker and replace it with plain text is inexcusable.
      wright_is
  • RE: iPad's versions of iWorks apps not fully roundtripping

    One thing I have not seen about the iPad is the ability to print to a wireless printer? Can it connect to one and print? Or does anything created on the iPad need to be sent to another machine to print?
    fbeiderb
  • RE: iPad's versions of iWorks apps not fully roundtripping

    The iPad is NOT a substitute for a laptop, so I've got no problem with limitations on the word processor (edit text, paste edited paragraphs back into the original - not a big deal). But losing presenter notes? On a gadget that's otherwise the ideal presentation tool? THAT is definitely a boneheaded screwup on Apple's part, and a deal-breaker on v.1.0.
    jpdemers@...