The biggest barrier to the Chromebook in the consumer space: Apple

By | May 12, 2011, 5:40am PDT

Summary: There’s a huge barrier to entry for millions of consumers considering the Chromebook: it doesn’t work with Apple products. That barrier may be too big for Google to overcome.

Google has set tongues wagging with the upcoming launch of the Chromebook devices, driven by Chrome OS and pushing the user to live in the cloud. The concept is interesting and Google has smartly aimed it squarely at the enterprise and the education system. It will be sold to consumers, too, and that’s the market segment that may give Google the most fits with the Chromebook. There’s a huge barrier to entry for millions of consumers considering the Chromebook: it doesn’t work with Apple products.

That barrier is massive to overcome for a new product, which already faces a big job to convince consumers that a totally new type of product is what they need. What Google is going to run into headfirst is something no amount of positioning or marketing can deal with. The millions of existing iPhone, iPad and iPod owners cannot use the Chromebook with those devices. That is one task the Chromebook can’t perform, and it is unlikely it ever will. Google will be looking at convincing Apple product owners that they need to switch, or forget the Chromebook. That is a huge unreachable market for a brand new product.

If Google and its Chromebook partners try to cover up that inability in the marketing message, it will backfire. There will be a lot of Chromebooks bought by existing Apple product owners, and they will quickly be returned for refunds. Companies will have to come up with a marketing angle for consumers that deals with that prior to purchase, and that is a very daunting task. I predict the number one reason given for Chromebook returns will be that “it doesn’t work with my iPhone/iPad/iPod.”

See related coverage:

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

James Kendrick has been using mobile devices since they weighed 30 pounds, and has been sharing his insights on mobile technology for almost that long.

Disclosure

James Kendrick

James Kendrick has no affiliations or relationships that need to be disclosed.

Biography

James Kendrick

James Kendrick has been using mobile devices since they weighed 30 pounds, and has been sharing his insights on mobile technology for almost that long. Prior to joining ZDNet, James was the Founding Editor of jkOnTheRun, a CNET Top 100 Tech Blog that was acquired by GigaOM in 2008 and is now part of that prestigious tech network. James' writing has appeared in many print publications: Smartphone and Pocket PC Magazine, Information Week and Laptop Magazine to name a few. James' coverage of the mobile technology sector has regularly appeared in the New York Times, Salon.com and CNN/ Fortune online. Not just a writer, James has filmed numerous video reviews and how-tos that have garnered well over a million viewers. He has appeared on local news segments and been interviewed by the Associated Press on mobile technology topics. Additionally, James has been podcasting about mobile technology for years.

86
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

RE: The biggest barrier to the Chromebook in the consumer space: Apple
arthur.freed 21st Sep
I have read an article about Microsoft Windows supporting Chrome but with this I think Apple is on the other way around. There maybe some issues between Chrome and Apple that we don't know.

Mortgage Jacksonville FL
Mortgage Jacksonville Florida

Mortgage Rates
0 Votes
+ -
Not following
facebook@... 12th May 2011
I do not see Mac users buying Chromebooks AKA nettops anyway. A Mac user would buy an Air or an ipad2 due to brand loyalty. Google is not going after the global 5% population of Mac users, they are targeting the other 95%.
0 Votes
+ -
Not sure about ....
Economister 12th May 2011
@facebook@...

the 5/95 split, but there are a lot of consumers like me who do not own ANY Apple products and who have no intention of getting any, and for whom this is a non-issue. It is also possible that many consumers who have grown frustrated with their PCs will give up their Apple product(s) just to be able to use a very simple computing appliance, WITH a keyboard. There are also substitutes for these Apple products that may meet the needs of Chromebook users. Time will tell.
@Economister
The Chromebooks are gonna tank. Why pay the same price for a device that is more cumbersome than a tablet and only just as useful. The reality is that you will still need a laptop so a laptop + tablet makes more sense thatna laptop + chromebook.
would like some of those adventuresome iPad owners to try Google for their netbook since it is a lot cheaper than Apple alternatives.
0 Votes
+ -
Yup
MSFTWorshipper 12th May 2011
@DonnieBoy I own an HP Pavillion, 2 iPads, iPod Touch, iPod Nano, iMac, Mac Mini.

I buy the best technology for my needs, whoever it is. Not into fanboyism.
@DonnieBoy Cheaper and equivalent and two different things.
@facebook@...

I don't believe James mentioned anything about Mac users. He did mention the millions of consumers using Apple's iOS devices that cannot use the Chromebook with those devices. And if we are to use your 5/95 split then it would be obvious that the majority of those iOS users are Windows users, not Mac users. iOS devices are not Macs.
@facebook@... your statement is based on a mythological sterotype of Mac users. While there may be a VERY small handful of brand extremists, most people who use Macs simply use Macs because they are good computers, and have no problem using products from other companies as well.

There are far more people with the oposite polarizing mindset- people who would never buy an Apple product no mater how good it was, god knows why.
@facebook@...

Apple iOS is not a Mac OS. It's the operating system that is used on iPhones, iPods Touch and iPads. Most users of those devices are used to using their Windows or Mac computer running iTunes to handle firmware updates, content purchases, etc.

That other 95% of users are often owners of one or more of the iWhatever and, as the article stated, are not going to be happy campers when they are unable to sync their devices with their new Chromebook.
0 Votes
+ -
Who said anything about Mac users?
rbethell 12th May 2011
@facebook@...

What about my iPod?
@facebook@... Did you not read the piece? At what point did he say Mac user only? First Mac users are going to either buy another or not based on their experience, not blind brand loyalty like all the haters want everyone to believe. That being said this article didn't have anything to do with them, it was talking about iPhone, iPod and iPad owners.
I have read an article about Microsoft Windows supporting Chrome but with this I think Apple is on the other way around. There maybe some issues between Chrome and Apple that we don't know.

Mortgage Jacksonville FL
Mortgage Jacksonville Florida

Mortgage Rates
Actually the biggest barrier is the Chrome Book itself! Nobody wants a device that requires you to be connected most of the time even if it comes with Verizon Data for free!

Even more, people don't want to rent their software, they want to buy a license and use it whenever they want.

Another thing, in this economy it is not the time to add another monthly bill!
0 Votes
+ -
"Nobody wants"?
Economister 12th May 2011
@Peter Perry

Only idiots speak for everyone else.
0 Votes
+ -
Well, this site is full of them
John Zern 12th May 2011
@Economister
many of them the bloggers themselves.
0 Votes
+ -
Including ....
Economister 12th May 2011
@John Zern

the man in your mirror.
@Economister - so he was referring to you, then?
0 Votes
+ -
And how exactly .....
Economister 12th May 2011
@HypnoToad72

would I be in HIS mirror????

Not the sharpest knife in the drawer.
@Economister
Speaking for yourself yay!
0 Votes
+ -
100% on spot
theo_durcan 13th May 2011
@Economister
sick of those idiots that speak for everybody!
0 Votes
+ -
OMG!! I agree with Peter!
James Quinn 12th May 2011
@Peter Perry This is yet another attemp to get a subscription model. Like cable, persriptiom drugs, utility bills, etc etc! Soon we will be expected to pay monthly for the cloths we wear! Maybe even the air we breath. Ownership is a concept that is being destroyed. There was an old song about "Oweing ones soul to the company store". The days of Indentured servitude are going to be a part of most people's lives if in many ways they are not already here.

Pagan jim
@James Quinn -- Agreed!
And Peter should have stated specifically that "Nobody in their right mind" not just "Nobody."
0 Votes
+ -
Who cares?
MikeFM 12th May 2011
@Peter Perry
A lot of my switch to primarily using an iPhone and iPad is that my real computing is done on my server cluster or in a hosted cloud. The device is just an interface with a cache. It does cache apps and data though so usually I can work during the rare times I'm not connected by wifi/3G to a server somewhere. The thing is, the cloud can be and eventually will be transparent to the user and it allows them to use smaller, sexier, cheaper devices that aren't miniture thermo nuclear reactors and don't require a cord or a constant recharge.

You're thinking of the web you know. What is coming down the pipe is optimized for running even when you aren't online and fast communications between client and server.
0 Votes
+ -
Rather not be a client
James Quinn 12th May 2011
@MikeFM I like the idea of depending on no one. If I buy into this modle I may very well find myself with a device who's function is only to connect me to (if i pay monthly for my connection) my data (if I pay a monthly storage fee), applications that I can pay (monthly) to use, and of course the device itself comes with a monthly fee. Yeah real attractive...... NOT!

Pagan jim
@Peter Perry I fully agree with you - this is a first! LOL

While I'm not claiming to speak for everyone why would I want a device that is barely a decent netbook that has no on-board storage and requires a full-time internet connection coupled with yet another monthly bill? If I'm in a spot where the internet is down I'm hosed if I want to use the thing, I'm unable to play any of my games on it, I'm not able to sync my iPhone to it, for me this thing has no appeal at all.

The business model itself just does not work out either. Sure it's $28/m which sounds great - heck I was interested until I read further about it - until one adds up the total cost with the 3 year commitment which is a bit over $1,000. I can get a fully loaded laptop running Windows 7 for far less and dual boot it with Linux if I'm so inclined and will still be able to use it if the internet is down due to it having an internal hard drive. This is a great way to bring an affordable starter computer (or a computer to use for email and web surfing) to those who are unable to pay up front for a computer - but that does not sound like the intent of Google at all in this.
0 Votes
+ -
Not every iPad , iPhone, or iPad user is a Mac user. In fact most aren't. So you're 5% notion is nonsense
0 Votes
+ -
iTunes for Chrome?
John Zern 12th May 2011
So how do you install iTunes on to ChromeOS? You don't.
So now Google's going to tell everyone that this is a best deal, and that you really don't need your Apple devices.

Yeah, I really see that working...
0 Votes
+ -
I don't use iTunes
Economister Updated - 12th May 2011
@John Zern

as shocking as that may be to you.
@Economister
John Zern is not talking about the penny pinchers like you though. He is talking about millions of iOS device owners, mind you.
@Economister I think he's referring to those who use iTunes to sync their iDevices... And that is one of my reasons for not wanting one of these ChromeBooks as iTunes is something I use to sync my iPhone with.
They would use ChromeBook for web applications, games, email, reading news, other work. In any case, I would assume there are already ways to get iTunes into MP3 format, and those would play just fine on a ChromeBook.
@DonnieBoy
You've even pointed out how great iTunes is because of all the people who use it for movies, music, TV, ect so how does one go about loading iTunes onto this so that they can use their Apple devices?

Doesn't matter there are alternatives, people won't give up iTunes to use this thing.
0 Votes
+ -
Read what you wrote
dave95. 12th May 2011
@DonnieBoy

"Most would use their iPod or iPhone to listen to their music.
They would use ChromeBook for web applications, games, email, reading news, other work."

But this is exactly how most use an iPad today, web, games, apps, reading news and other work. Why would anyone pass on an iPad for a ChromeBook that doesn't work with their current iOS ecosystem? Doesn't have nearly the amount of Apps as the iPad and most likely never will. Is basically just a web browser that's constantly connected to Google's data mining headquarters. I don't get it.
will continue listening to music on those devices. There will be ways to sync iTunes music to ChromeOS sooner or later. It is not necessary to have everything out of the gate. Most people get movies from other services.
iPhone. The ChromeBook is a different animal completely. It has a bigger screen, and full size keyboard, and is for when you have to do some more serious typing. The ChromeBook is also cheaper than an iPad. At Starbucks, I want something to set on the table and support itself. I want to be able to quickly shoot off a long email. So, iPad will continue to sell well, but, so will notebooks.
0 Votes
+ -
They wont
FADS_z 12th May 2011
@DonnieBoy
netbook is better choice. Cheaper, no subscription. Anyway, what 100M data plan can do?
@DonnieBoy

iPad users can also attach a full size keyboard and get the best of both worlds. You're failing at convincing me that this will sell well with consumers.
adaptor, and then, the screen is still too small, and, you are talking over 600 instead of 349. So, YES, there are use cases where iPad would be better suited, but, also use cases where ChromeBook would work much better. People will continue to buy notebooks in large quantities. The competition for ChromeBooks is Windows 7 notebooks, MacBook Air.
@DonnieBoy

If competition is Win Notebooks/Netbooks, then a quick search would find you this $349 Acer "15 Notebook below that can do so much more than this ChromeBook. Including playing nice with iTunes and iOS devices. Running Photoshop and other power software, as well as legacy stuff. If it's trying to be competition to Notebooks/Netbooks (and replace it) then ChromeBook loses there also.

http://www.amazon.com/Acer-LX-RD502-005-AS5253-BZ602-15-6-Inch-Laptop/dp/B004ETLO6C

The problem for Google is Apple has already proved (with the iPad) that consumers don't necessarily need a full physical keyboard and mouse to perform their daily computing tasks, which 95% of the time is consuming and entertainment. The iPad is not trying to take the place of Notebooks/Netbooks like this ChromeBook, or pretending to be one. It's truly offering a new post-pc paradigm to consumers.
@John Zern
why itunes, there are tons of alternatives amazon for instance
@kdsandeep@... Because iTunes works great! I can use Paypal with iTunes.. try that with Amazon..
@kdsandeep@... They use iTunes because its the best way to sync and manage their iOS devices.
@John Zern I don't use iTunes either. Never have. I just have not seen the need. I have all my music on my devices or in the cloud. Not knocking iTunes at all, just don't like only having one option.
@DonnieBoy: ... phones. Recent research of platform share shows that. In the future, yes, Andoid will be bigger numerically since it sells faster in the last few quarters than iOS.

However, the ecosystem is not actually the quantity of devices, was the quantity of capable devices -- with AndroidMarket and with users ever attempting to buy something from there. This, for now, is dim picture for Andoid -- its software market is super tiny comparing to iOS' one.
@John Zern Google will just tell them its another reason to use Android!
@John Zern

It's not jst iTunes, it is how do you sync ANYTHING? I don't use iTuens as I own 4 Zunes and use the Zune software, so this is automatically a non-starter. But what about phones, cameras, external drives, NAS devices etc.

There are just so many things wrong with this model and what they are offering that it can't be taken seriously by business or consumers unless you are a die hard Google fanboy, so that means DonnieBoy will have at least 3 of these on pre-order by this weekend happy
What tasks are you referring to. Normally, you would use these devices separately. You can share things via the web.
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
@DonnieBoy Activation, syncing with iTunes primarily. That's what current owners are using to handle the devices, and can't with the Chromebook.
iTunes. Also, most people that have iTunes already own an iPod and/or iPhone, they will use those devices to listen to music.
0 Votes
+ -
Which is an issue right now
Nihon8888 Updated - 12th May 2011
@JamesKendrick But when (and I guess if) Apple start offering a cloud based "iTunes" solution, as is rumored, this one barrier goes away.

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix