Traveler beware: Data-hungry smartphones
Summary: Savvy owners use Wi-Fi most of the time at home, but often that's not feasible when traveling. Beware the big data charge when switching from Wi-Fi to 3G/4G.
Smartphones are powerful communication tools that no longer only handle voice calls. Today's smartphone is a full communication system handling voice, email, text messaging, along with web access of all types. This comes at a cost in data consumption, as any savvy owner can attest. The amount of data transmitted by smartphones in the background can catch travelers by surprise on trips.
My colleague Zack Whittaker recently discovered how much data his iPhone was shooting back and forth on an extended trip to the U. S. (he's based in the UK). Just doing mundane things like email on his phone resulted in a large data roaming charge from his carrier in the UK.
Zack was so taken aback by this data roaming charge he switched back to the BlackBerry (not the one pictured here) after this trip. While the BlackBerry is gentler on data consumption than other options, with a little planning perhaps he could have avoided the big data surcharge.
I suspect Zack isn't the only traveler to run into this situation, and it's directly related to the inclusion of Wi-Fi on most smartphones. Savvy phone owners know that Wi-Fi is much easier on battery consumption than 3G/4G data connections as well as data consumption, and phones are kept on Wi-Fi a lot of the time.
I regularly check my data plans to make sure I am not pushing up against data caps, and never do. That's in large part because I leave all of my devices on Wi-Fi as much as possible. Data used on Wi-Fi isn't reflected in the data usage statistics as it is not tracked. I suspect if I took a 2-week trip on data only, I would be quite surprised to see how much data I was using.
Staying on Wi-Fi is not always easy to do when traveling, and smartphone owners discover the hard way that using the phone on a 3G/4G connection taps into the data plan quickly. It's harder on the battery too, as many who travel frequently know all too well. It can be a common occurrence for the battery to start running dry before the end of the day. The sudden switch from Wi-Fi to 3G/4G connections can be a big change.
Smartphones are always working on communication, even when not actively being used. Push email means the phones are always going back and forth with the email server to dish up the email as soon as possible. Those who only get a few emails a day may not worry about it, but those like Zack who get hundreds quickly find out that the data well can run dry quickly.
It is a good idea to get on Wi-Fi as much as possible when traveling to avoid the data consumption surprise. That's not always as easy to do in the real world, but it makes advance planning especially important. Savvy business travelers are known to plan remote work venues for the Wi-Fi, and rightly so.
Related: Face off: Novatel 4G LTE MiFi vs. Samsung 4G LTE Mobile Hotspot
I often take my 4G/LTE Mobile Hotspot along on trips for those times when Wi-Fi isn't readily available. It lets me use my laptop, tablet, and smartphone on a single data connection. That keeps my smartphone data plan under better control.
It's a good idea to realize how much data different tasks can consume, not just on smartphones but on tablets, too. Dwight Silverman of The Houston Chronicle recently discovered just watching two 30-minute TV programs on his iPad used up over a gigabyte of 4G data. It all adds up, and it pays to keep an eye on what you do on top of all the background activity that devices are doing.
If you want to get a handle on how much data your phone uses over time, there's an easy way to do it. Just turn the Wi-Fi off in the phone settings and use only a cellular data connection. Keep a close eye on the data consumption while doing so, either through the phone's utilities or the carrier's web site. Be prepared to be shocked if you try this little experiment.
As for my buddy Zack, he's been a Crackberry for a long time. I suspect he was just looking for an excuse to switch back, and that's OK. He likes the BlackBerry so that's what he should be using.
Modern smartphones are always using data in the background, it's part and parcel of the smartphone experience. While on Wi-Fi nobody cares, but switch to 3G (and especially 4G/LTE) and everybody need to pays attention, or likely pay up.
Related posts:
- How to fix the Android update mess: Paid updates
- New Year’s resolution for Google: Fix the Android update situation
- Cutting through the FUD about Windows Phone updates
- Microsoft is in the driver’s seat for Windows Phone updates
- AT&T’s business model: why your mobile bill keeps going up
- The Flawed Android Update Process; Too Many Cooks
- Will the new Android consortium fix the update fiasco?
Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.
Talkback
My trip
Over the 6 days I kept up with emails (although I slipped the refresh from as soon as anything came in to hourly (the other emails to manual download). Uploaded several pics of the trip, searched for a few locations etc.
I figured I'd get a bill for $300-450 for the time I was away... nope. Some other little fingers were searching for things too while her phone wasn't topped up with funds.
The bill was a little over $1000 for the 6 days. I should've kept better eye on the usage but what the hell, I needed to keep in touch for work.
Be careful... I was and I still got a big bill. Rude the prices we need to pay really. Considering how accessible the data is and how we 'need' it.
My recommendation
1) Buy simple dual sim phone. One sim for home-land other local sim. Call on local sim, get calls on your home-land.
2) use ipad with local sim, cheapest way.
3) don't travel with smartphone. sometimes just switch it on, and some data is being downloaded and charged; for example Weather Apps like HTC sense.
Isaac
Policy...
Roaming data should be switched off during normal use and only switched on to collect e-mails when needed, then switched off again. Likewise, the users are told to use wi-fi whenever possible.
I think my 2 week trip to the UK last year cost under 2 Euros in data usage.
I have to be careful with that
Another tip to minimize data roaming charges is to...
MiFi makes trips simple
Now when I go overseas I have a number of options.
1. Use the SIM in the MiFi and stand the roaming costs (although my provider does have some reasonable roaming deals)
2. Use a SIM from the likes of aBroadband who offer better roaming rates
3. Buy a Pre Paid SIM locally
By using the MiFi (which is easy to swap the SIM in and out of) I don't have to mess about reconfiguring phones and people can still call me on my voice number etc.
Likewise my smartphone can connect to the MiFi over WiFi, so can my wifes and we can connect an iPad or even a laptop.
So on a trip to Budapest only last week I was able to pop into the local T-Mobile store and buy a pre paid SIM with 2GB of data on it for less than 10 euros. This was more than enough for the whole family for the week we were there and we didn't need to think twice about uploading videos to Facebook, checking emails or planning our next day on Google maps.
Simple Solution
"Call Sprint and...."
Accept iOS / Android isn't for everyone
"I suspect he was just looking for an excuse to switch back, and that???s OK. He likes the BlackBerry so that???s what he should be using."
What is wrong with understanding for his / your NEEDs the Blackberry works better? It was built for the lone purpose of messaging thus it kills iOS / Android in that regard. Email's deliver in 2k increments, compressed, secure and sip on the battery.
All the other crap people do on devices has usually nothing to do with business communication. I have a host of devices (iPhone 4S, Android, Blackberry, Playbook, iPad) and the daily driver remains the Blackberry (9930) due to it works best for how I WORK. I don't want to change my work style and workflow to make the iPhone work. Frankly email on it is awful, it sucks battery like crazy and the whole point of Zack's article is data roaming (internationally) is expensive. People do realize public open WiFi is often not secure? The beauty of BB is even on a open WiFi the whole communication is encrypted at all times so the likelihood of being hacked is low. Add to the fact the compression and PUSH email delivery makes Blackberry an incredible device for the global traveler.
ActiveSync / IMAP are PULL based and thus not as efficient with battery life or data usage. It's one of the main reasons iOS people turn off ActiveSync as it's very chatty.
Thought Zack was a tecj-savvy hack ?
Anyone with half a brain knows, and has done for years, you shut your Data Roaming off before you go abroad, or set-up with your carrier so you don't get your bank account raped and pillaged.
Find cheap or free WiFi abroad is the way to go, or get a MiFi and buy a PAYG SIM when you get their.
data plan on required for making calls
I had access to wi-fi, so if I needed to send email or check any other app, it was fine via wi-fi. The only problem is that smartphones are useless if data services are turned off - can't even make a phone call except for emergency. It was vacation time and wasn't about to test how much Verizon can charge me for using data, even if roaming is turned off.
I always had someone with the local cellphone, but still this option is rediculous for US plans. European smartphones do not requires data plan to be used as phone - which is one option that we users should require from cellphone provides.
wifi and data