Tech Broiler

Jason Perlow and Scott Raymond

Android 3.1: Crowd-pleaser or heart-breaker?

By | May 13, 2011, 6:00am PDT

Summary: How well does the new update to Android Honeycomb fix the issues plaguing it?

This past week we heard a number of welcome announcements at Google I/O, not the least of which was the release of Android 3.1. Still dubbed Honeycomb, version 3.1 is supposed to correct a number of showstopping issues with the operating system that caused it to be roundly snubbed by the press.

Currently the update is being pushed out to Verizon and Wifi XOOM owners alike. Being the impatient sort that I am, I decided to track down the update and install it manually. Using this method found on the XDA Developers forum, I had reverted back to the stock boot image and system files, and then used the process to upgrade my tablet without needing to wipe my data. Of course, I did make a backup just in case.

Readers may remember that I recently rooted and installed the Tiamat kernel on my tablet, which improved stability and provided me with access to the SD card. Unfortunately, the Tiamat Kernel is not currently compatible with Android 3.1, so you might want to wait for version 1.4.2 before trying to install it.

Also See: Motorola XOOM vs. Galaxy Tab 7: A study in usability

After updating, the interface looked pretty much the same as it did previously. What I did notice was that the device felt a lot faster and smoother overall, for transitions, animations and application launching. I’ve noticed quite a few minor tweaks in the core applications; minor improvements in the user interface and layout.

Two major issues with the previous version of Honeycomb were the Android Market and the browser. Both of them were notoriously unreliable, crashing with little or no provoication. The browser was well-known for simply closing up without even an error message just for turning the tablet from landscape to portrait orientation.

Those issues are now gone. The browser and Market apps are quite stable now. I have also noticed a definite improvement in the performance of Flash video playback. Previously, videos from sites like Viddler would play, but the video would freeze while the sound kept playing. Now that issue has also been resolved.

Adobe has released Flash 10.3 for Android and desktops, which goes even further in improving Flash by utilizing hardware acceleration.

Of course, there are still some issues stemming from compatibility with Android 3.x. There are applications that were written specifically for Android 2.x, and are not necessarily compatible with the new operating system. Issues with resolution, orientation, and simply inability to run under the new OS exist in numerous applications.

Of course, this behavior is to be expected in any major OS upgrade. It happened numerous times with Microsoft Windows every time they had a major revision. Hopefully now that Google seems to have stabilized the operating system, more developers will update their apps to be compatible with the new OS.

And maybe, just maybe, Google will push an update that gives us access to the SD card slot. Right now, without Tiamat, the only way I can access the SD card is on recovery reboot through ROM Manager and Clockwork Recovery Image.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

Scott Raymond has been a technologist and system administrator for over 25 years.

Disclosure

Scott Raymond

I am the IT Manager for a high end audio and network systems integrator in northern Califronia. My wife works at Adobe Systems, Inc. Whenever I write an article that might involve Adobe or its products, I add a disclaimer at the top of the article to make sure she is not involved in any way. We have a small bit of stock with AT&T and no other major investments that would cause conflict.

Biography

Scott Raymond

Scott Raymond has been a technologist and system administrator for over 25 years. Starting as a hobbyist in his teens, Scott quickly learned that he could translate his passion and knowledge into a full-time career. He currently works as the IT Manager for a high end audio and network systems integrator in northern California. He has written technology articles for various publications in the past and began contributing to ZDnet as a guest blogger on Jason Perlow's Tech Broiler. Scott and Jason met in New York in the 1990s where they co-managed the New York City Palm Pilot Users' Group.

In his spare time, Scott is a trained chef and avid bicycling enthusiast, as well as a voracious reader of historical, science and horror fiction. He is a huge fan of pop culture, with a wide range of interest in TV shows, movies and games.

70
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

help with dissertation
2r4racer 19th May
It is very nice to see this blog and it's really informative for the readers. It is really nice to see the best information presented in an easy and understanding manner.
Thank you.
help with dissertation
0 Votes
+ -
Nice
Hasam1991 13th May 2011
But why are they obssesed with copying Apple and everything Apple does??
0 Votes
+ -
@Hasam1991 Not sure they are. They have copied as much from Windows as they have Apple, Gnome, and KDE...they also have aspects of the old Symbian interface. Innovation is about taking the best of everything and making something distinctly new. I believe Android has for the most part done that.
0 Votes
+ -
@Socratesfoot

Everyone borrows a bit from somewhere.

"If I have seen further it is only by standing on the shoulders of giants."

Isaac Newton
0 Votes
+ -
@Hasam1991 You mean like,

Unified notification area
Flash Support
Widget support
App Draw
Bluetooth Game Controller Support
True HD Playback on the Tablet
Voice Control
Voice dictation
Bit Torrent Support
App stores that don't require subscriptions in the App
Animated Wallpaper

Which one of these did they copy Apple on again?

Oh and get this, my battery has gotten between 10 and 12 Hours now!
0 Votes
+ -
@Peter Perry
yes, they've improvised some things but overall the strategy look like 'We want to be Apple' look at Apple TV for example..
0 Votes
+ -
@Hasam1991 Get real, Apple wasn't even the first to do that!
0 Votes
+ -
@Peter Perry Oh my Gods! Animated wallpaper! Widgets! What a brave leap into the institutionalized ADHD world of tween tweakers.
0 Votes
+ -
@Hasam1991 You mean like,

Unified notification area
Flash Support
Widget support
App Draw
Bluetooth Game Controller Support
True HD Playback on the Tablet
Voice Control
Voice dictation
Bit Torrent Support
App stores that don't require subscriptions in the App
Animated Wallpaper

Which one of these did they copy Apple on again?

Oh and get this, my battery has gotten between 10 and 12 Hours now!
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
Android 3.1 battery life
Scott Raymond 13th May 2011
@Peter Perry The Xoom battery life was already good, but I thought I was imagining things when it seemed like I was getting even more after the update. Now that's a real improvement.
0 Votes
+ -
@Scott Raymond you were not imagining it at all, several of us noted that the Tablet is making it longer in the day without dying!

I'm serious, this thing took what was a close comparison with the iPad 2 (nobody said the iPad 2 was beating it in every area) and has raised the bar enough that Apple cannot reach it with their present hardware!
0 Votes
+ -
@Hasam1991 They may copy a few design elements. Everyone does. After all, ipod3 was not the first touch screen phone that did not need a stylus. But, their business model is completely different. Google monetizes their software for the benefits of its advertising customers -- every software product google releases is a direct or causal link to advertising opportunities. And Apple is a hardware company -- every software product apple releases is a direct or causal link to sell high margin hardware.
0 Votes
+ -
@Hasam1991
when pointing out that much of the technology they sell has been done before (touchscreen phones, ect) that their "brilliance" is that they take these different, pre-existing devices and combine them into something new?
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Android 3.1: Crowd-pleaser or heart-breaker?
timspublic1@... 13th May 2011
@John Zern New? Like the tablet PC MS brought out 10 years ago? Or maybe the touchscreen phone, like the Palm Treo's? Ya, all new stuff and new uses...right?
0 Votes
+ -
timspublic1, like
Will Pharaoh 13th May 2011
@John Zern
years ago they had touch screen PDA's, (PocketPC, Palm, ect) that ran programs you downloaded and installed and did the internet, and cell phones.

So someone puts them together and they gets to call every part "original", and yet Palm does it then they're "coppying Apple"?

I don't get what your saying.
0 Votes
+ -
@Hasam1991,

In technology everyone copies everyone. Why re-invent the wheel? You don't have to...just make it better.
0 Votes
+ -
Foss philosophy.
Joe.Smetona Updated - 13th May 2011
Get someone's source code, improve it, they get your code back, improve on it. someone new gets it and uses it, improves it and everyone gains something. Someone uses it for a different purpose and adds to it, etc. Everyone wins unless you want to make a monopoly.
0 Votes
+ -
Apple TV is VERY Different than G TV
jivester 13th May 2011
@Hasam1991 Apple TV is a desktop (or iOS) extension for playing files on the TV. Google TV is a way of categorizing web video content for easy viewing on real TV's. Totally Different approach. Plus Google TV will open it's doors to apps which will hopefully usher in a whole new era (and hopefully reduce prices).
0 Votes
+ -
@jivester A new era of people playing Angry Birds on their TV?

Please go away.
@Hasam1991

"Of course, this behavior is to be expected in any major OS upgrade. It happened numerous times with Microsoft Windows every time they had a major revision. Hopefully now that Google seems to have stabilized the operating system, more developers learn violin online will update their apps to be compatible with the new OS."

And apart from that, you downloaded it in some illegal, copied version. glaucoma eyes drops How can you possibly expect it to work 100%?

Oh, and Hasam1991, why do you mean that they copy everything Apple does? Do you know what the idea behind Apple is? It is not to be bright eyes drops innovative and make brand new products. No, it is to take already existing stuff and make it better.
Lots of people get this confused.
0 Votes
+ -
Answer: They're not. Apple didn't invent the computer, the mp3 player, the tablet or the smartphone.

Why on earth can the sd card work in Android 2.x but not 3.x?
0 Votes
+ -
@bradavon
Hehe I used Android for a few months and had a lot of 'why on earth' questions lol
@bradavon: Apple Newton MessagePad from 1993 was the first tablet computer ever produced. And even though Newton became known as the first actual PDA (text-only keyboardy devices from 1990 can not compare), it was 800g-device that was the smallest of three form-factors that Apple developed since 1987 -- tablet computers.

With iPad, Apple reinvented its own invention.

With Apple II, Apple made first actual PC according to concept "what is PC" from ever since. Before Apple people had to make universal-purpose personal computers themselves, there was no such product. Or there were boxes with tumblers which had nothing to do with PC concept that Apple established from 1977: a desktop universal computer with uses keyboard and is connected to display device.

And, of course, Apple reinvented media players with iPod, with Click Wheel and whole songs management/purchase system.

And Apple reinvented smartphone with iPhone to allow finger/multitouch-based UI, actual WWW pages, etc.
0 Votes
+ -
@denisrs Typical reality distortion field nonsense...
Apple did NOT invent tablet computers.
Quote from actual history of tablet computers:
In 1989: "The first commercially available tablet-type portable computer was the GRiDPad[44] from GRiD Systems released in September."
The Poqet PC and NCR model 3125 also preceded the Apple Newton to market by several years, the latter arriving in 1991.
The Apple Newton didn't even enter development until 1991.

You are also incorrect about Apple making the first actual PC. Here is a quote from the history of personal computers: "The Kenbak-1 is considered by the Computer History Museum to be the world's first personal computer. It was designed and invented by John Blankenbaker of Kenbak Corporation in 1970, and was first sold in early 1971. "
In fact, ownership of Altair 8800s was already commonplace among computer hobbyists before the Apple 1 was even prototyped.

Spouting fiction zealously does not turn it into fact.
0 Votes
+ -
@BillDem: GRiDPad was 4.5 pounds monster that never went to mass production; the same is Poqet PC and NCR model 3125 -- and all of these were
"pen computers", not tablets . What Apple was doing was the actual tablet with mobile OS and mobile CPU in mind and it was working on it since 1987 (not 1991; and no wonder, since tablets' conceptual father Alan Kay worked at Apple). The ARM CPUs appeared because of Apple's wish to have a mobile CPU for Newton: in 1989, Apple found UK's desktop Acorn CPUs and wanted to scale it down to mobile versions and that is how ARM was created (similarly, Apple wanted to scale down IBM's Power CPUs and this is how PowerPC appeared -- both ARM and PowerPC now selling hundreds of millions units per year).

As to PC thing, are you sure you have read what I was writing? No one in their right mind would consider box with tumblers (Kenbak-1, Altair 8800) as "PC" by today's standards.

As I wrote, PC -- is universal desktop computer that works with keyboard and display. Before Apple II, there were either sets of "make yourself from the spareparts" or boxes with tumblers, which have nothing to do with anything recognizable as PC. There were also minicomputers, which are not PCs, and mainframe thin clients, which are not PCs, and floortop workstations like Xerox Alto, that are not PCs. All of these devices do not match to the definition.

Considering Kenbak-1 as "first PC" actually hilariously stupid -- not only because it is nothing like PC, but also because electronic watches from 1970 were programmable to "ring" at certain time -- and thus these watches are already "first PC" by that strange criteria that allowed Kenbak-1 to be considered as "first PC".
0 Votes
+ -
@denisrs

BS
?1956 RAND tablet ... invention of the digitizing tablet, for a handwriting recognition project.
(Actualy the Stylator came first!)
?1957 T.L. Dimond, "Reading Handwritten Characters", EJCC Claimed 97% recognition rate, and a better input device for humans than a keyboard
?1962 Masterson and Hirsch, IRE Transactions on Human Factors and Electronics
99.79% correct recognition.
?1962 J.C.R. Licklider, "On-line Man-computer Communication", SJCC
?1961/3 Sitari, Harmon, Frishkopf, et al cursive script recognition at Bell Labs
?1966 Groner et al, "GRAIL System", RAND Corporation Text/character recognition, gesture commands, sketch recognition

All of these were precursers to tablets ....
@noagenda
@bradavon
They didn't. But pick any Apple device and it's better than any other competing product. And very often the best selling too. Even iPhone 3GS outsells any Android-powered phone model in the US by a zip code. Tablet market is an iPad market, media player market is owned by iPod touch and same goes for MP3 players.

But... I discovered yesterday that a colleague of mine has a San Disk player. It was like seeing an ET.
0 Votes
+ -
For the record Scott, this is where it begins! Within 3 weeks we will see SD Card Support and Netflix on Honeycomb... In June or July 4G hits and the Ad Campaign thrn takes it to Apple.

You guys think I'm kidding? Youtube on the XOOM is the best I have seen on any mobile device (it used to be horrible) and now it might be the top app! Video Streaming with Flash ot through Google's product are excellent as well! Netflix (just the beta XOOM app) is already much more well conceived than the iOS App.
0 Votes
+ -
@Peter Perry

So when it goes nowhere in July and August, will you finally shut up?
0 Votes
+ -
@DeusXMachina It's kind of like how the Android Army of tablets was coming by summer 2010 and the iPad would be toast by the end of the year. We heard all that last year and again this year but it's changed to 2011.

I find it amazing that streaming Youtube videos is such a major selling point. Do people really waste that much time everyday on Youtube that it's of any importance what so ever? Between Mr Perry's fandroid love fest postings and his apparent addiction to Youtube he certainly couldn't be holding down a job, there just isn't enough time in the day.
You guys are so desperate to knock iOS it's ludicrous. iDevices are still the most practical and reliable in the market, and great value for money.
0 Votes
+ -
what about on a desktop?
mralbanydave 13th May 2011
Has anyone tried it on a desktop as a second boot?
0 Votes
+ -
Another Question
Hasam1991 13th May 2011
How is Google making money off Android??? with Apple you are paying upfront for something... 200 for iphone, 500 for ipad etc. But Android is free, when I bought my phone from Tmo, Samsung probably made money... not Google...

AND Again don't tell me ads, because I never really saw ads in Android other than in some free apps and I never ever clicked on an AD.
0 Votes
+ -
App store and search
Will Pharaoh 13th May 2011
@Hasam1991
but the problem is many are going after the free apps, and providers are changing the default search, so I think they're not making money anywhere near what they had hoped or calculated.
@Will Pharaoh
I think Google is confident in their search/advertising business and all they want is to keep an open platform so that consumers aren't forced into using product from competitors (which in turn forcing they out of Google products).
0 Votes
+ -
@anono Yeah, Google is doing it to give the world an open platform, nothing more than being generous. That was pretty funny, I needed that.
0 Votes
+ -
@Hasam1991 Google makes money with the built-in spyware and all the ad infected services they provide with the OS.
0 Votes
+ -
@Hasam1991 You do realize they get a 30% cut of all app sales and in-app purchases, right? And they still get paid for each ad impression, regardless if you click on it or not. Seriously, have you actually done ANY research on this topic, because you seem to have zero knowledge of Android or how advertising works on the web in general.
0 Votes
+ -
Yep. The freebies they passed out.
0 Votes
+ -
LOL! Everybody loves freebies!
Will Pharaoh 13th May 2011
@Userama
I'm no different!
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
RE: Android 3.1: Crowd-pleaser or heart-breaker?
Scott Raymond Updated - 13th May 2011
@Userama All high tech conferences give out "freebies". What do you think that $1500 pays for?
0 Votes
+ -
nope
banned from zdnet again and again 15th May 2011
@Scott Raymond
no freebies at wwdc. apple doesn't have to bribe it's developers.
0 Votes
+ -
Hey Scott ......
babyboomer57 Updated - 13th May 2011
Okay, i'm confused. What do you mean by 'can't access the SD card'. Are you telling me Astro or any of the other file managers could not read or work with the files on the card unless you rooted the tablet? I have the Iconia Tab with Honeycomb and not only does Astro work perfectly with the SD card, but the MM apps can access video/audio files on a USB drive. This sounds like a Motorola issue to me.

I fixed the crash issue with the browser by installing Dolphin HD. Works great. I am looking forward to the update to fix the Market crash problem. Both the Moto and Acer share that issue.

By the way, if you haven't found it yet, Weatherbug has a beta tablet version you can install. Search the Market for 'honeycomb' and it, along with all the other Honeycomb tablet apps show up, more than just the 'featured' apps on the Market start page. This version is much nicer than the old one.

And yes the Iconia can be rooted as well. Still waiting for a custom kernel so I can over clock this baby. Not that it isn't fast as hell now.

Enjoy your Xoom. I love my Iconia.
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
@babyboomer57 Yes, the SD card issue is a Motorola problem, and I'm not sure why they did it. However, the Tiamat kernel corrects that. I'm waiting for the next release so I can get access to the card again.

I have weatherbug, but I prefer to simply have weather as part of Fancy Widget.

At this point, I'm thinking the only tablet better than what we have now is the new Samsung Galaxy Tab running 3.1.
0 Votes
+ -
@babyboomer57 Here's the deal, the implementation of the SD Card in the Transformer and Iconia are hacks that most likely won't be compatible with Honeycomb going forward.

The XOOM is a Google Experience Device and their updates come straight from the Google Servers... When Google is done with it we'll get the SD card support as well.
0 Votes
+ -
Google can't be apple
rgor@... 13th May 2011
Google hates marketing. They can't stand it. If you read any interviews or blogs from ex-google employees you will see that they focused on engineering and algorithms. They focus seems to on converting all information into this planet into a numerical format.
They don't seem to understand that we need marketing to "sell" us on an item. If we were machines, then they would have a better chance of getting us to migrate to the cloud. As they are right now, they arouse too much mistrust and the company doesn't seem to understand the source of our fears.
0 Votes
+ -
Google hates marketing?????
Userama 13th May 2011
@rgor@...
Whoa! Just a sec here! Marketing (ads) is how Google makes 98% of their revenue. They may hate it, but it's what pays the bills and finances all their data suckers....er, I mean applications.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Android 3.1: Crowd-pleaser or heart-breaker?
anono Updated - 13th May 2011
@Userama
"finances all their data suckers....er, I mean applications."
Wow! seems like Facebook propaganda fooled a lot of people.
0 Votes
+ -
@Userama Providing the data to those that can use it to market is one thing and being able to market/good at marketing is another.
0 Votes
+ -
I have had the Asus Transformer 16gb/Wi-Fi only for the last 3 weeks. I also have had no experience with any Android version prior to buying the tablet.

I have NOT had any issues with the Honeycomb version that Asus packaged on their Transformer tablet. I use the Android Market and the browser frequently, and neither of them has had problems. I spend a lot of time on the tablet since I am learning my way around the limits of Android, and have been pleased with what I have found.

So, while 3.1 could have improvements to the 3.0 version, I am happy enough with 3.0, and look forward to further features.
0 Votes
+ -
help with dissertation
2r4racer 19th May
It is very nice to see this blog and it's really informative for the readers. It is really nice to see the best information presented in an easy and understanding manner.
Thank you.
help with dissertation

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix