Windows Phone 7: The Cialis of Smartphones?
Summary: If you suffer from chronic smartphone dysfunction, Windows Phone 7 may be for you.
If you suffer from chronic smartphone dysfunction, Windows Phone 7 may be for you.
Today I received a curious email. It was from my dad, a retired, 65-year old dentist who teaches at his local dental school in Southern Florida.
"Which is the best Android phone at AT&T?"
I was of course, perplexed.
Now, mind you, my father is as atypical a senior citizen as it gets -- this is a man who networked his entire condo with Wi-Fi using range extenders (with no help of my own) and customized his own La-z-Boy recliner to act as a computer workstation -- not a technology-averse person by any means whatsoever.
But he's never had any interest in having a smartphone, not at least until a few months ago, when I visited my parents and showed them my new iPad and my Motorola Droid, which has been serving me faithfully for about a year.
Had my father been a Verizon or a GMail user like myself, my response would have been fairly cut and dry -- get the Motorola Droid X, The HTC Droid Incredible or the Motorola Droid 2. Or if he was on T-Mobile, to get the new G2 or the Samsung Galaxy S. On Sprint, I'd probably recommend the Samsung Epic or the HTC EVO 4G.
But AT&T? Uh... The iPhone, I guess. But based on the god-awful things AT&T does to its Androids, such as loading them up with all sorts of extra carrier crap and ripping out Google search components, I'm not comfortable recommending any of them, and that includes the Samsung Captivate which is otherwise a pretty decent piece of hardware.
But then it dawned on me -- my dad is a Hotmail user.
Yes. Hotmail. I realize they're not the coolest of webmail providers, and they're not GMail, but they've got millions and millions of users. As does AOL Mail and Yahoo! Mail. And you know what? When it comes to integrating them with Android's email, calendar and contact management, they all suck, as do the 3rd-party solutions for attempting to make them work halfway decently on Android.
For all the techno-goodness that Android is, it is ultimately tied to GMail and Google services.
Simple, right? Just make grandma and grandpa switch to GMail, and hand them a shiny new Droid. Problem solved.
Uh, no.
Have you ever actually tried to make a Baby Boomer change their email address? Chances are, they've been using the same email provider since they've had dial-up. Yes, dial up, the way we used to get onto the Internet, with these things we used to call modems.
Also Read: Microsoft To Apple's iPhone and Google's Android -- Daddy's Home!
Although the wretched AOL software itself is now long gone, My Mother-in-Law still uses AOL Mail using their web interface, even though I told her it would be a simple matter of getting her contact list and importing it over to GMail, switching her over her mailbox to GMail with POP3, and sending out a broadcast message to her friends and family that she switched. You know what she told me? Forget it.
So my dad has Hotmail. He has AT&T. You know what? I think he'd be a good candidate for a Windows 7 Phone. And yes, I realize the iPhone can easily integrate with Hotmail, and all sorts of 3rd-party email services, but bear with me for a moment.
Why Microsoft? Windows Phone 7's got an easy-to-use interface with large tile visual icons and large text which might be appealing to someone that might be intimidated by something as sophisticated as a Droid or the iPhone, which can easily become a dizzying array of tiny icons and difficult to read text.
It's no wonder that older folks have chronic smartphone dysfunction.
A 65-year old who's never owned a smartphone device might be completely intimidated by an Android or an iOS device. Look, I'm only 41, I own a Droid and an iPad and find both platforms not particularly accessibility-friendly either.
And now that I've given it some thought, I think Microsoft should be thinking about positioning their product towards the just-retiring Boomer generation, rather than those Gen-Xers and Y-ers looking for the "Un-Android" or the "Anti-iPhone" --- which as far as I am concerned, is a demographic that does not exist. As I've said in the past, the smartphone market has chosen its technology leadership platforms, and Windows Phone isn't going to displace them.
Instead of Microsoft's marketing de-emphasis of 3rd-party Apps (well, because the platform doesn't have any yet) and spending less time with the smartphone and getting on with one's busy life as depicted in their latest commercials, I think they should be putting ads for Windows Phone 7 in TV spots for shows that "younger" Seniors watch and magazines that age demographic reads, and getting into bed with Boomer and Senior-friendly companies like AARP.
The same sort of shows and magazines that have Cialis commercials. Seriously.
Sounds nuts? Do you have any idea of how many Baby Boomers there are? If we're talking about age 65 and older, it's about 13 percent of the US population. That's not insignificant if we consider that as a whole, the population of the US is growing older. When you consider that most smartphone products are being marketed towards a younger generation of buyers, it leaves open a considerable marketing opportunity for a company like Microsoft that the others might not be addressing.
If I were Microsoft, I'd make absolutely sure that Windows Phones are everywhere that people 55 and older can find them, that patient and helpful salespeople at retailers and carrier stores are there to demo them, and that the devices are compatible and easy to configure with the email services that these seniors and Boomers use today.
Could Windows Phone 7 be the Smartphone platform for the Boomer Generation? Talk Back and Let Me Know.
Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.
Talkback
Windows Phone 7 should be given to geriatrics
RE: Windows Phone 7: The Cialis of Smartphones?
I also doubt that many people pay AT&T extra to get tethering anyway.
RE: Windows Phone 7: The Cialis of Smartphones?
Amen. Enough with the tethering.
Give it a break. WP7 is for propeller heads that are uncertain about their
The large icons might appeal to senior citizens as well.
RE: Windows Phone 7: The Cialis of Smartphones?
Did they say Jan 2011 or early 2011 for C&P?
@Dave95
There is no specific date. Early 2011 is all we know right now.
But they seemed to make a not of it release day, as it is their biggest complaint, so I would expect to see the update sooner rather than later.
RE: Windows Phone 7: The Cialis of Smartphones?
Mr Market Analyst may or may not be a troll, but really, relying on a "promise" from Microsoft is truly foolish (copy/paste).
Microsoft's history is simply to say whatever they think is politically expedient at the moment. Inaccurate propaganda is dished up with gusto, and MS does not care whether what they say is true and accurate.
http://www.zdnet.com/blog/microsoft/microsoft-tried-to-muck-with-anti-linux-facts/235?tag=mantle_skin;content
http://www.informationweek.com/news/global-cio/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=197002546
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Halloween_documents_leak
Standard MSFT response....
:)
RE: Windows Phone 7: The Cialis of Smartphones?
Obviously Microsoft moved on from their strategies that they had during 90's, but it seems you didn't move on, when are ya?
RE: Windows Phone 7: The Cialis of Smartphones?
You do know that you're pointing at reports of documents written 12 and 8 years ago respectively, right? And that both were created before Microsoft spent 7 years under DOJ oversight. And that most of those involved have since left the company ... especially that incompetent idiot Allchin?
These documents and the practices they describe have anything to do with Microsoft today any more than IBM's involvement with the Nazi's have anything to do with the way that IBM operates today.
Oh ... my ... maybe I've stumbled across a new headline for a talented ZDNet blogger! Since one of the biggest contributors to Linux, Java and other OSS projects is IBM, maybe we'll see posts along the lines of "Linux - operating system for Nazis"?
Trolls
RE: Windows Phone 7: The Cialis of Smartphones?
Microsoft's internal culture and the 2007 anti trust conviction in the EU
I have kept my eyes open in the last decade.
Are you like most Microsoft folks and have assiduously looked away from all the information which came out in the last decade (as well as the prior decade) such as the anti trust conviction in the EU in 2007?
Microsoft has a truly bizarre cult like internal culture which makes them very carefully avoid looking at any of the information which has exposed the business practices of the company (as well as the performance behavior of the products).
This is hilariously exposed in the following link. This link directs you to a pro-Microsoft site advising folks on how to try to "partner" with Microsoft. It totally unintentionally depicts a very insular internal culture which is incapable of seeing any failing in the company, its products, or its business practices- and a culture that needs to be told that MS products are just the greatest, regardless of actual performance characteristics.
Its hilarious, I strongly recommend it
http://rcpmag.com/articles/2007/07/01/minding-your-microsoft-manners.aspx
My previous girlfriend was as MS MVP and I was continually stunned by how insular the otherwise nice and intelligent MS folks were. The story line I would get was nope, all those convictions were bad convictions by judges that just didn't understand the company.
While MS often hires intelligent people, the very few who have not drank the Microsoft KoolAid realize they are better off never criticizing anything MS, or being exceptionally careful in doing so because it could threaten their employment.
Also keep in mind that the Softies realize they have this problem- "drinking the KoolAid" is term widely used inside of MS - referring to folks who just bought into too much internal propaganda.
Here is another good source of insight into Microsoft's internal culture- the internal Microsoft blog, mini Microsoft. If you read the comments you will repeatedly hear stories of folks that dare not criticize anything
Microsoft no matter how flawed it may be.
http://minimsft.blogspot.com/
RE: Windows Phone 7: The Cialis of Smartphones?
Mmmm, tethering. I love tethering. Road trip! Tethering! Cable is out! Tethering! What is this pay extra nonsense, though? Has T-mob done something significantly better than its competitors? I'll be... Maybe I'll stick with them a little longer, then.
i have to agree....
As for DonnieBoy, i think with comments like yours you should be banned from ZDnet period!... Using such comments to describe the general user of a MS product is unforgivable.
People in general should be respected unless they provide you reason not to be and you certainly gave us all reason not to respect your opinion. I usually dont attack people's character as a whole but this time you went too far (gentialia comments belong in uneducated public forums).
RE: Windows Phone 7: The Cialis of Smartphones?
RE: Windows Phone 7: The Cialis of Smartphones?
RE: Windows Phone 7: The Cialis of Smartphones?
Dumpp Att and Verizon and go with a real phone company. I have NEVER hand any connectivity issues with TMobile throu all my cross country travels to back-woods, out of the norm places such as Bailey NC.
RE: Windows Phone 7: The Cialis of Smartphones?
from first hand experience i can tell you that a small amount of people come into an at&t store and ask about tethering.
when people do ask, and they find about about the data cap and price, they say forget it.
RE: Windows Phone 7: The Cialis of Smartphones?
Actually, while he IS rather lame, he does get a point for the lack of tethering. It's why I won't be getting a WP7 phone until they add this feature. I use tethering all the time.
That being said - I don't know too many other people who do that - so yeah, not a big deal to the vast majority.