Zillow: Welcome to Whoville, where everyone knows your property value

Zillow: Welcome to Whoville, where everyone knows your property value

Summary: Zillow, a new real-estate search service, offers astonishingly deep insight into local markets and individual lives. This is a good thing with all sorts of potential negative costs that will have some folks howling.

TOPICS: Nasa / Space

Zillow logoI'm flabbergated. Zillow.com, which launched today, told me a lot I did not know about my local real estate market.

Zillow just obsoleted the local realtor as a necessary category of professional, leaving home owners in a much better position to pick and judge the performance of a realtor. I used to have to count on a realtor for information about the cost of homes or just an idea about whether my house is still a good investment.A clever and useful mash-up of mapping, satellite imagery, public records and information traditionally hidden from home buyers and sellers. It will certainly scare the bejeezus out of real estate professionals and privacy hawks, because with a few keystrokes and a little mousing, you can find out the price and history of about two-thirds of the single-family home in the United States.

First, the review of the interface: Phenomenal. A clever and useful mash-up of mapping, satellite imagery, public records and other information that has traditionally been hidden from the view of home buyers and sellers. Enter an address (Here's a house I sold last year) and Zillow returns an image of the neighborhood where the home is located, along with an estimated current value (my current home was appraised last year and Zillow's estimate is a bit low, but on the old house, it is both very high and does not reflect that we sold it last year for $95,000 less than the Zillow estimate), the number of bedrooms, bathrooms, and square footage.

But what's that around the house you searched for? The prices of nearby homes are displayed. Click on any of them and you get the same information and the ability to drill deeper. Want to find out if I have a fireplace, or if the neighbor does? It's there, along with the property taxes paid.

Also available are comparable home prices, the history of the home itself—when it was built, updated, and much more—along with the same details for other homes in the neighborhood in the same price range. 

It's an astonishing tool for quickly assessing the value of a home, whether you are buying it or selling it. I can't imagine getting involved in a real estate transaction ever again without using this tool, because it takes formerly difficult to find and understand information and creates context that is completely illustrated with facts.

Before you panic about your privacy, this data is all available from your local assessor's public records. Here, for example, is the public record of the same home as linked to above, which reflects that we did sell it last year. And, as I said, the Zillow estimate on the value of the home is so far off from the actual sale price that it makes me question the methodology and the system's capacity for "real-time" pricing. But there is nothing new here that I was hiding before.

Am I frightened that people will use Zillow to intrude on my privacy? No. They could do it before, though it took more work. And I am comfortable that, when I do decide to sell my home the buyer will be equipped with information to offer me a fair, rather than an outrageously high or low, price. Welcome to the no-haggle era of housing pricing. 

This is an incredible step forward in market transparency. Just being able to look at comparable costs without first getting hooked up with a realtor is something revolutionary.

Yet, it is also a form of data porn that can create irrational pricing pressure in the market, exaggerating the market cycle. For example, I can see this driving the housing bubble further and faster, because the home details interface of Zillow displays a one-week change in value for a home. According to Zillow, that house I sold last year is worth $3,424 more than last week. It tells me that my current home is worth $5,849 more than a week ago. If I were to actually use this tool to calculate my worth, it would be deeply misleading.

It's clear that home equity mortgages will be one of the first prominently advertised offerings on Zillow. We should avoid compulsively checking our home equity value like it was a stock.

Lest we get carried away about the values of our homes any more than we already are, Zillow's also a tool for checking our financial expectations, if we choose to use it that way, as well as keeping tabs on the Jones' property value. From now on, the kind of house we live in will be easily accessible rather than hidden in public records, which is why we'll want to have a Zillow on the pillow when thinking about the market.

What we really need now is a Zillow for commerical and rental properties, so that renters and small business have better insight into the profits landlords take out of their hide. That'd be some market disrupter, too. 

Topic: Nasa / Space

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


Log in or register to join the discussion
  • Not even close

    I looked up my home, and the description was not even right. I owwn a 4 bd 2.5 bath 1.5 story - Zillow's description is 3 bd 3 ba 1 story. I know the public record is correct, so I'm not sure where they are getting their data, but if the home description isn't even right, then they won't last long.
    • Agreed, but the feature set is a market-changer

      The data quality is a serious problem, because the company has to
      rely on third parties, thousands of county governments, for the
      information. I wonder if people will actually use the modify this
      listing feature?

      Nevertheless, the prospect of having even roughly accurate
      information?for the realtor's information we've paid for is just as
      bad?is a profound change in transparency.
      Mitch Ratcliffe
  • This is another case of a company capitalizing on information that is free,

    In Nassau County, Long Island, New York, where I live, there is: http://www.nassaucountyny.gov/ncasmt/security/protected/property_search_result.jsp
    Try entering ?Main Street? or any street that might exist and you can drill down to surveys, tax rates and government estimates of any house?s resale value; even recent pictures of the property. It?s very accurate, most taxing authorities have something similar.

    www.Zillow.com is embarrassingly inaccurate everywhere I tried it (for the record: I do not work or invest in Real Estate). In the government-supplied site I mention above for example, most homes that sold for about a million dollars are shown in Zillow.com as costing only $2,000.00.

    The difference between commercial (web or not) information services and free government information is that government authorities are at best indifferent about promulgating certain information to their constituency and are even less concerned about providing information to the public at large. Sometimes, they are even disinclined to promote the availability of information that they are statutorily obligated to provide: such as specific dollar amounts of a projected tax increase or notices of public hearings about objectionable variances. Commercial re-sellers of free government information are the profiteers of this political reality.

    Most services or their sites selling (or ?giving away,? but with advertising) information that is publicly available are cheating an uninformed public. Often their only service is misdirection. They are shills for their paying advertisers. The only ?value added? by the more reputable services is convenience, but if this service results in you buying the wrong house, then this ?free service? comes at a very high price.

    This blog?s name is ?Rational Rants? so I don?t know why a post about Zillow.com is even on it but, in the spirit of ?Rational Ranting? let me close with a short rant: This post reads nothing like a blog post, but shameless, tacky advertising copy.