Programmer gets del.irio.us about del.icio.us

Programmer gets del.irio.us about del.icio.us

Summary: Last week's debut of del.irio.us, which is essentially an open source knock-off of the social bookmarking site, del.

SHARE:
TOPICS: Open Source
1

Last week's debut of del.irio.us, which is essentially an open source knock-off of the social bookmarking site, del.icio.us, did not go over lightly for many partial to the incumbent's folksonomy/tagging service. Stephen O'Grady, a RedMonk analyst (and a del.icio.us user), points to a thread on the del.icio.us mailing list where Steve Mallet, the programmer behind del.irio.us, is under attack. O'Grady pinpoints several issues that the clone raises, such as questioning how long will open source development remain a competitive differentiator, and the potential for the newcomer to fracture the tagging community. The bottom line:

All in all, I think this example highlights the fact that there are right and wrong ways to clone applications or services; or maybe that's wrong - there are righter and wronger ways if not an absolute black/white determination. I think the degree to which del.irio.us flatly copied much of the del.icio.us design is not entirely appropriate, but at least in the short term I don't expect it to make much difference.

What do you think? Could have Steve Mallet created a similar service without much copying, or is the del.icio.us UI the optimal de facto standard?

Topic: Open Source

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

1 comment
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • My response....

    You'll see <a href="http://lists.del.icio.us/pipermail/discuss/2005-March/002472.html">here</a> on the delicious list where I state I went for the UI. You'll also notice no one refuted that as good. A few in fact say as you did above that the UI is familiar and good.

    There are always sour grapes. I don't see anyone complaining about yahoo, MSN, etc etc following google search engine UI choices. I'm just the first in this case.
    stevemallett