Google Copies Bing. There. I Said It.

By | November 9, 2010, 12:12pm PST

Summary: Google copies Bing. Disagree? Have a look and tell me what you think!

First, it was with their sidebar on the left. Next, it was having a wallpaper on your home page. Then, it was testing full-screen results. After that, it was showing results that included social data in an incredibly similar way to Bing (in relation to the recent announcement of Bing and Facebook being in cahoots but not to be confused with Google Social Search). Now, Google appears to be rolling out visual previews (called “instant previews”) of sites such that users can see them prior to clicking through to them. Personally, I think Google’s rendition of the feature is quite nice but it lets me know that we shouldn’t be so quick to count out Bing.

Now, I know that some — if not most — of you just looooove to hate on Bing, but there is absolutely no doubt that they’re getting a lot of things *right* in Google’s eyes and that’s the important thing to consider here. While I will be the first to say that I love Google for its search capabilities and I’ve yet to find a search engine that comes even remotely close to giving me the ability to drill down into results the depth and breadth of Google’s index, I think it’s time for some competition and innovation to happen in the search space.

I know that some of you are going to point out the ever-present “Microsoft copies Apple” debate, but this is different (unlike Apple’s users who are actually all thinking exactly the same when they buy into Apple’s products and marketing).

 

;)

Seriously, though, I think it’s time to stop hating Bing just because XYZ internet persona you know and love hates Bing. Here’s a novel concept: Instead of just hating on Bing and saying, “their search engine results suck,” why not actually try out Bing and then provide some *constructive* feedback? I know their search engine results are lacking for some of you, but when was the last time you actually gave Bing a shot? After taking a look at some search results today on Bing, I think they’re coming along quite well!

Now, you may say to yourself, “I’m not going to do that because I’m perfectly fine with using Google.” If that’s the case, then that’s great and I urge you to stay on your path. But if you happen to be like me and you’re excited at the prospect of just how deep Internet search still needs to go to provide adequate information based on extensive investigation, then Bing just might be the team you need to speak to. Between the two companies, I would wager that Bing is more eager to listen to the requests and constructive criticism of users than Google is right now. I may be completely off-base on that, but, hey… it’s been known to happen before. :)

Oh, and what about Yahoo? Well, you may not realize this, but Yahoo uses Bing’s search results now. No, seriously. If you love searching Yahoo but you say Bing sucks, then you just got busted for fruitlessly hating on Bing! Don’t believe me? Compare this (Bing) to this (Yahoo) and see for yourself. Yes, even image searches between the two are exactly the same (Bing Image Search and Yahoo Image Search).

And despite the competition, Bing still puts Google on quite the pedestal if you search for Google:

Much nicer and far more useful to the end-user than this, that’s for sure:

Anyway, I’m a realist. I know that companies are going to copy other companies in some capacity and that there’s a certain amount of innovation and implementation overlap that’s inevitable — much like when one hit song contains the same chord progression as another hit song. What I’m gleaning from this particular instance of Google taking from the pages of Bing is that we may want to start paying more attention to Bing. At the end of the day, the only thing Google may not use from Bing is their search algorithm because it’s not public and I’m sure Google is quite confident in their own. Everything else appears to be fair game, though.

Now, what do you think? Hammer me with your worst insults! Take your horrible day out on me! :D

*”Think different” image courtesy of http://rubasu.deviantart.com/art/Think-Different-5-100352943.

-Stephen Chapman
SEO Whistleblower

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

Stephen is a freelance writer based in Charlotte, NC.

Disclosure

Stephen Chapman

Stephen Chapman is a freelance writer and content strategist. All work that Stephen does for ZDNet is on a contractual basis.

It is left to Stephen's discretion whether or not to accept assignments from prospective clients who discover him through ZDNet. Such endeavors have no association with ZDNet and, unless otherwise agreed upon, are kept separate and private in the interest of all parties involved. You may freely contact him for consulting, training, and/or public speaking inquiries.

While Stephen may accept complimentary passes, waived fees, payment, and/or covered travel costs to industry-related events (conferences, expos, etc.) as an attendee or a speaker, acceptance of such offers is not considered payment for, or exclusive guarantee of, any particular blog coverage of the event attended.

Biography

Stephen Chapman

Stephen is a freelance writer based in Charlotte, NC.
50
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

Google Copies Bing Again
Karthikeyankc 6 days ago
Google is scared of Bing's New Social search!! lol
Juz found that google is experimenting the New Bing kinda search... I busted it accidentally and exposed it in ma blog happy
http://geekswipe.blogspot.in/2012/05/new-bing-stirrs-up-google-google.html
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Google Copies Bing. There. I Said It.
jspignardo@... 9th Nov 2010
It is about time that someone in the media recognizes this! Despite all the naysayers this has been a banner year for Microsoft in the innovation column. For years they've cranking out the same staid money makers. Now competition has got them back on their toes. From Zune to Xbox to WP7 to Windows 7 to Bing to Live Services, MS is battling back. But is anyone listening. Probably why Google can ape them without any fear of lash back.
0 Votes
+ -
@jspignardo@...

MS innovation? Hardly.

Zune is Dead
WP 7 is DOA
Win 7 - was going to be a hit no matter what.
Bing = Boing - DOA - only reason it has any marketshare is because it's the default in IE 7/8.

MS wouldn't know innovation if it B!tch Slapped them across the face.
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
RE: Google Copies Bing. There. I Said It.
StephenChapman Updated - 9th Nov 2010
@itguy08

Zune : Definitely dead, but it was a great product despite that fact.

WP7 : DOA? Where the heck did you pull that from? Oh, I know where. Never mind.

Win 7 : Oh, was it? Because the last I checked, the guys like you who gripe about Microsoft were SOOO sure that Windows 7 was "just another Windows Vista." I guess hindsight is 20/20 for you hecklers, huh? wink

Bing: Do you have any unbiased reports that back up this mighty tall (and mighty repetitive amongst your crowd) claim of yours?

Truth is, you wouldn't know Microsoft's innovation if it "b!tch-slapped" you across the face because you appear to have your head buried in the same place you pulled your WP7 "DOA" opinion from!

OHHHH SNAP! wink

-Stephen
0 Votes
+ -
Yup. MS copied the idea for Kinect
John Zern 9th Nov 2010
from Apple, Nintendo, and Sony!

And the HD and HD radio in iPods are so much better then the Zune's!

Win 7 was the next "Vista" acording to you!

Bing is rising, and getting good feedback because it's so much worse then all the others. It's not like Google is the default search in Android, or anything.

Yeah, your undies are about ready for a change, as they have to be pretty soiled at this point.
0 Votes
+ -
@StephenChapman

WP7: 40k on launch day says it all. Nobody wants it. Droid X sold out within hours, iPhone sold out within hours, Evo sold out within hours. I could go on and on. Yet MS can barely sell 40k?

Win7: I never said it would be another Vista. But if you look at the business upgrade cycle, it makes sense. Like most skipped WinME. It's not that good (I know, I run it occasionally in a VM), but Good Enough.

Bing: Seriously on any new install of Windows or IE 7/8 it sets Live as the default search. You have to jump through hoops to change that. Most won't. I know many that still want MSN as their "Homepage". Same with how IE got huge market share in the beginning - it was there by default. Not because it's good.
giving out coupons to appologize for not having enough. you're still living in 08 itguy. now would be a good time for you to go upstairs and ask your mom if you can have a cookie.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Google Copies Bing. There. I Said It.
d.j.elliott@... 12th Nov 2010
@itguy08
Hating Microsoft is practically a national IT pastime. Fact is, MS has lasted more than 30 years which is a lot longer than many other companies. If they went out of business today, they'd have a place in computing history.
0 Votes
+ -
@jspignardo@...

Switched to Bing some time ago. We have daily use for internet search and I'm quite happy with Bing. I'm also happier to use a search engine from a software developer than an advertising company.

Now I have my WP7 as well, and I won't be changing its default.

No amount of real data and facts is ever going to change an ABM fanboi's mind. However, you can tell when an MS product is excellent, they just get even more whiny and belligerent.
0 Votes
+ -
@tonymcs@... Google is actually a search company that also does Ads.
0 Votes
+ -
Surely Google copies some of the display properties of Bing. But the core functionality of Google is superb. Even Bing trying to copy that from Google and still they are experimenting.
SEO India
0 Votes
+ -
The concept is good (and that't what Google copies), but the search engine results still suck.
Sorry, but it's true.
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
RE: Google Copies Bing. There. I Said It.
StephenChapman 9th Nov 2010
@drphysx Do you have some specific examples? Honestly, I couldn't think of anything a little while ago that resulted in horrendous results, so I would like to reach out to readers like you and find out what you search for that Bing provides such "sucky" results for. happy

-Stephen
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Google Copies Bing. There. I Said It.
drphysx Updated - 9th Nov 2010
@StephenChapman No, I set Bing as my default search engine for a few weeks, as one can certainly not come to any conclusions from just one or two searches.

Anyway, in the end, I switched back to Google and it's just so much more convenient, because somehow Google seems to know what I want and Bing doesn't.

With Google, I rarely have to look at page 2 results, because usually what I'm searching for is within the first ten results. Bing, on the other hand, displays lots of irrelevant results on page one and most of the time I had to go through five or more pages of search results in order to find what I was looking for (well, usually, when it wasn't on one of the first five pages, I simply went to Google, which usually showed me what I was looking for on page 1).

I'm not saying Bing is a failure or that it won't get better. Some people may actually like it (although market share trends suggest otherwise). Try it for yourself.

The problem is, by the time Bing's search results get useful, Google will most likely have copied all the great concepts that Bing introduced. wink
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Google Copies Bing. There. I Said It.
drphysx Updated - 9th Nov 2010
@StephenChapman OK, just gave Bing one more try.

I searched for a paper on solid state physics by a professor named Rudolf Gross, in German.

I typed "gross festkoerperphysik".

Of course, Bing didn't "get" that I was searching for a professor named Gross, instead of the German word for 'big'.

So, what did I get? Lots of irrelevant results and the paper I was looking for was nowhere to be found, on the first ten pages.

So I gave up. Fired up Google. Typed "gross festkoerperphysik", again.

Where's the paper? First page. BOOM.

Sorry, Bing.
0 Votes
+ -
@drphysx - erm ... do you mean the paper on "Determination of high Qbeta-values by beta-gamma-coincidence"?

I just typed "gross festkoerperphysik" into Bing and this was the title of the first result.

The second result points here: "http://www.uni-tuebingen.de/en/faculties/mathematics-and-physics/institutes/physikalisches-institut/festkoerperphysik/publikationen/1992.html"

The third points here:
"http://www.uni-tuebingen.de/publikationen/1989.html"

And so on...

All the above links have cached copies too in case the site is down.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Google Copies Bing. There. I Said It.
Loverock Davidson 9th Nov 2010
Should come as no surprise. I've been saying all Google does is copy for years. When they released that preview I was thinking to myself how Bing already had that. I like how Bing is the thorn in Google's side happy
0 Votes
+ -
I gave Bing a shot
HollywoodDog 9th Nov 2010
At the Bellagio, I went to the concierge desk with the 3 people I was with to ask for printed directions to a restaurant. The woman used Bing. We gave the address, she printed a map and directions.

When handed to me it looked wrong - the directions took us to the airport and terminated at it.

I felt like something was wrong, but drove out there anyway. Stopping outside the perimeter fence, we stood there looking across active runways with jets landing, where Bing said the restaurant was supposed to be.

It took us an hour to inch back up the strip. We phoned for directions and it was actually close to Bellagio. We went to dinner, late as it was, and things were fine after that, but it was a frustrating, agonizing hour stuck in traffic before we arrived.

Obviously Bing didn't know where the place was, so it defaulted to the airport.

When an official from Microsoft compensates me for my lost hour due to their incompetence, I will consider using it once again.
0 Votes
+ -
Wow, that is an unbelievable story!
NonZealot 9th Nov 2010
@HollywoodDog
Seriously and literally, that is an unbelievable story!

But it does remind me about this one time that the exact same thing happened to me when using Google Maps on my friend's iPhone. When are Apple and Google going to reimburse me for my 2 lost hours?
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
RE: Google Copies Bing. There. I Said It.
StephenChapman Updated - 9th Nov 2010
@NonZealot Nice one. =) I've been saying the same thing about AOL and Mapquest for years! lol. (Not really)
0 Votes
+ -
For a second there I thought...
zkiwi 9th Nov 2010
You'd had an epiphany and realized that you post the unbelievable and claim it's reasonable/factual. Ah well...
0 Votes
+ -
@HollywoodDog - interesting. So what was the name of the restaurant?
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
RE: Google Copies Bing. There. I Said It.
StephenChapman 9th Nov 2010
@bitcraed And the name of the hotel the lady looked up the directions for, too! Let's reproduce this. =)
0 Votes
+ -
@HollywoodDog i believe you buddy! BING SUCKS.
0 Votes
+ -
@HollywoodDog ROFL, if it didn't look right then why did you drive out there?
0 Votes
+ -
Google is not an innovative company
iPad-awan 9th Nov 2010
Google has always copied Apple, now it copying Microsoft. I won't be surprised if Google copies AOL next.
0 Votes
+ -
@iPad-awan What are you smoking?
0 Votes
+ -
Google copying something... now that's just silly
Michael Alan Goff 9th Nov 2010
I mean.... just look at their android OS. It isn't like they copied anything to make th- oh.

Okay, maybe they copy every once in a while.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Google Copies Bing. There. I Said It.
drphysx Updated - 9th Nov 2010
@goff256 Are you kidding? Android couldn't be much more different from any other mobile OS.

Compare it to iOS, for example. The home screen works completely different, notifications work completely different, data syncing works completely different, multitasking works completely different...

There's hardly anything they could do except for a paint job in order to make Android any more different from all the other mobile operating systems out there.

I mean, other companies just give things a different look, rename some things (widgets to tiles for example) and sell it as something new...
0 Votes
+ -
@drphysx - Android is Linux in a pretty dress. Or do you believe that Google wrote Android from scratch? If so, then I have this lovely bridge you might want to buy.
0 Votes
+ -
Android isn't original
Michael Alan Goff 9th Nov 2010
What's so original about a Linux Distribution (old hat) added with what they stole from Oracle for Dalvik? Is there anything really original about it? Maybe it LOOKS unique. But if you go by appearances, then you have a really messed up metric for new.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Google Copies Bing. There. I Said It.
drphysx Updated - 10th Nov 2010
@bitcrazed Of course it's Linux, but I hope you realize that this wasn't the point at all.

I was talking about how Android works in use, compared to other operating systems. The concepts behind the UI etc., which couldn't be much more different from other systems.

That has little to do with its Linux core.
0 Votes
+ -
I forgot about that wackoe
Michael Alan Goff 10th Nov 2010
They -did- buy Android, didn't they?
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Google Copies Bing. There. I Said It.
mary.branscombe 9th Nov 2010
I ended up switching to Bing by accident while testing multiple Windows 7 machines; as I tested each new machine I reset default search to Google when I didn't get the results I needed. And somewhere along the line I stopped resetting the default because I was getting the results I needed - and it took me about a week to notice I'd forgotten to switch...
0 Votes
+ -
@mary.branscombe - specific examples of searches that don't show up on Bing please - claims of "I didn't get the results I needed" will be met with the derision they deserve.
0 Votes
+ -
@mary.branscombe
That and because Google tends to steal personal data.
0 Votes
+ -
Not true.
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
RE: Google Copies Bing. There. I Said It.
StephenChapman 10th Nov 2010
@james347 True.
0 Votes
+ -
i went to ask.com and typed "when is bing gonna follow?"
0 Votes
+ -
And that...
charaze 9th Nov 2010
And that proves, Google isn't the king of the internet. It may be popular, but if you're the lord of everything, why copy others, right? Or in this case, why copy other websites and its features?

http://educationflat.com
0 Votes
+ -
you know bing copied google first right?
Seriously, the pictures claiming that Google copied from Bing are of features that Google had YEARS before Bing was even invented (actually named ... since it is a re-branding of the old MSN/Live search with a background picture).
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
RE: Google Copies Bing. There. I Said It.
StephenChapman Updated - 10th Nov 2010
@wackoae The pictures I provided weren't to show anyone copying from the other, but rather how each of their top search results appear when searched for one another in their respective search engines.

Bings results look much more attractive and provide more data and functionality with those results than Google currently does with theirs.

As for Bing, it actually isn't a re-branded MSN/Live search. It's a completely new product with new search algorithms and everything. All while MSN/Live was still Microsoft's search engine, they were developing "Kumo" which was the codename for Bing. Just FYI.

-Stephen
0 Votes
+ -
uh
sportmac 10th Nov 2010
where are the articles called "microsoft copies (insert darn near anything), there i said it"?
0 Votes
+ -
Nevermind....
storm14k 10th Nov 2010
the fact that Bing had to first copy Google Search to get anywhere lol. How about instead of asking from constructive criticism on why people say Bing sucks you ask for reasons why Bing may be better. I mean it is Bing that has to gain the users right? I have yet to see anyone actually show me whats better about it. I see people pull up searches on both and say "see Bing is better" but its the same search results on both. You even did it in your article. The results are the same but Bing has a search box (something I've seen Google have for other sites) and the stock quotes which Google also does for companies. Remember Bing is not a company but Google is. If you want people to switch then seriously...show us whats better. Don't put up results that are just slightly different and then say "see Bing is better".

I bet there won't be an article like this when Bing adds instant search.
0 Votes
+ -
As in evidence here, a lot of people hate Bing because they hate Microsoft. That, of course, is as stupid as it gets.

I've tried some Bing searches, and found the results to be less useful than Google's. But I do, and will, try it once in a while to see if it offers anything to make it better than Google.

See, I judge a product by its usefulness, not by what company produced it. What a concept, huh.
0 Votes
+ -
I'm getting very poor results when searching for Egg Salad Ice Cream. Stupid Bing.
0 Votes
+ -
Message has been deleted.
myclub Updated - 6th Jul
0 Votes
+ -
lonzchb 85 hzn
dmakrejktt20-24379071982088446065530010994651 25th Nov
gnxdun,qnhkrcpk42, ojexj.
0 Votes
+ -
Google Copies Bing Again
Karthikeyankc 6 days ago
Google is scared of Bing's New Social search!! lol
Juz found that google is experimenting the New Bing kinda search... I busted it accidentally and exposed it in ma blog happy
http://geekswipe.blogspot.in/2012/05/new-bing-stirrs-up-google-google.html

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix