NIST definition of cloud computing doesn't go far enough

NIST definition of cloud computing doesn't go far enough

Summary: The National Institute of Standards and Technology published its 16th and final definition of cloud in September. A great resource for government agencies, but businesses may need something more strategic and less tactical.


What is cloud computing again? Dave Linthicum revisited this question, observing that many people are referencing the cloud definition established at the US federal government level, by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST).

NIST admits that it has published no less than 16 updates to the definition, with its final definition published in September 2011. In short, NIST defines cloud this way:

"Cloud computing is a model for enabling ubiquitous, convenient, on-demand network access to a shared pool of configurable computing resources (e.g., networks, servers, storage, applications and services) that can be rapidly provisioned and released with minimal management effort or service provider interaction."

Not enough, Dave says. And I agree. NIST's definition is intended for government agencies, which have different motives -- mainly efficiency -- for turning to cloud. On the business side, cloud may mean entire new business models, a platform that can launch new lines of business.

A report from The Economist Intelligence Unit and IBM finds that among 572 business leaders surveyed, almost three-fourths indicate their companies have piloted, adopted or substantially implemented cloud in their organizations – and 90% expect to have done so in three years. However, the report’s authors, Dr. Saul Berman, Lynn Kesterson-Townes, Anthony Marshall, and Dr. Rohini Srivathsa, all with IBM, suggest that few companies -- only 16% of respondents -- see cloud as enhancing companies' opportunities for "sweeping innovation, such as entering new lines of business or industries, reshaping an existing industry or transitioning into a new role in their industry value chain.”

Designing new products and services in the cloud is one example. For example, Apple's Siri, the cloud-based natural-language intelligent assistant on the Apple iPhone 4S, enables users to send messages, schedule meetings, place phone calls, find restaurants and more, employs artificial intelligence and a growing knowledge base about the user to understand not only what is said but what is meant. “In a nutshell, it leverages the computing capabilities and capacity of cloud to enable individualized, context-relevant customer experiences.”

Dave notes that "so many design and architectural patterns are emerging around the concept of cloud computing that it's difficult to fit everything into NIST's definition. I'm counting well past 100."  The problem is that it is a tactical definition, versus its ultimate value, "sharing solutions and pushing risk out of the business."

Ultimately, the term may disappear, vendors will move on to hyping the next big thing, and we'll remove the "cloud" from "cloud computing" as it simply becomes a ubiquitous method by which applications and services are assembled and accessed.  For example, who talks about "desktop computing" or "web-based applications" any more? We're already getting close to that point.

Topics: Cloud, Apple, Hardware, IBM, iPhone, Servers, Smartphones, Storage

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


Log in or register to join the discussion
  • re:

    "What is cloud computing again?"

    Apparently a word only NIST can truly define -_-. Everybody else has their own fuzzy vision of what they think it is. Personally, I've always disliked using the word because it really has no meaning.

    "For example, who talks about 'desktop computing' or 'web-based applications' any more?"

    Who ever used "desktop computing"? I don't recall that much usage of that term to begin with.

    And most of your article is "we innovate, therefore the definition of the word 'cloud' is inaccurate"? I don't quite follow that logic. How does innovation change the definition of a word?

    "Ultimately, the term may disappear"

    Frankly, I wish it were never invented. It was always a really bad term. It had no purpose. It was basically there for marketing types as a catchy word to sell new products, and for tech news to overuse and overhype.
  • Defining cloud

    For IT leaders the definition of cloud should be a flexible, scaleable platform designed to help the organization innovate and achieve strategic goals. Unfortunately with all the vendors in the mix each with their own "cloud" offering, the definition of cloud is often quite murky.