Opt out of 60 ad networks in 3 minutes

By | October 26, 2010, 7:45am PDT

Did you know that 60 ad networks may be tracking you right now? And may be selling personally identifiable details about you? The good news: you can opt out of these networks in less than 3 minutes. Here’s how.

Forget about privacy?
Online behavior tells a great deal about us: our food likes; the car we drive; our income level; religion; gender; sexual preferences; diseases; job status; and, how many and how old our children are. Traditionally, we’ve considered much of this information to be no one’s business but our own.

But thousands of companies would like to make our business their business. And with the Internet and cookie tracking, they can.

The Wall Street Journal has been running a series on personal data collection by Internet companies. They’ve proved what many suspected: unchecked data collection is eliminating our traditional zone of privacy.

The WSJ lays out the case of Linda Twombly, a senior citizen in New Hampshire, that it identified from data provided by one ad network, RapLeaf.

The data covered dozens of aspects of her life. The Journal was able to decode 26 of these segments.

Who cares?
Some argue that if we are doing something that we don’t want other people to know about, then maybe we shouldn’t be doing it. Or that the benefits of advertising that targets our interests outweigh a modest loss of privacy.

But not all personal details are created equal. An interest in radio controlled model aircraft is one thing. The fact that we support legal medical marijuana is very different.

Students of history know that activities acceptable in one decade can invite ridicule or worse in another. In the 1940s the Soviet Union was our ally in World War II. We sent billions of dollars in aid and they bore the brunt of the battle against the Nazi war machine.

But a decade later congressional committees were hounding those suspected of being too sympathetic to the Soviet Union. Careers were destroyed, huge legal bills incurred and lives were disrupted for years.

Does the average Internet user know how much is being collected and who is buying it? Clearly, the answer is no.

Take some control
Commendably, some in online advertising know that they can choose between regulating themselves and being regulated by our democratically elected representatives. The Network Advertising Initiative is a group of over 60 advertising networks that track your Internet behavior.

They’ll tell you how many networks are on your system. I was startled to find I had cookies from all but 5.

Enter one of your e-mail addresses, click “select all” and submit. They’ll send a confirming e-mail with a link. Click on that and you’re done. Enter as many e-mail addresses as you use.

The Storage Bits take
Massive storage and the Internet are wonderful things. But like many other wonderful things they have unintended consequences.

One of those consequences is the loss of personal privacy. In the abstract having advertising targeted to our personal issues and concerns is a good thing.

But should a grandmother surfing the web with her six-year-old grandchild have to answer the question “Grandma, what is herpes?”

The NAI is giving some control back to us. I urge every reader to see what networks are tracking you today. I doubt that plugs every hole in our online privacy. But it’s a start.

Comments welcome, of course.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

More from “Storage Bits”

Topics

Robin Harris has been messing with computers for over 30 years and selling and marketing data storage for over 20 in companies large and small.

Disclosure

Robin Harris

Robin Harris is a president of TechnoQWAN, a consulting and analyst firm in northern Arizona. He also writes StorageMojo.com, a blog which accepts advertising from companies in the storage industry, and has a 25 year history with IT vendors. He has many industry contacts, many of whom are friends and all of whom he has opinions about. Robin has relationships with many companies in the technology industry. Every company he writes about may have sought to influence his opinion through carefully-crafted marketing messages and self-serving white papers, gifts ranging from desk calendars, t-shirts, lunches and trips as well as analyst or consulting assignments. He also invests in some technology companies. He may accept payment for services in stock as well. Robin discloses financial investments in or client relationships with companies named in Storage Bits. To help readers sort out the gold from the dross in his writings, Robin tries to communicate his reasons as clearly as he can. If you agree, you are intelligent and discerning. If you disagree, well, you disagree. In all cases, Robin encourages readers to subject everything they read, see or hear on the internet or from politicians to some simple questions: * What assumptions are implicit in the world view and judgments of the author? * What, if any, is the factual basis for the opinions the author expresses? * Is it reasonable, logical and clear? Your critical faculties: use ‘em or lose ‘em!

Biography

Robin Harris

Harris has been messing with computers for over 30 years and selling and marketing data storage for over 20 in companies large and small. He introduced a couple of multi-billion dollar storage products (DLT, the first Fibre Channel array) to market, as well as a many smaller ones. Earlier he spent 10 years marketing servers and networks. After leaving corporate life he founded TechnoQWAN, a consulting and analyst firm. He also developed StorageMojo into one of the top storage industry blogs.

Robin writes, consults, coaches and lives among the mountains of northern Arizona.

Related Discussions on TechRepublic

Did you know you can take part in these discussions with your ZDNet membership?
54
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

don?t feel alone or rejected,
chloe1023 2nd Nov 2010
If you have been diagnosed with an STD, don?t feel alone or rejected, you have found? the place that will help you ?Continue to Live?!

The doctor recommend me a STD dating site: STDmatching,com. Most of us here can face the condition correctly.
0 Votes
+ -
where's the url for out-out ?
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
RE: Opt out of 60 ad networks in 3 minutes
R Harris Updated - 26th Oct 2010
@jinishans
Thanks for flagging this. In a rush to get to Silicon Valley today for the OpenStorage Summit I neglected to put text into the link.

Fixed.

Robin
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Opt out of 60 ad networks in 3 minutes
razzamatazzer@... 26th Oct 2010
@jinishahttp:

//www.networkadvertising.org/managing/opt_out.aspns
0 Votes
+ -
I found I had to override my browser's cookie settings to accept 3rd party cookies for all the networks to take effect.
0 Votes
+ -
Got link?
bg7566 26th Oct 2010
just sayin
0 Votes
+ -
This is useless because
Stan57 26th Oct 2010
This is useless because if you delete cookies or have them deleted automatically you will have to do this all over again,daily.
NO advertiser should be spying on what we do without us being able to opt-in to giving the information of what we do in the internet.
0 Votes
+ -
Stan57 gets a cookie!

This is worse than useless, because the very method provided to grant us a minimal amount of control (based solely upon trust) of a non-trustworthy third party entity requires that we disable the only thing that grants any protection now.

I don't know about you, but I'll keep dumping any cookies accumulated during a session after every session, thank you.
0 Votes
+ -
@Stan57 I agree. Ironically, when I clicked the link the first thing they wanted me to accept a cookie. Of course I said Deny. End of story.
0 Votes
+ -
@Stan57

I would think that the SITE cookies are the ones you want to keep. The cookies for the ad banners and such? Not so much.
When they start to spam an alias, delete it.

Been doing this for years... you would be suprised that most people dont question when i give them an email with their company name in at my domain name. I just tell them, spam it and i will delete the account.

Generally companies wont spam me, but some choose to start or sell my info, so i just delete them and never have to deal with them again. Also helps me create a blacklist of companies i will try not to deal with again.

You could also give them a catch all email and only go in to retrieve specific emails, just make sure it clears mail automatically.
0 Votes
+ -
@Been_Done_Before

Sounds like way too much work to be worth the time. I'll let other people filter for me instead.
0 Votes
+ -
@MisterFish are you that lazy. It took about 3 minutes, really. Guess you must have a lot of important work to do or are just incredibly self-centered and lazy as can be.
  • Flagged
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Opt out of 60 ad networks in 3 minutes
Garrett Williams 27th Oct 2010
@MisterFish It's really not much work. Yahoo offers a throwaway email service for a fee, too, although I personally use a catch-all address on my own domain and it gives me GREAT control of my email, even knowing who gave the spammer my email address, based on what address it's sent to. I've blocked a few "to:" addresses and haven't heard from those spammers since. As a bonus, my Gmail account grabs email from my catch-all, making things even easier.
Even my friends are given throw-away addresses, heh. I hate email postcard sites.
0 Votes
+ -
@MisterFish
Other people's filters (such as Zone Alarm's and our ISP's) are unreliable, sometimes trapping very normal looking emails while sometimes letting through very obvious spam. Dealing with their flaws is a real nuisance.

I have been giving out unique email addresses on my URL for many years and it works great. About the only time I have to give someone an email address is when I'm also setting up a password, so it's all part of the same process and my password program keeps track of both the email addresses and the passwords. No trouble at all.
0 Votes
+ -
@Been_Done_Before Yahoo! premium membership for $20 per year has the same capability. Create disposable inboxes on-the-fly, delete them if they become spam magnets, plus POP3 and webmail that work well, and one of the best spam filters I've seen. I'm coming up on one year of a trial run, and I'm happy.
0 Votes
+ -
@Been_Done_Before You don't even have to buy a domain, most mail-host services allow you to set up 'dummy' email aliases with an extra entry in the domain section of the address.

As for filtering the email, set up a filter that redirects all mail NOT sent to a specific address into the Bulk Mail bucket. You can then review, or delete, at your leisure.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Opt out of 60 ad networks in 3 minutes
Garrett Williams 27th Oct 2010
@Been_Done_Before I even give my FRIENDS throw-away email addresses for me. After receiving email postcards from various sites, I found this to be a great solution.
It gets tricky when I have to come up with an email address on the fly. "Erm, it's fromxyzcompany@..." "No, I want YOUR address". I've had to explain my throwaway email system to various people. I tell them "It helps to verify who sent me the email, especially if I don't recognize the email address it's coming from." A nice way of saying, "If the address gets to a spammer, I know who gave it to them.", but it's come in handy when I didn't know who an email was from, too. On resumes, I have to be extra creative so it doesn't look like a throw-away address, & keep a record of the trickier ones.

I definitely recommend this solution to people, & feel free to simplify things. It's probably okay to give one email address on all job applications, since it's likely going straight to the trash anyway. Oh, and if you do this, immediately block the addresses "info@", "marketing@", and "sales@". First-hand experience.
0 Votes
+ -
Where do you plug in your e-mail address?
Smart_Neuron 26th Oct 2010
Hmm... I don't see it.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Opt out of 60 ad networks in 3 minutes
phil8192 Updated - 26th Oct 2010
@Smart_Neuron You don't. Instead, you accept a new set of persistent cookies from www(dot)networkadvertising(dot)org. It's obviously not portable from machine to machine. For every machine you run, you'll need to visit the site and run the opt-out dialog again, and again if you purge all your browser cookies.
0 Votes
+ -
@phil8192 It is rather ironic that, in order to invalidate up to 60 different cookies, you have to.... (wait for it... ) set a cookie.
0 Votes
+ -
I must be missing something...
RandyLyon 26th Oct 2010
Based on what I read and heard on the opt out site, this just stops you from seeing targeted ads. I didn't see anything that says they won't keep tracking you or selling information. Like I said, maybe I missed that.
0 Votes
+ -
Email address?
levinson 26th Oct 2010
I clicked on the link but see nowhere to enter an email address. It looks like this just reviews the cookies in your browser. Then you should repeat this for each browser you use, right?
0 Votes
+ -
Every browser, every computer
MisterFish 26th Oct 2010
@levinson

In the FAQ:

11. Will I ever need to renew my opt-out or opt out again?
If you ever delete the "opt-out cookie" from your browser, buy a new computer, or change Web browsers, you'll need to perform the opt-out task again. It's only when the network advertiser can read an "opt-out" cookie on your browser that it can know you have decided not to participate.
0 Votes
+ -
@MisterFish: but where do I enter my email address, as stated in the original article? "Enter one of your e-mail addresses, click ?select all? and submit."
0 Votes
+ -
I don't see anywhere to plug in your email addresses either. Come on, Robin, doesn't anyone proof their stories any more??!
0 Votes
+ -
Well, I don't see anywhere on the opt-out page to enter an e-mail address, but even so, it really doesn't make any sense anyway. We're talking about browser cookies here -- How does that correlate to an e-mail address? I can't see that it does.

I think that instead, you probably should say, "Perform this action from each web browser on each of your computers, and again as often as you delete your cookies."

-=B
0 Votes
+ -
Great article.........a real service to us!
0 Votes
+ -
Found it wasn't necessary
Dr. John 26th Oct 2010
Using Firefox with NoScript, Ghostery and AdBlock Plus, when I went to the website, I discovered, as I suspected, that there were no tracking cookies from these folks on my system. Gotta love good plugins!
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Found it wasn't necessary
LStewart 26th Oct 2010
@Dr. John The only one you are missing is BetterPrivacy. Use it to kill all of the flash plugin tracking.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Opt out of 60 ad networks in 3 minutes
fatman65535 26th Oct 2010
@LStewart

Exactly!

And, have Firefox set to delete your cache on exit. Screw advertisers.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Opt out of 60 ad networks in 3 minutes
blaacksheep 26th Oct 2010
@Dr. John

That, and having disabled 3rd party cookies gave me a clean bill of health on their page, too. I'm surely not going to enable 3rd party cookies just to carry their opt-out cookies.
0 Votes
+ -
Why bother with having another company put another cookie on your computer. Set your browser to delete all temp internet files and cookies when you close your session. Or set your browser to not use cookies!

You can go even farther.....Install Firefox and then install the following extensions: BetterPrivacy, Ghostery, AdBlock Plus and IE Tab (for those narrow minded IE only programmers).

AdBlock Plus blocks 90% of ads on pages, ones that do not get blocked can easily be added to your block list by right clicking on the ad and selecting the option from the menu.

BetterPrivacy deals with a majority of the tracking that is really done on computers - - THROUGH FLASH plugins. You can delete all the cookies you want, but the flash based ads on pages don't use them. This plugin removes them when you close you browser.

Ghostery is a script blocking plugin that prevents approx 380 know tracking scripts that companies use to track your information without using cookies. Don't want Google gathering info with their Analytics BS, use this.

Cookies tracking is very much last decade and century. Come into the 21st century with much better privacy/security tools.
0 Votes
+ -
At least they are making it somewhat easier to stop ad tracking - and they are open about it.
Course you cannot use (in IE) the default delete cookie function since it would wipe out the cookie on the system stating that you don't want the ad cookie on your system for each network.
This pushes to another problem and thus you have to use a 3rd party app like CC Cleaner that allows you to maintain a list of cookies NOT to delete and delete all others when you want run their delete routine. It's a shame IE (other browsers?) does the all or nothing approach to cleaning cache items.
The other way is of course to set the browser to ALWAYS ASK before letting a cookie onto your system and have the broswer then permanetly block the cookie domain - but that too is an all or nothing and each page load question which is unworkable for the end user. Of course on some web sites you would have to click around 20 times before a page loads!
0 Votes
+ -
Browser plug-in
linuxlubber 26th Oct 2010
I've been using the TACO add-in for FireFox. It shows the tracking sites in use at the site you visit. Amazing to see how much is tracking you. It does give you the opportunity to block...not sure how effective it really is.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Opt out of 60 ad networks in 3 minutes
telecomsearch 26th Oct 2010
NAI program has a serious bug.
I use W7 Pro X64 and Firefox 3.6.11. Firefox failed to boot after loading plug-in and all selected advertiser cookie control entities. Remedied by using Firefox Safe Mode and uninstalling NAI plug-in.
0 Votes
+ -
i only had 5
g_keramidas@... Updated - 26th Oct 2010
with active cookies. but i have a long list of sites i've added to restricted sites on the security tab and sites on the privacy tab of ie. i export them from the registry regularly so i can import them all again if i need to add them to a clean pc.
i rarely see those ad sense/intellitxt links, either.
0 Votes
+ -
Spam or web based opt out?
modemjunkie 26th Oct 2010
As others noted, I don't see any email address field.
Hmmm. Still don't see any email address field as others noted.
But why should there be. Does this address spam emails or only web based advertising based on tracking cookies.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Opt out of 60 ad networks in 3 minutes
redcaboosejr@... 26th Oct 2010
As a computer user who knows just enough to really mess my computer up, I hope you will further expand on your article. I'd appreciate learning how to remove what ever these blood sucking, privacy invading ad companies are or have installed on my computer, especially Google.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Opt out of 60 ad networks in 3 minutes
daboogiemansass 26th Oct 2010
The best solution I've found is to only accept cookies where >I feel I need/want to. This helps:
https://addons.mozilla.org/mn/firefox/addon/4703/
0 Votes
+ -
This is a big waste of time. The biggest purveyor of surreptitious spyware is Google. It is very difficult to go anywhere on the internet without some bit of Google script spying on you even if you don't use their services or apps. If you do, there is no hope.

And yet, there are seldom headlines about all the spying that Google is doing. They are the most dangerous accumulator of information in the world.
0 Votes
+ -
(although you don't have to LEAVE "third-party cookies" enabled). This overall approach doesn't solve EVERYthing, but it is a start, and qualifies as "raising awareness of the issue".

But for you who obsess, and have a bit of free time, consider this -- you now have a fairly complete list of ad-network URLs which can be (fairly) easily boiled down into a HOSTS file add-in -- adding to your list of "the usual suspects" who don't get access to you.

The only difficulty I've seen with this approach is the occasional "feed ME first" ad-network URL which leads a chain of "alias as" and "refer to" URLs. Which simply requires a bit of address bar select-and-delete to get past, while reinforcing "dodged THAT one" in your mind.
And while you're digging around in your Temporary Internet Files, you should probably read up (somewhere around here) on "flash cookies" too. NOT clear whether ad-networks have shifted toward those, much, but I was surprised at just how much "debris" I cleaned out when I went looking.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Opt out of 60 ad networks in 3 minutes
Pro Covers FX 26th Oct 2010
Well, they say that if you do it on the Web it is public information!

I say if they install $hit on my computer in my house on my property that they are trasspassing and it is against my consitution rights of privacy!!!
0 Votes
+ -
Seems pointless...
max_wedge 26th Oct 2010
I regularly purge my internet cache anyway, including cookies. So I don't have anyone collecting data off me except when I visit their site, and tbh I don't really care about that. They can't get at my real name (not even facebook has that) nor my address oranything truly personal. Who cares if they know what I like to buy?
0 Votes
+ -
This is next to useless to me. I regularly clear my internet cache. I don't care what they think anyway as long as they aren't (and they can't anyway) accessing my personal data (my documents, pictures etc)
0 Votes
+ -
Apparently, I have no cookies from any of these sites. I guess it pays to black list all cookies by default.....actually that's 0 on FF. I have most on IE, though I rarely use IE, so I'm not sure how much it matter. Nevertheless, I opted out on IE.
0 Votes
+ -
Ad-Block does wonders
Ludovit 27th Oct 2010
for in browser ads ... doesn't help with e-mail ads though ...

Ludo
0 Votes
+ -
to 127.0.0.1 on my host file (universal loop back address).
End of problem. The cookies are still there, but the data goes to limbo land!
0 Votes
+ -
not on their radar
xambassador 27th Oct 2010
I ran the check. Status for each member company showed that their cookie was not on my machine. Why? Running Opera set to accept no cookies and delete all cookies upon closing. Hotmail doesn't like it (have to enter password twice), but who cares.
0 Votes
+ -
don?t feel alone or rejected,
chloe1023 2nd Nov 2010
If you have been diagnosed with an STD, don?t feel alone or rejected, you have found? the place that will help you ?Continue to Live?!

The doctor recommend me a STD dating site: STDmatching,com. Most of us here can face the condition correctly.

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix