Technicon

Jeffrey S. Young

More Microsoft Chinese Backscratching

By | April 26, 2006, 10:33am PDT

Summary: I’m not advocating a Fortress America attitude, just wondering why we can’t have leaders who’ll combine a desire to make money with a willingness to speak out enough to nudge repressive regimes towards more humane policies.

A few hours after my last post on Bill Gates’ unconscionable silence over China’s sorry political and personal freedoms, ZDNet has reported on a whole new series of agreements between Microsoft and China.  This is more evidence of the lack of moral fiber, and the dominance of money and megalomania at the expense of courage in the global economy.

I’m not advocating a Fortress America attitude, just wondering why we can’t have leaders who’ll combine a desire to make money with a willingness to speak out enough to nudge repressive regimes towards more humane policies.  If we believe—and I do—that business and commerce can change the world for good, doesn’t it behoove those who are profiting from this to use their success to try and make the world a better place?

So I’m bemoaning our country’s business leaders’ seeming inability to look at the big picture, pointing out how pouring billions into China may reap short term benefits but also props up a corrupt regime.  At the same time a good friend, Dave Churbuck, is in China right now and is filing a series of fascinating blog reports about what he is discovering here, and here and here.  They are all worth reading, and while I might argue with him that he’s being a bit naïve in his view of the cultural landscape, there is no mistaking the passion, and intelligence, and exuberance that he is encountering.  Not to mention his.

So, what is the right way to engage with a reactionary country that has unleashed the floodgates of commerce?  Will the rise of the middle class inevitably lead to a relaxation of political and personal freedom in China that will create a society as open and extraordinary as our own?  Or is the great sucking sound of our money, know-how, ideas, and innovations heading across the Pacific going to end up with us as an emaciated hull, in thrall to a resurgent China?

Right now it looks like the Global Economy is a one-way superhighway when it comes to China.  My argument is that the greatest export America can make is simple, eternal, and awe-inspiring: “We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men are created equal; that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights; that among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.” 

If all we can export is Microsoft Windows, McDonalds, KFC, and Starbucks, we’re not only shortchanging the Chinese, we’re shortchanging ourselves.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

More from “Technicon”

Topics

Biography

Jeffrey S. Young is the author of two books about Steve Jobs--iCon Steve Jobs and Steve Jobs The Journey is the Reward--as well as several others about science and technology. Along the way, Young has worked and written for many magazines and newspapers, including Forbes, Wired, The Hollywood Reporter, MacWorld, Esquire, and the San Jose Mercury News. He currently tends a small vineyard in Northern California.

5
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

What we export
Chiatzu 29th Apr 2006
I agree with your ideals of how American companies should
operate under the umbrella of a foreign influence. American
corporations, whether they realize it or not, represent the
American image to the people of the country in which they
reside. Not all of these images are necessarily positive, but I
suppose they fit well into China's voracious economic hunger
and rapid growth on the whole.

I get the feeling that any power we have begins on the
bargaining table, before even setting foot in China. Though it
appears we are currently losing the battle. I think that incentives
of some kind, government tax breaks or other temptations are
necessary to curb ongoing backscratching. Then again, shouts
of 'Show me the money!' (spoken in Mandarin) are practically
mantras in some companies.

As far as curtailing software piracy in China and Microsoft's deal
for licensing, I wonder if it wll make an appreciable impact.
China isn't exactly known for their strict enforcement of DVD
pirating, for instance. They have had a few examples made
known in popular press, but word is pirate DVDs are available on
the street, just about everywhere. Piracy feeds their commerce
and doing as little about it as possible is in their best interest.
We shall see how Bill and crew fares.

I wonder if the gentleman you mentioned, the guy writing the
blog regarding his travels in China, ever figured out how to work
a proxy. I'd be interested to learn how far over the fence of
Chinese government Internet censorship he can actually peek.
0 Votes
+ -
"Resisitance is futile...you WILL be assimilated"
This "BORG-ian" statement WILL come to pass as "We the Sheeple" blindly concume ourselves into mind-altered submission...all for the hedonistic pleasures of "Babylon, the Harlot"!
The citizens of Rome were slaughtered by the "Barbarians at the Gates" (PUN intended!) and so will we! George Orwell, we are here.
0 Votes
+ -
Great article...one correction
valkyrie777 28th Apr 2006
"...all men are created equal..."?? it is going to need to read "...all men and women are created equal..." China is missing 50 million women to gender-based abortion, infanticide, and murder. Ergo, we should probably also export the idea that killing people because of tradition is unacceptable. (for more info., take a look at "Development as Freedom," by Amartya Sen)
0 Votes
+ -
Interesting reading about China:
btljooz 28th Apr 2006
http://www.clearwisdom.net/emh/156/

Be sure to go through that website with a fine-toothed comb!

This is the country that our 'Big Business' is in bed with. UUHHGGMMM...who buys and pays for OUR 'gov'???

THINK about all this.................
0 Votes
+ -
Intention
bigpicture 28th Apr 2006
You are missing the whole root cause of the issue. Yes governments and businesses could make the world a better place, that is not in question. So then what is stopping them, well the answer is INTENTION.

If something is not an INTENTION in the first place, it will probably never happen. How many corporate mission statements have you seen the state "make the world a better place" as one of the vision items. Or government policy for that matter. The closest that I have seen is Googles "do no evil", which is really only an expression of what they intend NOT TO DO.

So is it not more about money, growth, greed, self interest? How does this have any relationship to, or interest in human rights?
0 Votes
+ -
What we export
Chiatzu 29th Apr 2006
I agree with your ideals of how American companies should
operate under the umbrella of a foreign influence. American
corporations, whether they realize it or not, represent the
American image to the people of the country in which they
reside. Not all of these images are necessarily positive, but I
suppose they fit well into China's voracious economic hunger
and rapid growth on the whole.

I get the feeling that any power we have begins on the
bargaining table, before even setting foot in China. Though it
appears we are currently losing the battle. I think that incentives
of some kind, government tax breaks or other temptations are
necessary to curb ongoing backscratching. Then again, shouts
of 'Show me the money!' (spoken in Mandarin) are practically
mantras in some companies.

As far as curtailing software piracy in China and Microsoft's deal
for licensing, I wonder if it wll make an appreciable impact.
China isn't exactly known for their strict enforcement of DVD
pirating, for instance. They have had a few examples made
known in popular press, but word is pirate DVDs are available on
the street, just about everywhere. Piracy feeds their commerce
and doing as little about it as possible is in their best interest.
We shall see how Bill and crew fares.

I wonder if the gentleman you mentioned, the guy writing the
blog regarding his travels in China, ever figured out how to work
a proxy. I'd be interested to learn how far over the fence of
Chinese government Internet censorship he can actually peek.

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix