Blogging wields power again--sort of

Blogging wields power again--sort of

Summary: Some of you may remember the story I wrote last year in this blog about a lifestyle columnist who was forced to resign from her job, after bloggers expressed outrage over comments she made about overseas Filipino workers. That episode demonstrated how blogging has emerged as a new and powerful medium where ordinary folks can air their opinions and grievances, regardless of whether they're legitimate or not.

SHARE:
TOPICS: Legal
3

Some of you may remember the story I wrote last year in this blog about a lifestyle columnist who was forced to resign from her job, after bloggers expressed outrage over comments she made about overseas Filipino workers. That episode demonstrated how blogging has emerged as a new and powerful medium where ordinary folks can air their opinions and grievances, regardless of whether they're legitimate or not.

There's now a new issue that is threatening to put a real test on whether blogging is indeed a revolutionary communication tool, or just merely a tech scourge that does nothing to help clear the air of confusion.

The case I'm referring to is the controversial blog of Australian Brian Gorrell, whose account of an ill-fated relationship with his Filipino ex-boyfriend, coupled with juicy criticisms of some members of the so-called high society, has attracted thousands upon thousands of curious visitors daily.

The word controversial is an understatement. The blog has actually created a firestorm in the local scene, with the media, the legal community and the public all keeping a close watch and eager to find out the conclusion of this real-life soap-opera.

Lawyers who have been interviewed on the subject are unanimous in saying that the accusations hurled by Gorrell in his blog are downright libelous. In fact, a local television show which tackled the issue said providing a link to the site can be construed as something like abetting a crime and is therefore illegal.

Although I find this notion quite puzzling, perhaps it's better that I also choose not to publish the site's URL here...but, no doubt, you'll be able to Google the guy and get more information.

I'm not about to comment on the arguments raised by Gorrell because I don't have any personal knowledge on those issues. I'm not a lawyer either so I'm not in a position to point out the legal infirmities in his blog.

However, as a member of the news media, I find it both amusing and disturbing that bloggers like Gorrell are being threatened with libel suits--something that was once applicable only to media entities. Not only is the legal action difficult to implement, especially for someone like Gorrell who is located outside of the Philippines, but any attempt to do seems counterproductive to me.

In my view, a blog is merely a personal journal or diary. It just so happens that it is on the Internet and has the capability to generate feedback from the people who read them. The trouble starts when we treat them as a member of the media, which, unlike the general blogging community, are bound by journalistic rules.

Except for some few bloggers (perhaps like the ones here in ZDNet Asia, which, by the way, is a news media company), most bloggers don't pretend to be reporters or sources of legitimate news. It is actually the general public and readers who treat their stories as hard news--and that shouldn't be the case.

Blogs, as far as I'm concerned, are no different from text messages or e-mail messages passed on or read by many people. It's primarily a technology tool that enables messages of any kind to be broadcast, but that's just about it to blogs.

Topic: Legal

Melvin G. Calimag

About Melvin G. Calimag

Melvin G. Calimag is currently the executive editor of an IT news website in the Philippines. Melvin has been covering the local IT beat for the last 13 years. He is currently a board member at the IT Journalists Association of the Philippines (CyberPress), and also serves as a charter member with the Philippine Science Journalists Association.

Joel D. Pinaroc

About Joel D. Pinaroc

Joel has been a media practitioner since 1996, starting off as a reporter and eventually becoming editor of a pioneering IT trade newspaper in Manila. He is currently one of the content producers of a Manila-based developmental website.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

3 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • Blogging wields power again--sort of

    Well, if you have any power as a blogger, try to get Zdnetasia to test their web site with Firefox (I am using 2.0.0.13 on XP SP2). On the main page, the "Latest News", "Most Popular" and "Most Discussed" sections show only tabs - the pages are blank.

    Appalling for a technical publication such as Zdnetasia.
    anonymous
  • Blogging wields power again--sort of

    hi "iggy Evans",

    Thanks for your comment. However, we were unable to replicate the problem you described. If this issue persists on your end, do contact us directly so we can help resolve the bug.
    We regularly monitor our site on both Firefox and Internet Explorer for potential bugs and to ensure page formats remain consistent on both platforms. Some minor bugs will inevitably appear now and then, and we seek our readers' understanding here as it may sometimes take a little longer for us to resolve the issue.

    Regards,
    Eileen Yu
    Senior Editor, ZDNet Asia
    eileen.yu
  • Blogging wields power again--sort of

    Thanks for the prompt response, Eileen. It works now. On my behalf, please thank the person who fixed it :-)

    Bloggers do have power!
    anonymous