Clegg: Gov't may lack powers to keep McKinnon in UK

Clegg: Gov't may lack powers to keep McKinnon in UK

Summary: Deputy prime minister Nick Clegg has said it may not be possible for the coalition government to halt the Nasa hacker's extradition to the US after all


Deputy prime minister Nick Clegg has said the government may be powerless to keep Nasa hacker Gary McKinnon in the UK, despite the Liberal Democrats' pre-election pledge to do so.

In the months leading up to the general election, Lib Dem leader Clegg said he believed legal mechanisms were in place that could allow the government to halt McKinnon's extradition to the US to face charges of hacking into military systems. However, in an interview on Radio Five on Tuesday, Clegg said the legal picture appears to be less clear than his legal advisers had made it seem.

"What I haven't got the power to do — and neither has the home secretary nor the prime minister — is to completely reverse and undo certain legal aspects of this (case)," Clegg said. "That, of course, you wouldn't want any politician to do. That's what we're looking at at the moment. It's legally very complex."

Before the election, the Liberal Democrats said they would push to halt the extradition, no matter what the outcome of the polls. After the election, the party entered into a coalition government with the Conservatives, who have also expressed reservations about the extradition.

Read this

Tech election 2010

Labour, Tories, Lib Dems and other parties outline their tech policies on open source, government IT and other issues

Read more+

The Lib Dems also promised a Freedom Bill which would, among other things, be aimed at making changes to the UK/US extradition treaty introduced under the Labour government and which is has been criticised for a lack of reciprocity on the US side.

In the interview, Clegg said he hadn't changed his mind on the "morality and the principle" of the matter. "It would be the right thing to do to have Gary McKinnon tried in this country," he said.

McKinnon, who suffers from Asperger syndrome, hacked into 97 US military systems between 2001 and 2002 in what he claims was a search for evidence of extraterrestrial life. According to the US authorities, he caused $700,000 (£485,000) damage and should stand trial in that country. If convicted in the US, he could be sentenced to 70 years in a maximum security federal prison.

A succession of Labour home secretaries, including Jacqui Smith and Alan Johnson, refused to intervene in McKinnon's case. Johnson declined to halt the extradition despite fresh evidence of McKinnon being suicidal and on medication — a decision that was to have been reviewed by the administrative court at the Royal Courts of Justice this week.

That review was halted by new home secretary Theresa May, a Conservative, in order to carry out a re-examination of the case, following an appeal for action by McKinnon's legal team.

Topics: Government UK, Security

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


1 comment
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • USA pressure no doubt. This was always to be expected, since they couldn't believe that Labour was giving them the right to extradite people without providing the key evidence that THIS PERSON did THAT CRIME.

    Lots of other evidence is provided, the nature of the crime (e.g. murder is a serious crime in US law, therefore it comes under this treaty), and the identity of the person (Fred Bloggs, 5'6'', dark hair, ....) but it's all tangential to the case.

    Who cares if McKinnon is a fruit loop, his right is to a judicial process before punishment. Extradition is a punishment (akin to BANISHMENT of olden days). He has the right to see and challenge the evidence first, the proper evidence, not some tangential twaddlings.

    The treaty can be cancelled by Clegg it is a voluntary agreement between the US and UK. The Home Secretary has to approve the extradition, he can unapprove it.

    Don't give in to US pressure, show a bit of spine.