Developers: help fix our convoluted patent system

Developers: help fix our convoluted patent system

Summary: The U.S. Patent and Trademark office seeks software developers' input on enhancing the quality of software patents, and will host roundtables next month in Silicon Valley and New York.


Groklaw reports that the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office "would like to form a partership with the software community" to figure out how to "enhance" the quality of software patents. The agency is seeking comments, and will be hosting two roundtable events in February, one in Silicon Valley and one in New York.

According to the USPTO's request, it is seeking comments (at a live forum and via email -- see below) "on how to more effectively ensure that the boundaries of a claim are clear so that the public can understand what subject matter is protected by the patent claim and the patent examiner can identify and apply the most pertinent prior art." The agency also seeks "specific claim examples and supporting disclosure" to illustrate the points made.

To register for the roundtables (must be done by February 4):

"Send an email message to and provide the following information: (1) Your name, title, and if applicable, company or organization, address, phone number, and email address; (2) which roundtable event you wish to attend (Silicon Valley or New York City); and (3) if you wish to make an oral presentation at the event, the specific topic or issue to be addressed and the approximate desired length of your presentation."

To provide comments (must be submitted by March 15):

Send an email to on one or all of the three topics of discussion:

1) "How to improve clarity of claim boundaries that define the scope of patent protection for claims that use functional language."

2) "Identify additional topics for future discussion by the Software Partnership."

3) "A forthcoming Request for Comments on Preparation of Patent Applications and offers an opportunity for oral presentations on the Request for Comments at the Silicon Valley and New York City roundtable events. Written comments are requested in response to the first two discussion topics. Written comments on the third discussion topic must be submitted as directed in the forthcoming Request for Comments on Preparation of Patent Applications."




Topic: Software Development

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


Log in or register to join the discussion
  • Please wait!

    I am in the process of patenting rectangle icons. Once I do this, feel free to overhaul the patenting system.
  • Open it up for public feedback on obviousness and prior art

    And make it that any ip used in a standard is public. Done.
    Johnny Vegas
  • Make the time shorter

    Software has a much shorter life cycle than most physical items. It should have a mush shorter patent.
  • Developers: help fix our convoluted patent system

    the current patent system may look like advantageous to us, but in the long run it will be its achilles' heels. as can be gleaned from todays headlines, patents changed hands every so often that sooner or later us patents will be transferred to those who possesses wealth to own them. so far, us corporations are on the top of the heap, but the future is uncertain considering that us market will be smaller compared to the emerging economies in asia.
  • Any Tinkering Is Just Going To Make It More Convoluted

    Given the powerful pressure groups benefiting from the current mess, who will benefit even more the messier it gets, I don't see much hope for any incremental "fixing". Ultimately, you have to concede that all patents are Government-granted monopolies, and such monopolies have no place in a competitive free market.

    Scrap the lot.