Facebook faces facial feature scrutiny in Germany

Facebook faces facial feature scrutiny in Germany

Summary: Data protection authorities in Hamburg have dropped a complaint over Facebook's Friend Finder feature, but have warned the social-networking firm over its facial-recognition technology


Data protection authorities in the German city of Hamburg have warned Facebook to change its facial-recognition data-retention policies, while dropping a previous complaint against the social network over its Friend Finder feature.

Facebook facial recognition feature

Data protection authorities in Hamburg, Germany are scrutinising Facebook's introduction of facial-recognition tech to suggest name tags in photos. Photo credit: Facebook

The city's data protection chief, Johannes Caspar, said Facebook might have to pay a €300,000 (£262,000) fine over the facial-recognition functionality. The feature, which scans users' photos in an attempt to recognise and tag their contacts, has also caused concern at the UK Information Commissioner's Office.

Caspar told ZDNet UK on Thursday that he was worried about the fact the facial-recognition feature was turned on by default, but more concerned that Facebook might be retaining the biometric information it gathers even when the user opts out. He said this was not compliant with EU and German data protection laws.

"We told Facebook that they should decide within two weeks whether to execute our request to delete the data or not," Caspar said. "If they say 'We won't delete the data and we will collect further biometric data', then we will come to a decision about what legal measures we will take."

Read this

Schneier: Facebook kills privacy for profit

Social-networking sites such as Facebook are eroding privacy to sell content to advertisers, according to BT chief security technology officer Bruce Schneier

Read more+

Caspar noted that the maximum fine the Hamburg data protection authority can levy for such breaches is €300,000.

However, Caspar also revealed that he had dropped another complaint against Facebook in the same letter to the social network. That legal procedure was in connection with the company's Friend Finder feature, which lets people send invitations to others to join them on the network.

"We didn't think the Friend Finder feature met the standard of German data protection law [but] we told Facebook [on Tuesday] that we would not levy a fine because they said they would co-operate and changed their system," Caspar said. "They gave an opt-out to people who don't want any invitations to join Facebook."

Caspar also pointed out that Facebook users now have more control over the invitations they send. "At first, the user didn't know when Facebook was sending an invitation from their account, nor what the content of the invitation was," he said.

A Facebook spokesman told ZDNet UK that the company "will consider the points the Hamburg Data Protection Authority have made about the photo tag suggest feature but firmly [rejects] any claim that we are not meeting our obligations under European Union data protection law". He added that the facial recognition data "is deleted" when the user opts out. 

"We have also found that people like the convenience of our photo tag suggest feature which makes it easier and safer for them to manage their online identities," the spokesman said.

Get the latest technology news and analysis, blogs and reviews delivered directly to your inbox with ZDNet UK's newsletters.

Topic: Legal

David Meyer

About David Meyer

David Meyer is a freelance technology journalist. He fell into journalism when he realised his musical career wouldn't pay the bills. David's main focus is on communications, as well as internet technologies, regulation and mobile devices.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


1 comment
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • I'm a teacher and feel especially threatened by the Chinese-style monitoring Facebook is implementing in the West. It's all the more a threat given how it goes out of its way to invade and pervert people's privacy. Just look at the risks in simply using Facebook to comment: Websites are permitted, without any real reason, to access your basic information including your name, "profile picture, gender, networks, user ID, list of friends and any other information I've shared with everyone". It allows the site to send you unsolicited email. It can actually send any post it wants to your Wall- status messages, notes, photos, videos, etc... You have absolutely no control over the content. Worryingly is can "access my data any time" without saying exactly what data it will be accessing and for what purpose, and even "access my data when I'm not using the application." All very useful when Facebook tries to convince the Chinese to let it be allowed to be used within that country in exchange for such valuable information and technology; just the type of behaviour fascist states need! Thank God I live in Germany that is putting a stop to this- so much for America being the land of the free...